Camron Rust |
Tue Apr 16, 2013 12:38pm |
Quote:
Originally Posted by HokiePaul
(Post 891083)
This makes me wonder how certain violations can be changed after signaled, but others can't.
|
Basically, anything can be changed after it is signaled unless it is conflicting judgements of the very same act (was it a block or a charge). Everything else is open for discussions. It may not be advisable, but it is at least an option.
Quote:
Originally Posted by HokiePaul
(Post 891083)
It is generally accepted that a mistake (official blows whistle using the wrong line) can be taken back as an inadvertant whistle.
|
Not only is it accepted but it is actually the rule. What matters is not what the official thought happened but what actually happened. If they blow the whistle and there was no violation, even if they thought there was one to start with, the rules grant the ball back to the team in control or the team that is still due a throwin/FT for a prior infarction....or a AP arrow if none of the above apply.
Quote:
Originally Posted by HokiePaul
(Post 891083)
An official can reverse an out of bounds violation call (based on information from his/her partner).
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by HokiePaul
(Post 891083)
Can an official reverse a travel or double dribble call ... I've never seen it done. Say the Trail is in the back court on a fast break and calls what appears from his view to be a double dribble. The Center/Lead who is in front of the play has a better view is 100% certain (perhaps along with the coaches) that the play was not a double dribble. Can the Center/Lead approach his/her partner and offer information that would allow them to change the call?
|
They could. I did it once. I was trail, partner lead at the baseline. He called a double dribble on a player at half court. The defender had knocked the ball out of the opponents hands after the dribble had ended, creating a new opportunity for a dribble which the offensive play made use of. He didn't see the defender knock the ball away and only knew that the offensive player had already dribbled. He refused to change the call and we talked about it after the game.
Quote:
Originally Posted by HokiePaul
(Post 891083)
And are there any fouls where the call can be changed after the fact? I know you can upgrade to a Intentional/Flagrant after discussing with partners, but I can't think of any situation where you could reverse a foul call to a no call based on additional information.
|
The foul call could be overturned if, by rule, it was at a time when a foul could not occur such as a common foul after the ball is dead.
|