Using Lists to Rank Officials

[MJT]

Originally posted by Jeff Drahozal
MJT, I to am in Iowa and I know nothing about a 1-5 rating. I do know it was discussed last spring by the Offical's Advisory Committee and got no farther than that.
In Iowa, we get no feedback at all about performance. Good or bad. Local associations have no authority, it all is controlled at the state level.
I would actually like to get some feedback from coaches, good and bad. The coach's recommendation are what it takes to get playoff games in Iowa.

I was messed up in my thinking. We, as officials rate the fans, coaches, and players on a 1-5 rating. The schools recommend 3 crews to the playoffs. The number of ratings is what determines who gets playoffs.

It is the girls union in Iowa where the officials get a 1-5 rating like I discussed. Then each year you get your rating in a letter from the state.
Sorry for the confusion.