The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Football (https://forum.officiating.com/football/)
-   -   Back and Forth (https://forum.officiating.com/football/15659-back-forth.html)

chiefgil Fri Oct 01, 2004 01:24pm

YES
 
Linemen cannot go beyond the expanded NZ until the last pass thrown goes beyond the NZ.

Ineligible downfield.

cowbyfan1 Sat Oct 02, 2004 03:20am

Quote:

Originally posted by mcrowder
What a bizarre rule. Let me ask 2 related questions then...

Lineman #59 receives a legal handoff, runs 5 yards past the LOS, returns back behind the LOS, and throws a pass. Illegal man downfield?

Lineman #59 receives a legal handoff, runs 5 yards past the LOS, pitches to QB #11, who immediately throws a pass. Illegal man downfield?

Yes and yes. Linemen cannot be down field until the last pass is thrown. Now having said that, when is the last time you saw a lineman receive a hand off??? Keep in mind, a lineman number cannot be a back in Fed.

BulldogMcC Sat Oct 02, 2004 03:55am

Quote:

Originally posted by cowbyfan1
...Keep in mind, a lineman number cannot be a back in Fed.
What rule prevents a player with a number 50-79 from being a back?

bdavid48661 Sat Oct 02, 2004 10:56am

I think if this is legal then it should be changed. You teach a DB to stay with a receiver until the ball crosses the line. Thanks for all your responses.

Snake~eyes Sat Oct 02, 2004 11:02pm

Quote:

Originally posted by bdavid48661
I think if this is legal then it should be changed. You teach a DB to stay with a receiver until the ball crosses the line. Thanks for all your responses.
It is legal! Like I said I've never seen or heard about it happening. So it's not that big of a deal. Guess you need to teach DB's to go back to the reciever when the ball goes back behind the LOS.

cowbyfan1 Sun Oct 03, 2004 01:51am

Quote:

Originally posted by BulldogMcC
Quote:

Originally posted by cowbyfan1
...Keep in mind, a lineman number cannot be a back in Fed.
What rule prevents a player with a number 50-79 from being a back?

look at the chart, I do believe it is in rule one (don't have my rule book handy). Also the answer on part 2 to that was false.

Texoma_LJ Sun Oct 03, 2004 04:24am

The rule that applies to numbering requirements is rule 7-5-6a.
The rule that applies to ineligibles is rule 7-5-12.

BulldogMcC Sun Oct 03, 2004 06:30am

The rule that defines a back is 2-30-3 and it has nothing to do with numbers.

chiefgil Sun Oct 03, 2004 08:14pm

Was he lined up as a running back?

If so, it was a legal handoff to a "runner". The fact that he was beyond the LOS when he tossed it back behind the LOS should not have any bearing on the ruling on this play. The lineman had been established as a runner, not a lineman.

Rich Sun Oct 03, 2004 08:54pm

Quote:

Originally posted by cowbyfan1
Quote:

Originally posted by BulldogMcC
Quote:

Originally posted by cowbyfan1
...Keep in mind, a lineman number cannot be a back in Fed.
What rule prevents a player with a number 50-79 from being a back?

look at the chart, I do believe it is in rule one (don't have my rule book handy). Also the answer on part 2 to that was false.

There is a difference between being a back and an eligible receiver.

Dommer1 Mon Oct 04, 2004 05:01am

McCrowder,

I'm talking about NCAA rules. I do not only imply that a QB can not cross the NZ, return behind it, and throw a legal forward pass; I'm in fact stating that that is a fact! ;)

When re-reading the entire thread, it see that it is not clear that, except for my first post, I was talking about NCAA rules. Sorry about that.

[Edited by Dommer1 on Oct 4th, 2004 at 06:04 AM]

waltjp Mon Oct 04, 2004 07:25am

Quote:

Originally posted by mcrowder
What a bizarre rule. Let me ask 2 related questions then...

Lineman #59 receives a legal handoff, runs 5 yards past the LOS, returns back behind the LOS, and throws a pass. Illegal man downfield?

Lineman #59 receives a legal handoff, runs 5 yards past the LOS, pitches to QB #11, who immediately throws a pass. Illegal man downfield?

In both cases I'm going to flag for ineligible downfield. The restrictions for A continue throughout the down until the last pass is thrown. The theory is that A knows the play and should know the rules.

mcrowder Mon Oct 04, 2004 09:38am

Thanks for the answer, Walt.

Dommer - I'm in Texas, so I'm under NCAA rules too. My hypothetical was to help me understand the Fed rules they were discussing.

keystoneref Mon Oct 04, 2004 09:58am

Federation Rules. An ineligible numbered player may be lined up in the backfield and may block or receive a handoff or BACKWARD pass and run the ball. The player (say # 60) cannot receive a FORWARD pass or advance beyond the neutral zone during a forward pass play (untill the last pass crosses the neutral zone). A player in federation rules must be eligible by position and NUMBER (they CANNOT report to the referee with an ineligible number and make themselves legal). If this player advances beyond the neutral zone, he is guilty of ineligible receiver downfield and if he touches or catches the pass beyond the neutral zone, he is guilty of offensive pass interference. If he catches or muffs a FORWARD pass, in or behind the neutral zone, he is guilty of illegal touching. Just keep in mind no matter what position he starts the play in he still must have an eligible number to receive a forward pass.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:42am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1