Whaddaya Do?

[Skahtboi]

Originally Posted by varefump

Remember that angles are much more important than proximity when making calls.

When you cannot get close to the play, then yes, getting the angle is very important. However, proximity with the appropriate angle to see the play is even more important.

Originally Posted by varefump

Since our association has gone to teaching and using Modern Softball Mechanics, all the umpires are finding out that the ASA manual (what the NFHS basically uses) that was written back in the 70's has no place in 21st century fast-pitch softball.

The mechanics used by ASA are updated annually. Those who attend the clinics know that there is always something in the offing. The mechanics listed in the Umpire Manual are for the masses. And for that purpose, they are still very applicable.

Originally Posted by varefump

Other Modern Base Mechanics include doing away with the 'button hook'; staying outside the diamond as much as possible, and using a new 'D' position anytime a runner is on 3rd.

I can't wait for the traditionalists to respond.

Rimming, or staying outside the diamond has been played with in the past. It is currently being used in three man mechanics in the NCAA. However, nearly all advocates of rimming also recognize there is a time when you must come inside the diamond. Being in the diamond is not a bad thing, and is often necessary to get those angles we spoke of earlier. Besides, to keep the four elements of the game in front of you, it is often necessary to come inside. Or do "modern mechanics" not recognize the importance of this? The new "D" position is not really new. I have seen it ever since I began umpiring. It is also called the lazy man's C position.