Penalty enforcement
If a flag is thrown for celebrating after a touchdown , do you still mark the penalty or wave it off ,if the touchdown is called back
|
Quote:
|
Dead ball foul, still gonna get enforced.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Team B would most likely make them try from the 18 but they can elect to make them kick from the 25 on the subsequent kickoff.
|
Quote:
I think he's saying there was a foul on A during the play, nullifying the TD. |
that's a good question. never thought of that. so youre saying:
during a 30 yd TD pass, team A holds. and the receiver, after crossing the goal line spikes the ball. strictly speaking, you back them up 10, then back them up an additional 15 for the dead ball USC, and replay the down. but in a high school game, I think some crews might "quietly pick up" the USC flag here and just enforce the hold. while technically not the correct thing, the thinking being that nullifying the TD and assessing 10 yards is enough of a penalty. (note: if it was a dead ball personal foul on team A, then yeah, we're walking off 25). |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
In your example, there was no live ball foul, the play simply ended at the 1 yard line. After the play, the dead ball foul is enforced from the subsequent spot. |
Quote:
Along the same lines, what if a player is ruled down by contact or stepped out of bounds but he continues to run. If there is no immediate whistle and it may not be obvious to the defensive players the down has ended, do you give the defense a little more leniency on a hit that occurs while the offensive player is still running? |
Quote:
Why not let team B decide if the 10 yard penalty was enough? Couldn't they decline the dead ball USC if they thought that was too much, the way some players will deliberately miss a technical foul shot in basketball if they think the other team was unfairly penalized? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Unfortunately for the player, the undoing of an otherwise score only highlites and magnifies the ignorance of the celebration. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:08pm. |