The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Football (https://forum.officiating.com/football/)
-   -   Penalty enforcement (https://forum.officiating.com/football/53149-penalty-enforcement.html)

Brandon Kincer Sun May 10, 2009 10:54am

Penalty enforcement
 
Where can I find the rule as far enforcing a penalty simaltaneous with the snap or kick?

ajmc Sun May 10, 2009 11:29am

The rule is NF: 10.4.2.a. Rule 10 is a relatively short rule and should be read slowly, simultaneously with the Case Book.

There is a pretty extensive "Summary of Penalties" as appendix B in the Redding Study G to NFHS Rulesuide which you may find helpful.

Brandon Kincer Sun May 10, 2009 11:31am

Thanks!

daggo66 Sun May 10, 2009 07:08pm

You are asking a lot of good questions, however IMO, you are far from ready to step on a varsity field,

Brandon Kincer Mon May 11, 2009 04:06am

Quote:

You are asking a lot of good questions, however IMO, you are far from ready to step on a varsity field,
with all due respect sir, I don't think you know me well enough to determine thatnor do I think its your place. Just because im not sure of somethings doesn't mean im not ready. Ya gotta start somewhere and as a matter of fact new officials staer out on the middle school level amd I plan on learning by doing and taking what I can from that. So please refrain from trying to put me down when all im trying to do is answer a few questions. Thank you.

mbyron Mon May 11, 2009 07:45am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brandon Kincer (Post 601147)
with all due respect sir, I don't think you know me well enough to determine thatnor do I think its your place. Just because im not sure of somethings doesn't mean im not ready. Ya gotta start somewhere and as a matter of fact new officials staer out on the middle school level amd I plan on learning by doing and taking what I can from that. So please refrain from trying to put me down when all im trying to do is answer a few questions. Thank you.

Sorry dude, that's not how forums work. Everybody gets to post his or her opinion, no matter how idiotic. It's up to you to decide what's good, and to try to ignore the rest.

mikesears Mon May 11, 2009 09:59am

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 601161)
It's up to you to decide what's good, and to try to ignore the rest.

Kind of like any advice you will be given from people. It is just more "anonymous" here.

daggo66 Mon May 11, 2009 10:29am

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 601161)
Sorry dude, that's not how forums work. Everybody gets to post his or her opinion, no matter how idiotic. It's up to you to decide what's good, and to try to ignore the rest.

Are you implying my opinion was idiotic? His questions are good questions, but they are novice questions nonetheless. I would tell anyone with those questions that they need more experience. I apologize if my frame of reference is different from most. Where I officiate, inexperienced officials work their way up from youth to JV to Varsity.

mikesears Mon May 11, 2009 10:42am

Quote:

Originally Posted by daggo66 (Post 601217)
Are you implying my opinion was idiotic? His questions are good questions, but they are novice questions nonetheless. I would tell anyone with those questions that they need more experience. I apologize if my frame of reference is different from most. Where I officiate, inexperienced officials work their way up from youth to JV to Varsity.

Everyone is entitled to their own opinoin, not matter how stupid it might be, right? :D

I know you weren't asking me but I do agree with you that some of his questions are basic questions. They are much like the questions I asked as a newly licensed official. I give this site (and a few others) credit for developing my knowledge of the rulebook at a much faster rate than I would have gotten on my own.

My story is that I was a Referee of my own crew at the start of my third year because I was tired of waiting, but I look back and wonder how badly I messed stuff up. Most new officials don't know how much they don't know and are anxious to work "meaningful" games.

I think we both agree that we are glad the poster is here asking them and I saw that encouragement in your post.

HLin NC Mon May 11, 2009 11:01am

Brandon, do you have a set of rule books yet? If not, I'd suggest you ask someone in your HS league to see if they might donate you a set of last year's. While there are changes, both in the rules and editorially, the change is not so great that you couldn't utilize them. You can print off the synopsis of 2009 changes off the Federation website

I had a supervisor (in my day job) that absolutely refused to answer a question until he had determined that I had looked it up in the policy manual first.

Its great that you want to learn but you and your new association will be better served by getting in the rule book and looking it up first. If something confuses you then ask members of the association you are joining. Every officials association is going to have different takes on certain rules and you want to ensure that the interpretation you use is the one that your association wants-not what we discuss here or on the other boards.

Also I would order two supplemental guides- the Reddings NFHS Guide and the Fed's Rules by Topic. Redding';s is available from Honig's and the Rules by Topic guide can be had from Referee Magazine. Those two books are excellent study resources as they break the rule book down into a more mentally digestable format.

If you are new to NFHS rules, I'd shy away from the case book for awhile, unless you loved word problems in school or are a whiz with the Federal tax code. :)

Brandon Kincer Mon May 11, 2009 12:32pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by HLin NC (Post 601228)
Brandon, do you have a set of rule books yet? If not, I'd suggest you ask someone in your HS league to see if they might donate you a set of last year's. While there are changes, both in the rules and editorially, the change is not so great that you couldn't utilize them. You can print off the synopsis of 2009 changes off the Federation website

I had a supervisor (in my day job) that absolutely refused to answer a question until he had determined that I had looked it up in the policy manual first.

Its great that you want to learn but you and your new association will be better served by getting in the rule book and looking it up first. If something confuses you then ask members of the association you are joining. Every officials association is going to have different takes on certain rules and you want to ensure that the interpretation you use is the one that your association wants-not what we discuss here or on the other boards.

Also I would order two supplemental guides- the Reddings NFHS Guide and the Fed's Rules by Topic. Redding';s is available from Honig's and the Rules by Topic guide can be had from Referee Magazine. Those two books are excellent study resources as they break the rule book down into a more mentally digestable format.

