football bicep bands

[BktBallRef]

Originally Posted by KWH

I explained how it is justified above.
But I will repeat it since you appear confused.

1) Coach is advised in the pre-game any and all uniform adorments or modifiyed equipment must be removed or corrected prior to participation.
2) If detected during play, player is sent out for one play, team recieves 5-yard equipment penalty, coach is notified of situation. (In your state this may be an UC)
3) On second penalty by same player, player is ejected, coach is issued UC.

You won't find it in your rule book. Amazingly enough you won't find the A-11 Offense to be a UC foul or a Travesty in your rule book either.

So you're saying that the NFHS rule book does not tell us to eject players for not removing bicep bands but your state association feels strongly about this, feels it's not good for the game and has taken it upon themselves to take a stand against this?

That's all I need to know! Thanks!

[HLin NC]

BANG

[BktBallRef]

Originally Posted by HLin NC

BANG

This is very interesting, HL. KWH has been busting on you, me and the NCHSAA through PM and posts because our state rep has followed his convictions and made a decision tha the A-11 is not good for high school football in the state of North Carolina.

Yet, when his state makes a similiar decision concerning illegal equipment, and that's alright. They're doing the right thing. Hmmm.

Then, when challenged on it, he deletes his post.

Wow.

[BktBallRef]

Originally Posted by KWH

No, BBR, once again you have misquoted me, just like you do on the NFHS webpage.

No partner, I didn't misquote you. In fact, I quoted your post which is fortunate since you deleted.

I gave up making childish attitude statements such as your "Thats all I need to know! Thanks" (listed above) when I reached puberty.
You do not attempt to engage in a discussion rather you find it necessary to slam anyone and everyone at will.

Really? You mean like when you wrote, "Good luck in your season you arrogant a$$!" in a PM to me?

You have shown us all your acute abilty to copy and paste rules onto a thread! (Impressive to say the least)

Thank you, I think. I notice that you copy and paste rules as well, so I'm unsure why that's an issue for you.

You have the unique abilty to have an answer for everything yet a solution for none!

Never claimed to have a solution or an answer for every situation. But I don have opinions that I share from time to time. I thought that's what discussion forums are all about.

You are BBR, in the strongest sense of the term, a Legend in your own mind!

So you gave up making childish attitude statements when you were in puberty, eh? It's a shame you didn't give up personal insults and name calling.

Say what you want but your state association has taken a stand on a situation that they feel is good for high school football in your state. So has mine. The best thing for you to do is get over it.

[sloth]

I can honestly say that as a crew chief and referee, I will NOT be calling an USC on a player wearing arm bands. This is real simple. When you see it, tell the kid thats considered to be illegal equipment and they'll need to remove it. If they balk, tell the coach and this will fix the situation.

Here in Indiana, the coaches vote on post season assignments. Throwing an USC on something as trivial as this is a pretty good way to make sure you are sitting at home fro the first round of the play-offs.

[Blue37]

Originally Posted by sloth

I can honestly say that as a crew chief and referee, I will NOT be calling an USC on a player wearing arm bands. This is real simple. When you see it, tell the kid thats considered to be illegal equipment and they'll need to remove it. If they balk, tell the coach and this will fix the situation.

Here in Indiana, the coaches vote on post season assignments. Throwing an USC on something as trivial as this is a pretty good way to make sure you are sitting at home fro the first round of the play-offs.

Are there other rules the coaches ding you on when you enforce them?

[sloth]

Originally Posted by Blue37

Are there other rules the coaches ding you on when you enforce them?

I'm sure there are. The coaches vote has no feedback to the governing body aside from the vote itself. Common sense lends itself to the idea that you should focus on penalties that relate to the fairness of the contest and safety rather than nit-picking over the presence of an underarmore bicept band or a "live strong" yellow wrist band.

[KWH]

Originally Posted by BktBallRef

So you're saying that the NFHS rule book does not tell us to eject players for not removing bicep bands but your state association feels strongly about this, feels it's not good for the game and has taken it upon themselves to take a stand against this?

That's all I need to know! Thanks!

No, BBR, once again you have misquoted me, just like you do on the NFHS webpage.
I gave up making childish attitude statements such as your "Thats all I need to know! Thanks" (listed above) when I reached puberty.
You do not attempt to engage in a discussion rather you find it necessary to slam anyone and everyone at will.
You have shown us all your acute abilty to copy and paste rules onto a thread! (Impressive to say the least)
You have the unique abilty to have an answer for everything yet a solution for none!
You are BBR, in the strongest sense of the term, a Legend in your own mind!

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by KWH

No, BBR, once again you have misquoted me, just like you do on the NFHS webpage.
I gave up making childish attitude statements such as your "Thats all I need to know! Thanks" (listed above) when I reached puberty.
You do not attempt to engage in a discussion rather you find it necessary to slam anyone and everyone at will.
You have shown us all your acute abilty to copy and paste rules onto a thread! (Impressive to say the least)
You have the unique abilty to have an answer for everything yet a solution for none!
You are BBR, in the strongest sense of the term, a Legend in your own mind!

Is everyone that disagrees with you needed to responds from you in a childish way?

Someone disagrees with you and they have an inflated ego?

Even though I agree with you on this topic, but when are you just going to just disagree with someone without name calling like you are 5 years old?

BTW, we were told the very same thing about this rule. If the coach does not comply you have options to penalize this. That is the first time I heard this, but that is what our Rules Interpreter said.

Peace

[Fedex]

As an umpire, I don't think I'd want to start off a game dinging players or coaches for bicep bands. This is the worst way to start things off and I'm sure I'd get an earful from my wings. How about working with the coach to make sure that the players remove the bands and use the USC as a last resort? The rule may be in black and white, but some common sense has to factor in here.

Scott

[ajmc]

The original question on this thread was, "Can the team get an USC penalty (for wearing armbands) or has this been changed. thanks". The absolute answer to that questions is "Yes", but the better question might have been SHOULD an USC penalty be assessed for wearing armbands, and that answer is not so universal.

Whether we each like it, or not, the NFHS rules identify this equipment as illegal and there is a prescribed penalty for playing with illegal equipment. They have decided the equipment poses a potential hazard, and it's their responsibility to render such judgments, not our's. However, equally important to our knowing the rules of the game is our judgment in knowing when to enforce them.

If a State Association, or a more localized Board, issued a specific modification or called special attention to this application of this rule, it seems logical to follow those instructions. However, as we've done for the last 100+ years we try and avoid the necessity of penalizing certain situations by what we call "preventive officiating", such as when we see a mouth piece dangling, or a chin strap unbuckled.

We're on the field for 30 minutes before each game, and inappropriate arm bands are pretty visible, even more so than prohibited knots tied under the armpits or on the back of jerseys. It seems a lot more productive to address this issue with the coaching staff before the game (emphasis on "address" rather than discuss) and prevent any subsequent oversight by refusing to allow any player, so equipped, from entering the game.

Those efforts should prevent 99.9% of the problems from occuring. If you find it necessary to apply the remedy proscribed by rule in the remaining 0.01%, it shouldn't surprise anyone.

[Careyy]

Following the book and calling it an adornment it would be a UC, 2 and you are gone, right? Also 9-5-1g Refusing to comply with an official's request-Penalty UC, page 73 The second unsportsmanlike results in a disqualification.

It would be nice if we actually followed the book, the amendments are a pain at times.