Substitution on throw in position
Had this one last night:
Foul on Team A on a drive to B1 just outside the three point line. I have the whistle from T and indicate ball to the sideline. We were in Cadillac so I have throw-in responsibilities. After reporting foul, A2 subs in for A1 and as I turn to look at the player going out and to ID where the ball is when I notice U2 lining everyone up for a baseline throw in. I get U2's attention and tell him we're on the sideline and he throws the ball to me. Coach A then tells me that he subbed in A2 for the express purpose of a baseline throw in and now that it's a sideline throw in, he wants A1 back in the game. No time ran off the clock so I didn't allow a re-sub. His subsequent play resulted in a layup so he was happy, but he could have really made a stink about it. Would you have allowed the re-sub? |
Sounds OK, with a Caveat
Quote:
Only catch is that a sub must report to the table in time, and, according to 3-3-4, the player he took out must "sit a tick." The other guy who went in doesn't have to "play a tick." Therefore, when you admit that, "No time ran off the clock so I didn't allow a re-sub" appears to be half-right. |
"By the book" answer: Freddy gave it. His sub does not have to play, but the guy he replaced cannot return at this point.
"Game management" answer: if coach made the substitution based on misleading info from the officials, the spirit of fairness would permit him to withdraw the substitution (esp. at lower levels). I might go "by the book" for varsity and "game management" at any lower level. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
"Coach, he can come out, but *he* can't come back in yet. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Divine Intervention ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
A coach need not be quality control for officials' intra-communication errors.
Having certain players perform specialized tasks is a completely valid coaching strategy, and should be expected at higher levels. I'm going to let A1 back in. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
Mississippi used the "Cadillac" positioning for three-man as recently as the 2006-2007 season. I was thoroughly confused by this during my first scrimmage. Thankfully, the powers that be saw the light the next season.
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:21pm. |