The Teaching of Umpires

[wadeintothem]

I also hear you guys and see your POV.. If the ASA exam were a test administered by ASA with specific guidelines as a board type exam, I would agree. It is not. It is basically a multiple choice POE. Its not even a real test. So I put it at the level it is at. ASA as the org itself doesnt care.. You are inventing principles not applied by the governing org. Basically, "this is my local rule so the entire nation must comply with it".

Sorry, dont work that way.

Your local rules are simply that. Nothing done violated either ASA rules or even ethics, as to have an ethical problem, there MUST be a set criteria to measure against. There is no set criteria here.

If you want to invent yourself a local rule, you'll now need a local rule that says "no reading the answers off of the net".