BOO-NFHS

[Dakota]

Originally posted by Chess Ref
I say that is ASA.

It's not ASA, either. Your call was correct in both NFHS and ASA.

For the out due to BOO, the improper batter must complete her turn at bat and the appeal must be made before a pitch is thrown to the next batter.

ASA and NFHS differ in which other outs stand on the completed play, but your situation never got that far.