![]() |
Definitions would have you believe so, however within the rule book the appeals must come from the players. Is this a technical quirk.
|
Don't know what a 'quirk' is... By the way the Rulebook clearly says appeals can be made by players, managers and coaches.
This is so on ISF Rulebook: Rule 1 - Sec. 2. APPEAL PLAY. A live or dead ball appeal play is a play upon which an umpire cannot make a decision until requested by a manager, coach or player of the defensive team. EXCEPTION: An offensive manager, coach, or player may appeal for illegal defensive team substitution violations. Ciao! |
Quote:
The definition covers ALL appeals. There ARE appeals that coaches may make (BOO). There ARE appeals that coaches may NOT make (missed base). Clear? |
I will have to study the ASA book a bit more to see just which situations can & can't be made by Mgr/coach. We were discussing and reading about missed bases and the wrong use of the white part of the double 1st base. Did not appear a coach could, but definitions allowed it. The class thought it to be a conflict in the definition
|
The definition says that certain inquiries by certain people, including coaches, players, etc, are APPEALS. It doesn't intimate that all appeals are legal coming from all of those parties.
|
I believe that last year, NFHS changed the rules to allow a head coach to make a dead ball appeal.
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:32am. |