The Official Forum - Walk this way ?

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)

- Softball (https://forum.officiating.com/softball/)

- - Walk this way ? (https://forum.officiating.com/softball/52268-walk-way.html)

Quote:

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA (Post 588455)

Depends. If I believe the purpose is a personnel/line-up issue or maybe even an equipment issue, I'll close the gap.

If it is to discuss a play or call and they want to instigate a discusson, they are coming to me with one exception. If the umpire makes a mistake which needs correcting or a brain fart (i.e. verbal safe with out signal), I would probably go to coach if s/he isn't already there :rolleyes:.

I do not believe an umpire should ever move toward a player/coach who is about to question a call, ruling or heritage. It can appear to be a defensive or agressive action by the umpire and an umpire should NEVER appear defensive or agressive toward a player/coach.

Ever...Really???

Quote:

Originally Posted by WestMichiganBlue (Post 671242)

I disagree with most of you. I do not want a coach on the field. I want the conversation held outside the foul lines. If a coach is on the field when I reach him, I will walk him across the chalk lines.

Reason: when I am done, I want to walk back onto the field; that is my territory and the coach does not belong there. If he is outside the chalk lines, he can gracefully return to the dugout. If I walk away from him and leave him standing somewhere on the field, he is going to be alone - and ticked. More like to chase after me.

If he is outside the chalk when I walk away, he better not cross the lines. That is asking for the parking lot.

WMB

So what happens if you're the rabbit and the coach is in the 1B dugout? :confused:

I personally wouldn't have such hard and fast rules about where a coach stands. I'd rather be able to stand my ground, have a quick conversation without being adversarial, and get the game moving again.

Quote:

Originally Posted by AtlUmpSteve (Post 588249)

It depends. If I think he has a valid reason to chat or ask a question, I will meet him half way. He's agreeable, I'm agreeable and working with him.

If he wants to challenge judgment or tell me he disagrees with a call, he needs to walk all the way to me, and all the way back.

agree w/ this ...

Quote:

Originally Posted by luvthegame (Post 671248)

Ever...Really???

Not when they know it is contest a call.

I've seen too many umpires almost hurry to get to a coach and get overly defensive prior to the coach even opening his/her mouth.

Just as you are not to take a position with arms crossed that could be construed as defensive or inattentive, I do not want to offer ANYTHING which would give the impression that I am eager to confront a player or coach.

For that matter, I try to make a point to have a big smile on my face when a coach is heading in my direction. I want them to do the work and not have me to use as an excuse.

Quote:

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA (Post 671414)

For that matter, I try to make a point to have a big smile on my face when a coach is heading in my direction. I want them to do the work and not have me to use as an excuse.

And don't forget to remove your sunglasses!!:cool:

Quote:

Originally Posted by HugoTafurst (Post 671431)

And don't forget to remove your sunglasses!!:cool:

Don't wear sunglasses :cool: and I'm not taking off my photo-gray prescriptions.