Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
Frankly, I think some leagues prefer a zero-tolerance policy on the arm bar for the same reason they ask for it on a hand-check; it's difficult to tell whether the contact impedes the offensive player or merely discourages him to try. |
Okay, I finally got my computer back up (wiped and restored), so I could watch the video.
Play 1. I can't tell from my angle when he gathers, but it looks from my view that it'sl close. I can't see making that call in live play. Play 2. I would have got that on a pivot after a jump stop. |
Quote:
Both offense and defense utilize the arm bar at various times. Therefore we have to determine if the contact is illegal. Your statement implies that the defense only uses the arm bar. |
Quote:
if you cannot tell if the contact impedes play, you cannot call it. it would be considered incidental contact. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
My point with regard to "measuring up" is that it's stupid and not necessary. Why in the world would you need to use your hands to figure out how far you are from a player you an see? Yet I know it's allowed, so I don't call it unless the hand stays on the dribbler. |
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
And I also think that failure to adjust to this lies with the players. Not just Chandler, either, as Marc Gasol had a major issue with this in the final game. |
Quote:
The second is obvious - both feet initially land with ball in hands, then both feet move before the dribble (ball is pushed to ground) begins. Traveling. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
simply touching a player to measure up is not illegal
if you cannot tell if the contact impedes play, you cannot call it. it would be considered incidental contact. Quote:
When the offense initiates contact most defenders will place a forearm between the two bodies to absorb contact. You are saying that the defense is now responsible for the contact? It is part of the normal movement of players during the game. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:34pm. |