Umpire Rating Systems

[argodad]

Originally Posted by Skahtboi

I have often wondered about systems like this. How the heck does a coach know how to evaluate an umpire?? How many coaches know anything how mechanics that umpires use? To me, this sounds like a very flawed system from the get go. JMO, of course.

We used to have coaches mail in evaluation cards. It was worth next-to-nothing with respect to giving umpires solid feedback.