![]() |
Kentucky/Ole Miss Video Request
I'm thinking this was about 7:55 second half.
Jim Burr was the calling official. Ole Miss gets a rebound and my initial reaction was that's a foul on the Kentucky player going underneath the Ole Miss player on the rebound. As that happens the Ole Miss player falls to the ground with clear possession of the ball all the way down, so now I'm thinking travel. Well that's what I get for thinking as neither was called. So I rewind it and upon further review when the Ole Miss player fell to the floor he was half way out of bounds and you guessed it, no call. Play on boys we're going the other way. 2 wrongs don't make a right so what about 3 wrongs? I just started scratching my head then flipped back over to US Of Bacon. |
Quote:
If he wanted to not call a foul and let a little bit go, I can see that. But things that obvious, you really can't ignore those...you must take a step back and get the foul if the foul causes that. |
In NCAA an airborne player can fall to the ground and it is not travelling. I believe there is a subtle difference in how the travelling rules are written between NFHS and NCAA that accounts for this. I'll have to look it up later if someone else doesn't beat me to it.
|
Quote:
It is traveling when a player falls to the playing court while holding the ball without maintaining a pivot foot. I know in the NBA you are allowed to fall to the court but I'd never heard that for NCAA |
Quote:
In fact, by rule, I don't see why it is travelling in the NFHS. But when doing HS I call it a travel and when doing college rule set I no-call it. |
Quote:
|
Two plays from this game:
First play and one I was going to post myself: <iframe width="640" height="360" src="https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/su444NDA7a4" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> Illegal screen or pushing foul for going through the screener? Second play and the one the OP asked for: <iframe width="640" height="360" src="https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/AKqMyYFE0mQ" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> |
Quote:
|
Play 1: I like the pushing foul on the defender.
Play 2: Wow. Hard to tell about the foul from the angle, but not hard to tell about the travel or OOB. And where the heck was the L going? |
Quote:
a. May not touch the floor with a knee or any other part of the body other than hand or foot." |
Play 1--illegal screen to me.
Play 2--I would go with a foul on blue, and if no foul, definately travel or out of bounds. Has to be something on this. |
Play 1 - I would've liked to have seen an illegal screen called here, but I can understand why the T would only be able to see the push. The L had no one between him and this play, and he needs to see and call the illegal screen. The bucket definitely counts with what was called though.
Play 2 - He was definitely pushed, and it caused him to go to the ground. If a foul isn't called here, the travel or OOB should have been. I can see getting away without calling a travel if the official passed on the foul, but the OOB is too obvious... |
Quote:
|
Play #1: Either an illegal screen or it was a pushing foul on B1 PRIOR to A2 starting his habitual shooting motion.
Play #2: Can't tell if there is a push, but there is definitely a travel and an OOB violation. |
Quote:
On play two, I have an undercut by the defender. |
I thought that screen was illegal when it happened and I still do now after seeing the replays.
After seeing the replay on the rebound, non-traval, non-OOB, I think a foul was the right call. Blue-12 came into White-10's legs as he was coming down and caused him to fall. In the end, the right team got that ball, but it sure was an ugly way to get to the right result. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I have an illegal screen on the first play that the Lead needs to get. Definitely looks like a foul on Blue in the second clip, but if you're going to pass on that, don't compound it by no-calling the travel and OOB. |
#1 = Illegal screen. It happened in L's PCA so he's the one who needs to get it first, though it's not impossible for the T to get it since no one was near the shooter when he got the ball.
#2 = Foul on Kentucky #12. |
Quote:
|
1. Illegal screen
2. Blue foul - it's not a full undercut, but it's contact that causes a player to hit the floor and/or commit a violation (OOB). If you're going to have the balls to no-call it, have the bigger balls to call the white player OOB. Doing nothing just looks wrong. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Illegal screen by the offense, and rebounding foul.
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:27am. |