If you are new to NFHS rules, I'd shy away from the case book for awhile, unless you loved word problems in school or are a whiz with the Federal tax code. :)

Yes sir, I have a 2008 rule book, 2008-09 officials manual, and 2008 case book. I study them hard every chance I get. My nose has been stuck in that book ever since I recieved them in the mail. Im not new to NFHS rules because the recreation dept. that I ref for uses that book. Im just trying to work through some loop holes and make sure that I understand the rules clearly. Up to this point, all of my questions have been pretty much answered.

Quote:

Are you implying my opinion was idiotic? His questions are good questions, but they are novice questions nonetheless. I would tell anyone with those questions that they need more experience. I apologize if my frame of reference is different from most. Where I officiate, inexperienced officials work their way up from youth to JV to Varsity.
Just to make this clear, I do not think your opinion is in anyway idiotic. My point was you were saying that I am "Not Ready simply because I ask questions you consider to be "Novice" Some of the questions im asking I already know the answer to but just want to be sure that I am getting things right before I step up to the next level. Any piece of advice you can give me is greatly valued but I do ask that you do not cut me down just for asking questions, not necessarly that I don't know anything about, but that im just not clear on. Your comment of me being not ready was clearly nothing more than that of a cut down because you didn't even answer the question. You just simply stated that im "Not Ready"

Ed Hickland Mon May 11, 2009 12:32pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brandon Kincer (Post 601147)
with all due respect sir, I don't think you know me well enough to determine thatnor do I think its your place. Just because im not sure of somethings doesn't mean im not ready. Ya gotta start somewhere and as a matter of fact new officials staer out on the middle school level amd I plan on learning by doing and taking what I can from that. So please refrain from trying to put me down when all im trying to do is answer a few questions. Thank you.

It is good that you ask questions and try to learn the game rules before stepping out on the field, in fact, keep asking because it makes veteran officials like myself think about what may have unfortunately become routine.

As for the level of game you work always look to the next level to determine what you need to do to reach that level. Personally, new officials who ask questions have all my support because they can be taught.

Best of luck to you.

Welpe Mon May 11, 2009 12:39pm

Brandon-

You will get there, keep studying, asking questions and seeking the right answers from a variety of sources.

My own advice is to get intimate with Rule 2. Understanding and being able to apply definitions will be key in learning and comprehending the remainder of the rule book.

daggo66 Mon May 11, 2009 12:51pm

Brandon,

I am not "cutting you down." You very well may be ready. Only those from your association who have observed you can know for sure. Based on the level of your questions I firmly believe that you need more work. As I said previously, in my organization the standards are high. Getting on the varsity field too soon can negatively affect an official's career. You and others may feel my criticism is harsh. So be it. You had best prepare for harsh criticism as you move up. Your questions tell me that you have potential. Keep it up.

mbyron Mon May 11, 2009 06:56pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by daggo66 (Post 601217)
Are you implying my opinion was idiotic?

No, not in what I said there.

Forksref Mon May 11, 2009 07:42pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by daggo66 (Post 601069)
You are asking a lot of good questions, however IMO, you are far from ready to step on a varsity field,

I fail to find anything in the OP that indicates the level at which this person wishes to officiate. And...it is certainly not my duty to judge the level at which our colleagues should be officiating.

I hope the original poster continues to ask questions here regardless of how much someone attacks his ability.

Brandon Kincer Tue May 12, 2009 01:53am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ed Hickland (Post 601262)
It is good that you ask questions and try to learn the game rules before stepping out on the field, in fact, keep asking because it makes veteran officials like myself think about what may have unfortunately become routine.

As for the level of game you work always look to the next level to determine what you need to do to reach that level. Personally, new officials who ask questions have all my support because they can be taught.

Best of luck to you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Welpe (Post 601263)
Brandon-

You will get there, keep studying, asking questions and seeking the right answers from a variety of sources.

My own advice is to get intimate with Rule 2. Understanding and being able to apply definitions will be key in learning and comprehending the remainder of the rule book.

Quote:

Originally Posted by daggo66 (Post 601265)
Brandon,

I am not "cutting you down." You very well may be ready. Only those from your association who have observed you can know for sure. Based on the level of your questions I firmly believe that you need more work. As I said previously, in my organization the standards are high. Getting on the varsity field too soon can negatively affect an official's career. You and others may feel my criticism is harsh. So be it. You had best prepare for harsh criticism as you move up. Your questions tell me that you have potential. Keep it up.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Forksref (Post 601360)
I fail to find anything in the OP that indicates the level at which this person wishes to officiate. And...it is certainly not my duty to judge the level at which our colleagues should be officiating.

I hope the original poster continues to ask questions here regardless of how much someone attacks his ability.

Thanks for all the support guys. It really is appreciated. Like ive said before, this is something I really want to grow in. For the record, I do not plan on working a single varsity game this season although some of the certified officials say that I will be scheduled for at least one near the end of the season. I want work my way up not only because I am required to but I feel its essential that I do for the sole purpose of learning and educating myself to become the best I can be. People I work with at my primary job are excited for me. Some have even asked that I send them tickets to the super bowl when I make it to the NFL lol. I told this one lady that when I throw a flag on her favorite player, I would sign the flag with a sharpy and send it to her in the mail. Nevertheless, I am ver appreciative of the support I get but at the sametime I never frown upon contructive criticism and will continue to ask questions.

JugglingReferee Sat May 16, 2009 07:09pm

Canadian Answer
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Brandon Kincer (Post 600991)
Where can I find the rule as far enforcing a penalty simaltaneous with the snap or kick?

CANADIAN ANSWER:

Snap: Rule 4.

Kick-Off: Rule 5.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:36am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1