What makes a catch?

[davidfv1]

Originally posted by cmathews
Ed, I agree that there would have been no basis to overturn it, I also think that had the ruling on the field been a TD there would have been no basis to overturn it. However if we apply NHFS rules which I know those guys weren't using, I think you would have a better case for a catch...again only in SLO MO, at full speed I wouldn't even venture a guess as to how many would call it a catch..

I now posted the real time play...