The Official Forum - Can We Have The NFL Replacements Back, Please?

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)

- Football (https://forum.officiating.com/football/)

- - Can We Have The NFL Replacements Back, Please? (https://forum.officiating.com/football/93017-can-we-have-nfl-replacements-back-please.html)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eastshire (Post 863737)

And yet, I'm willing to wager you know exactly what I mean and therefore it is not lost.

I agree 110%.

Quote:

Originally Posted by MD Longhorn (Post 863754)

Conceptually perhaps, but are you really saying that if an official is 80% sure a player was down, he should blow the whistle? If not... then no, I don't know exactly what you mean. Sure is sure. Not sure is, well, not sure. Currently the line is 100% vs anything else. Not 100% sure = don't blow the whistle... so what do you really mean?

Well, sure isn't sure. I can be pretty sure, sure or even absolute sure. Each is a different level of certainty. I use pretty sure all the time at work when I'm asked for a number I don't have on me.

But, let me give you what I mean in another way. It seems to me that the NFL has instructed the referees not to whistle a play which is subject to automatic review even if they are sure the runner is down unless it will be obvious to the fan in the last row that the runner is down. We just don't see plays whistled were a referee is in position to be sure when it involves turnovers. I think a better standard would be based on what's obvious to a fan in the first row.

Too many seemingly easy calls are getting passed to the automatic review.

Quote:

Originally Posted by jTheUmp (Post 863699)

Better to let it run and let replay overturn it than the other way around... Consider the reverse situation of the aformentioned TD run. Runner appears down but isn't, official blows the whistle and stops play as the runner takes off for a touchdown. Now you're screwed when the replay shows that the runner wasn't down.

Isn't it amazing how many of these plays, which are allowed to continue to conclusion, turn into to touchdowns? Do you know why that is? BECAUSE ALL OF THE PLAYERS ON THE FIELD KNOW WHAT HAPPENED - they simply stop playi g...The 7 officials working the game don't know that they play was over!!!!!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 863709)

The play in the Auburn-Oregon BCS game a couple of years ago would have never been called properly if people listened to Twocentsworth.

Peace

Sitting on my couch thousands of miles away, even I could see that this play was called correctly.

Today's NFL officials seem to be following the rules from 60 yrs ago where you had to tackle the guy & lay on him for 3 seconds before was considered down.

Just wait Jeff...we'll ha e plenty more of these embarrassments by the NFL officials. Can't wait for the playoffs - they'll screw up a game For sure!

Quote:

Originally Posted by twocentsworth (Post 863769)

Just wait Jeff...we'll ha e plenty more of these embarrassments by the NFL officials. Can't wait for the playoffs - they'll screw up a game For sure!

Well folks, that's a wrap. Twoscents said it was so, and thus it will be.

Maybe we should just close this insipid thread....

And that's enough of that.