Jump ball held ball plus injury.
What happens if on a jump ball, A2 and B2 tie up a ball for a held ball call and A1 is injured in the scrum. Who jumps?
|
Quote:
Team B's coach gets to choose the shortest player on Team A to replace A2 and he will be the jumper. ;) In all seriousness, I am going to have A6, the substitute for A2 be the jumper along with B2. Not sure if this is addressed anywhere in the rules, so this is just what makes sense to me. |
Agree with MathReferee
|
Honestly have to say this is a question I have never thought of before.
In the NBA, which I'm assuming the OP is referencing when he talks about a held ball situation, I would think the substitute would have to jump since it has to be the two players who were involved. If we are talking NFHS or NCAA I don't know why we wouldn't let the coach put in a sub and have whoever he wanted be the new jumper. |
Quote:
Absent the injury in NCAAW, any two players can jump. So, any two players can jump after the injury. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
I don't think the FT situation is analogous. |
Quote:
|
This specific play I am looking for the HS ruling. So far we just have opinions but no rules backing. Anyone care to venture?
|
Quote:
I'd make the sub jump. |
Quote:
That said, you can go with 2-3 if you want. Honestly, since it's not covered by rule, I'd have a hard time telling anyone their wrong if they came to the other conclusion (allowing anyone to jump). Most of us won't have more than a handful of held balls on the opening tip anyway; the odds of one of those 5 situations involving an injury are infinitely small. |
Huh?
Quote:
7-3-2. Though I'd never want to be construed as speaking for Bob who is right. |
Quote:
Quote:
Now I know this given the .001 chance it happens in a game any time soon. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:48am. |