The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Hand/Bounce (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/9924-hand-bounce.html)

APHP Wed Sep 03, 2003 02:32pm

I am thinking that following basket interference or goaltending the official shall hand the ball to the thrower-in. But I can't find it in any of my books. Is it stated anywhere that the official has to "hand" the ball to the thrower-in following BI of GT....is so where? Thanks

mick Wed Sep 03, 2003 02:47pm

Try : Rule 7-5.3, 7-5.7, 7-5.2,
Case 7.5.7
Officials Manual 220

wizard Thu Sep 11, 2003 02:04pm

Mick,
I read those rules but could not determine if team B throws in from the spot or has the baseline. It IS a basket (awarded one though)?

Dan_ref Thu Sep 11, 2003 02:57pm

Quote:

Originally posted by wizard
Mick,
I read those rules but could not determine if team B throws in from the spot or has the baseline. It IS a basket (awarded one though)?

A can run the baseline after a made or awarded basket by B.

mick Thu Sep 11, 2003 04:03pm

Quote:

Originally posted by wizard
Mick,
I read those rules but could not determine if team B throws in from the spot or has the baseline. It IS a basket (awarded one though)?


YU.P.
... What Dan said.

If it counts let 'em run with the ball; it doesn't matter if they get a bounce, or have the ball handed to them due to defensive pressure.
mick

mick Thu Sep 11, 2003 04:04pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref
[B
A can run the baseline after a made or awarded basket by B. [/B]
Dan,
I haven't forgotten you.
Been busy.
Thanks.
mick

APHP Fri Sep 12, 2003 07:49am

The purpose of the original question (should the official hand or bounce the ball to the thrower-in following basket interference or goaltending) was to see what responses would be given since the rules/case/simplified & illustrated books give diffferent answers. It is a given that no fan or coach would not know the difference and most officals would not know either.

Rule Book 2003-04::Page 59, Rule 11 Section 12 Penalty 1.--if goaltending occurs at the opponents basket, "the official shall HAND the ball to a player of the team entitled to the throw-in".

Simplified & Illustrated 2003-04::Page66, Rule 9-11-1, Case play at bottom of page--For basket interference "the official HANDS or BOUNCES the ball to a team B player for a throw-in anywhere along the end line nearest team A's basket"

Case Book 2003-04::Page 60, Rule 9.0--Middle of page Basket interference or goaltending "the official MUST HAND or BOUNCE the ball to the thrower."

Obviously the Books are not consistent with each other. To be redundant, if the books are not consistent then no one in the gym would know what is proper. However, when in doubt I do what the rule book says. I was just curious was to what answers would be given on the board.

mick Fri Sep 12, 2003 08:20am

Quote:

Originally posted by APHP
The purpose of the original question (should the official hand or bounce the ball to the thrower-in following basket interference or goaltending) was to see what responses would be given since the rules/case/simplified & illustrated books give diffferent answers.
APHP,
Interesting.
Yet, I think the important point made is that the opponent of the awarded basket may not simply take the ball at will,
the official shall stop the clock and the official shall administer the ball.
mick


BTW:

Rule Book 2003-04::Page 59, Rule <b>9</b> Section 12 Penalty 1.--if goaltending occurs at the opponents basket, "the official shall HAND the ball to a player of the team entitled to the throw-in". ;)

BktBallRef Fri Sep 12, 2003 08:37am

It's no different than any other throw-in that's to be administered. You can hand it to the thrower or bounce it to him/her. I think you're getting to wrapped up in the semantics. The rule book simply hasn't been changed to reflect that we can now bounce the ball to the thrower, not that it necessarily needs to be.

Rich Fri Sep 12, 2003 09:15am

Methinks that you are being a little anal :)

Actually, I wouldn't be surprised if this is just one that got by the rules editor. A mechanics change was made allowing a bounce, but that doesn't always mean that the change makes it over to the rule book.

And if it is a mechanics question, I would let the mechanics manual(s) win out over the rule book.

Rich

JRutledge Fri Sep 12, 2003 11:03am

Talk to your head people.
 
We were told to hand the ball on all endline throw-ins. Guys were leaving the line too early when they were bouncing the ball. Your state might have a specific take on this, that the mechanics book does not support.

