The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Softball (https://forum.officiating.com/softball/)
-   -   Finally! (https://forum.officiating.com/softball/13140-finally.html)

Dakota Thu Apr 08, 2004 10:49am

Finally!

Called my first game of the season yesterday afternoon. HS game. 10th grade team, but hey, I was on the ball field! Besides, since this is my first year officially registered for HS ball, I'm willing to "pay my dues" before varsity assignments come my way. (Been "pure" ASA up until this year, with just a season of Jr Hi games 2 years ago as a favor to the local school.) ASA doesn't start for another 5 weeks or so.

Nice warm & sunny afternoon, just a bit windy. A well played game - finished in 6 1/2 innings, 3-2 final score with the final out on the visitors having already scored 1 run in the 7th and with runners on 2nd and 3rd - ended in a strike out. Took about 1:20.

The only remotely unusual call was a nice dribbler of a bunt that just barely moved in front of the plate, batter dropped the bat right in front of the plate and hit the ball. I ruled batter out, since the "drop" seemed to me to be intentionally placed.

mick Thu Apr 08, 2004 11:29am

Quote:

Originally posted by Dakota
The only remotely unusual call was a nice dribbler of a bunt that just barely moved in front of the plate, batter dropped the bat right in front of the plate and hit the ball. I ruled batter out, since the "drop" seemed to me to be intentionally placed.
Dakota,
The "bit windy" was just put there to keep you humble.
Dunno, if I'll ever get an outdoor game.

Of course, I didn't see the bat dropped, but it <i>seems</i> to me that since the drop only <i>seemed</i> to be intentionally placed, that may have been quite a tough decision that you had to make in 0.2 seconds.
mick

Duke Thu Apr 08, 2004 11:34am

Have my first game of the year in about three hours. It is a HS VAR scrimmage. It is a balmy 49 degrees with 9-10 MPH winds. Like you say though, at least I can get out on the field and start calling.

kellerumps Thu Apr 08, 2004 01:47pm

We have been working since late Feb.

Anyway, since we don't call HS ball, what is the difference in rules about the "Bat Hitting the ball"? The NCAA rulebook(11-15),


In/Out of box - Bat out of hands - Bat hits Fair Ball - Out
In/Out of Box - Bat out of hands - Ball hits Bat during a fair ball - Live Ball

I don't have a ASA book handy but am curious about that one as well.

Dukat Thu Apr 08, 2004 01:47pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Dakota
Finally!
Called my first game of the season yesterday afternoon.

That is sort of funny because I called my last game of the HS season Tuesday. Playoffs start this weekend but I doubt very seriously that I will get any because there are too many others in our Assn with many years seniority on me but at least I still lave the Private schools who are playing Slow Pitch for a while longer and then ASA starts 1st of May.

Dakota Thu Apr 08, 2004 01:57pm

Quote:

Originally posted by kellerumps
We have been working since late Feb.

Anyway, since we don't call HS ball, what is the difference in rules about the "Bat Hitting the ball"? The NCAA rulebook(11-15),


In/Out of box - Bat out of hands - Bat hits Fair Ball - Out
In/Out of Box - Bat out of hands - Ball hits Bat during a fair ball - Live Ball

I don't have a ASA book handy but am curious about that one as well.

The NFHS rule is different. It says...
Quote:

<font color=blue>Rule 7-4 Art. 1 A batter shall be called out when:
k. after hitting or bunting a ball, she intentionally hits the ball a second time in fair or foul territory; the ball is dead, no runner(s) advance and the batter is out.
EXCEPTION: If the bat and ball accidentally come in contact with each other a second time while the batter is holding the bat in the batter's box, it is a foul ball.
NOTE: In the case ofintentional contact with a foul ball, it must have a chance to become fair in the umpire's judgment.</font>

CecilOne Thu Apr 08, 2004 02:28pm

Actually had a 7 inning freshman game finish in 100 minutes yesterday, in spite of only 1 good pitcher, many substitutions, and working solo. No inning limits were reached and only three base calls were close. Of course, three fly ball "double-ups" helped.

kellerumps Thu Apr 08, 2004 02:42pm

The NCAA rulebook also addresses this

Fair or Foul ball Bat hits ball Intentionally - Batter is out.

