How Long?

[OKREF]

Originally Posted by scrounge

Isn't it already there with the prohibitions against butt blocking?

9.4.3 COMMENT: Face tackling, butt blocking and spearing are somewhat related fouls. All are illegal and each carries a 15-yard penalty. Butt blocking is initiating contact with front of the helmet against an opponent who is not the runner. It may be committed by either offensive or defensive players. Face tackling is the same act against the runner and can only be a defensive technique. Both fouls may result from inadvertent acts. Spearing is initiating contact against an opponent with the top of the helmet and may be committed either by offensive or defensive players. Any tactic which involves the illegal use of the helmet is condemned by all who are concerned with the well-being of players and the perpetuation of the game. (2-20-1c)

Butt Blocking deals with the front of the helmet. Doesn't say anything about the crown. How many of you have ever flagged a running back when they lower their head to take on the hit, and hit the tackler with the crown of their helmet? I have never done it.

[jTheUmp]

In a game this year... Runner was getting tackled near his sideline, and one of the runner's teammates came in, head lowered, and speared his own ballcarrier right in the side of the helmet right in front of my H. Ball carrier was knocked out cold, and we had about a 15-minute injury stoppage.

I was told by an AC later that it was the kid's 3rd concussion in a 12-month span (the previous two had come in the prior basketball season).

No flag was thrown because, by rule, you cannot commit a spearing foul on your teammate. ("Spearing is initiating contact against AN OPPONENT with the top of the helmet....")

Methinks the rules committee should change the wording to "against another player"

[Rich]

Originally Posted by OKREF

Butt Blocking deals with the front of the helmet. Doesn't say anything about the crown. How many of you have ever flagged a running back when they lower their head to take on the hit, and hit the tackler with the crown of their helmet? I have never done it.

My crew has done this in each of the last 3 seasons. We flagged one all-state player twice for it and his coach almost picked one up as well arguing it.

Not all helmet-to-helmet contact is a foul, though.

[OKREF]

Originally Posted by Rich

My crew has done this in each of the last 3 seasons. We flagged one all-state player twice for it and his coach almost picked one up as well arguing it.

Not all helmet-to-helmet contact is a foul, though.

I understand that some helmet to helmet to contact is going to happen. What about the stiff arm from a RB that grabs the facemask and pushes head back. Ever called that? I did. Called a face mask. RB just grabbed the facemask and pushed players head back as far as it would go.

[Welpe]

Originally Posted by OKREF

What about the stiff arm from a RB that grabs the facemask and pushes head back. Ever called that? I did. Called a face mask. RB just grabbed the facemask and pushed players head back as far as it would go.

It's not a foul for the runner to push the facemask of an opponent, it is a foul to grab the facemask. I have called the latter before (though it was the Personal Foul variety, not the 5 yard variety).

[OKREF]

Originally Posted by OKREF

I understand that some helmet to helmet to contact is going to happen. What about the stiff arm from a RB that grabs the facemask and pushes head back. Ever called that? I did. Called a face mask. RB just grabbed the facemask and pushed players head back as far as it would go.

Originally Posted by Welpe

It's not a foul for the runner to push the facemask of an opponent, it is a foul to grab the facemask. I have called the latter before (though it was the Personal Foul variety, not the 5 yard variety).

Please read whole statement. I called the 15 yarder.

[Welpe]

Originally Posted by OKREF

Please read whole statement.

I did. I did not say you made a bad call.

[HLin NC]

Already is... see definition of spearing in 2-20-1(c). Also Case book play 9.4.3d

Just never called, even though Illegal Helmet contact is, has been, and probably will be for the forseeable future, a point of emphasis. I imagine the Fed just needs to add the act by a running back in their POE examples.