Peace

Camron Rust Fri Sep 12, 2003 11:19am

Actually, I don't think they are inconsistant as you suggest....
Quote:

Originally posted by APHP
The purpose of the original question (should the official hand or bounce the ball to the thrower-in following basket interference or goaltending) was to see what responses would be given since the rules/case/simplified & illustrated books give diffferent answers. It is a given that no fan or coach would not know the difference and most officals would not know either.

Rule Book 2003-04::Page 59, Rule 11 Section 12 Penalty 1.--if goaltending occurs at the opponents basket, "the official shall HAND the ball to a player of the team entitled to the throw-in".

The GT was by the defense at the offensive teams basket. The throwin will be on the endline. All endline throwins in the frontcourt are handed to the thrower.

Quote:

Originally posted by APHP
Simplified & Illustrated 2003-04::Page66, Rule 9-11-1, Case play at bottom of page--For basket interference "the official HANDS or BOUNCES the ball to a team B player for a throw-in anywhere along the end line nearest team A's basket"

This one was was at A's basket and since B's getting the ball, A committed the violation. The throwin is along the endline but in B backcourt since it was at A's basket.

In the backcourt, all throwins can be bounced or handed.

Quote:

Originally posted by APHP

Case Book 2003-04::Page 60, Rule 9.0--Middle of page Basket interference or goaltending "the official MUST HAND or BOUNCE the ball to the thrower."

Correct. It must be one or the other. We can't let the player just grab the dead ball and resume play.

Quote:

Originally posted by APHP

Obviously the Books are not consistent with each other. To be redundant, if the books are not consistent then no one in the gym would know what is proper. However, when in doubt I do what the rule book says. I was just curious was to what answers would be given on the board.

They are consistent.

<LI>Frontcourt endline throwin...the official must hand the ball to the thrower.
<LI>A throwin from any other location...official may hand or bounce the ball to the thrower.
<LI>After a BI or GT, an official must administer the throwin.

Dan_ref Fri Sep 12, 2003 11:38am

Quote:

Originally posted by Camron Rust
Actually, I don't think they are inconsistant as you suggest....

The GT was by the defense at the offensive teams basket. The throwin will be on the endline. All endline throwins in the frontcourt are handed to the thrower.




Camron, I've long ago learned not to question your analysis but I can't for the life of me conjure up a scenario where a BI/GT at any basket would not lead to a team getting the ball <u>in their own backcourt</u>.

What am I missing?

Quote:


<LI>Frontcourt endline throwin...the official must hand the ball to the thrower.
<LI>A throwin from any other location...official may hand or bounce the ball to the thrower.
<LI>After a BI or GT, an official must administer the throwin. [/B]
Good summary, although as has been pointed out handing/bouncing may not be optional. Where I am bouncing on the BC endline & any sidelines varies from STRONGLY recommended to ABSOLUTELY required.

Camron Rust Fri Sep 12, 2003 12:45pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref
Quote:

Originally posted by Camron Rust
Actually, I don't think they are inconsistant as you suggest....

The GT was by the defense at the offensive teams basket. The throwin will be on the endline. All endline throwins in the frontcourt are handed to the thrower.




Camron, I've long ago learned not to question your analysis but I can't for the life of me conjure up a scenario where a BI/GT at any basket would not lead to a team getting the ball <u>in their own backcourt</u>.

What am I missing?


After a second look....nothing.

I responded too fast...not considering that the basket is awarded for the defensive interference...before heading off to a meeting.

I agree with you in that all throwins after BI/GT will be in the backcourt since the points wiil be awarded for defensive infractions and the defending team will get the ball on the backcourt endline. And, for offensive infractions, the defense will again get the ball on the backcourt endline after the points are canceled.

Looks like there may actually be an inconsistancy in the rules. :|

williebfree Fri Sep 12, 2003 07:39pm

Am I missing something?
 
Hello All!

Semi-rusty brain at work....

Wouldn't the inbounding team have endline "Priviledge" after an "awarded" basket? Also, wouldn't the subsequent throw-in only occur at the backcourt endline since the official has just awarded the ball to the opponent of the offended team.



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:52pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1