I understand you ruled that the drop was intentional. No problem....but what is the ruling if the it was NOT intentional but the bat still hit the ball?

WestMichBlue Thu Apr 08, 2004 05:01pm

If a bat is dropped or thrown in a direction where it can hit the ball I will call that intentional.

WMB

mick Thu Apr 08, 2004 09:10pm

Quote:

Originally posted by kellerumps
The NCAA rulebook also addresses this

Fair or Foul ball Bat hits ball Intentionally - Batter is out.

I understand you ruled that the drop was intentional. No problem....but what is the ruling if the it was NOT intentional but the bat still hit the ball?

kellerumps,
Without intention that ball has to be live, that is our only alternative choice.

I have to see, and believe, the intention.
For example, dropping a bat 24" in front of the plate,
having the ball hit the bat, and stopping the ball "for the catcher", would not seem intentional to me.
Whereas, dropping the bat between the catcher and the 12" bunt, with bat and ball contact, may well seem intentional.

In the original case, the batter dropped the bat on the ball creating a potential hazard/distraction for the catcher. Fine! Let's make the batter go away, for ignorance if for nothing else. All runners go back.
mick

Little Jimmy Thu Apr 08, 2004 09:31pm

Dakota started the thread speaking of Jr. High ball (JV to me) as a place to "pay dues". I agree that overall Varsity has the best action but to tell you the truth I love JV ball. You see tomorrows' stars and the attitude hasn't kicked in yet. I do them both and kind of enjoy the last glimpse of innocence (if you will) before these girls hit the big time.

Roger Greene Fri Apr 09, 2004 06:49am

For a bat hitting a batted ball you can also invoke Fed 7-3-6
"...If a whole bat is thrown and interferes with a defensive player attempting a play, interference shall be called."

No intention is required. You can even declare 2 outs if it prevented a double play.

Roger Greene

whiskers_ump Sat Apr 10, 2004 10:39pm

Did you have another game on the 8th Tom?

TexBlue Sat Apr 10, 2004 11:28pm

Yep, if the ball hits the bat, it's a live ball. If the bat hits the ball, it's a dead ball, batter's out. Now, if you see the bater chunk the bat at the ball and it stops, then the ball rolls into it, I'm still calling dead ball. To me, that's clear enough for me to call it intentional.

TexBlue Sat Apr 10, 2004 11:34pm

<i> Originally posted by Roger Greene:

__________________________________________________ _________
"...If a whole bat is thrown and interferes with a defensive player attempting a play, interference shall be called."
__________________________________________________ _________
</b>

Just wondering, do you see many "not whole" bats up North? Down here, they just dent from the heat, after about the middle of February. Just curious.

whiskers_ump Sun Apr 11, 2004 12:35am

Quote:

Originally posted by TexBlue
<i> Originally posted by Roger Greene:

__________________________________________________ _________
"...If a whole bat is thrown and interferes with a defensive player attempting a play, interference shall be called."
__________________________________________________ _________
</b>

Just wondering, do you see many "not whole" bats up North? Down here, they just dent from the heat, after about the middle of February. Just curious.

</i>

Sure they do....It is so cold, they break. You know how
these gals, after hitting a ball in January and early
February, shake their hands claiming, "that stung"...

TexBlue, you better get off the "<b>Yanks</b> about their
cold weather...You are liable to bring us a "blue northern".

Skahtboi Sun Apr 11, 2004 12:11pm

[QUOTE]Originally posted by whiskers_ump
Quote:

TexBlue, you better get off the "<b>Yanks</b> about their cold weather...You are liable to bring us a "blue northern".
Now I know who to blame for the temperature only being 48 outside today!

TexBlue Sun Apr 11, 2004 12:11pm

Originally posted by whiskers_ump:
<B>
__________________________________________________ _________
TexBlue, you better get off the "Yanks about their
cold weather...You are liable to bring us a "blue northern
__________________________________________________ _________
</B>

Yeah, it might be too late. Feels like it blew in last night. It's only 56 degrees right now. Almost broke my coats back out. Oh, yeah, did I mention no snow?

Dakota Sun Apr 11, 2004 07:02pm

Quote:

Originally posted by whiskers_ump
Did you have another game on the 8th Tom?
Nope; my next game is the 13th. Just as well. Weather has been cold with a few flurries the last couple of days.

Ed Maeder Sun Apr 11, 2004 07:55pm

All you guys have it made. We still have two feet of snow on the ground and are supposed to start our high school season on the 24th. Not looking too good for that date. We try to squeeze our season into 4 weeks before the school year is over. Will probably get a week or so late start and have many more games crammed together.

whiskers_ump Sun Apr 11, 2004 09:16pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Ed Maeder
All you guys have it made. We still have two feet of snow on the ground and are supposed to start our high school season on the 24th. Not looking too good for that date. We try to squeeze our season into 4 weeks before the school year is over. Will probably get a week or so late start and have many more games crammed together.
Ed,

Few years ago, we had a team from Alaska come to the 18U AFA
Nationals. They lasted two days in the heat. The umpires all
sorta adopted the team. We had them over to our compound and
feed them a couple of first class meals. They love watermelon
and gumbo. Everyone at the tournament, 121 teams, enjoyed their
participation. They tried hard, but the heat got to them. They
were from Anchorage, Alaska Lady Bears, Manager: Sam Senner.

Ed Maeder Sun Apr 11, 2004 09:51pm

I know the team and the coach very well. The teams that come to the states always are welcome with open arms. As an umpire I too have had nothing but good to say about my reception where ever I have been in this country. A lot of people have a misconseption that where we are located that softball and fastpitch don't happen. We are very lucky to have some very good umpires here and get a lot of military personal that come through here with some very good experience. It is wonderful to come and do tournaments in the states and I have been very lucky to have been selected to come to Clovis,California in August for the Girls 18-under A. I'm looking forward to that Championship and am also traveling to two other tournaments this summer.

[Edited by Ed Maeder on Apr 11th, 2004 at 10:54 PM]

Skahtboi Sun Apr 11, 2004 10:39pm

Quote:

Originally posted by whiskers_ump
They were from Anchorage, Alaska Lady Bears, Manager: Sam Senner.

I'm impressed. I can't even recall who I called yesterday and what their coach's name was. Hmmm...must be time for the Aricept!

whiskers_ump Mon Apr 12, 2004 06:11am

Scott,

This bunch was a lot of fun. You would have remembered them
also. They just could not handled the Texas July heat. That
whole week that year, was a killer. Heat index over 100 every
day of the tournament. Team dropped from tournament on second
day, but stayed around visiting the surrounding area and watching
games. Umpires figured we would just show them a good time, so
we had them fed with us. Our food was catered from various
places
around town. They handed out some nice pins of which I still have.

CecilOne Mon Apr 12, 2004 11:09am

Quote:

Originally posted by Roger Greene
For a bat hitting a batted ball you can also invoke Fed 7-3-6
"...If a whole bat is thrown and interferes with a defensive player attempting a play, interference shall be called."

No intention is required. You can even declare 2 outs if it prevented a double play.

Roger Greene

deja vu!
I don't think Rule 7-3-6 applies to this kind of play. It is about the bat actually going toward a fielder like when it slips out of the batter's hands and flys toward F1 or F5. The word "whole" is in the book because it differentiates a whole bat from a broken piece of a bat, also covered in 7-3-6, which is not interference. This case did not sound like the bat went toward a fielder.
Also it is about a "thrown" bat; whereas this case is apparently covered by 7-4-1-k and it's case F.

Dakota Mon Apr 12, 2004 12:16pm

Quote:

Originally posted by CecilOne
deja vu!...
Ain't cut 'n' paste great! ;)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:16pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1