The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   First AAU Follies of the Off-Season (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/91514-first-aau-follies-off-season.html)

Scrapper1 Sun Jun 03, 2012 08:57am

First AAU Follies of the Off-Season
 
3 boys AAU games last night, probably 17U.

First game is a blow-out. Losing team player gets fouled during a 3-point try as the horn sounds. Game over. No free throws, as they would not affect the outcome of the game. Losing coach insists the kid gets to shoot his free throws. Says to me "If this was the NBA, he'd get to shoot them". All I could do was shake my head.

As soon as both teams arrive for the second game, I put 4 minutes on the clock for warm-ups (which is specifically provided in the tournament rules). Coach says the game's not scheduled to start till 7:40 and insists we put 6 minutes on the clock for warm-ups. I tell him the rules say 4 minutes, and that's what we're going with. He insists I put up 6 minutes and says he's not putting his team out on the floor till 7:40. I ask him, "Is this really how you want to start this game, fighting over 2 minutes?" He says, "Yes!" So I said, "Well, we're starting at the end of the 4 minutes. We can start with you having 5 guys on the floor, or we can start with them shooting free throws for your T." We started 5-on-5 when at the end of the 4 minutes.

Third game is close, but very low quality play. The score was 8-6 after about 9 minutes of play. Ugh. Early in the game, as the ball is live and in play, I'm Lead watching the 2 post players. B5 bends down and tries to untie A5's shoes. I have never seen this before. I was so surprised, I blew the whistle to say, "Hey, don't do that nonsense". Then realized I probably had to call something. So I T'd him up.

That wasn't even all of the crap in those games. I was very glad to get home.

BillyMac Sun Jun 03, 2012 09:38am

Get Up Every Morning And Something New Happens Every Day ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Scrapper1 (Post 844574)
"If this was the NBA, he'd get to shoot them". All I could do was shake my head.

I would have done more than shake my head: "Coach, it's not the NBA."

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scrapper1 (Post 844574)
The ball is live and in play, I'm Lead watching the 2 post players. B5 bends down and tries to untie A5's shoes. I have never seen this before. I was so surprised, I blew the whistle to say, "Hey, don't do that nonsense". Then realized I probably had to call something. So I T'd him up.

I'm surprised that it took some thought to charge the technical foul. My only hesitation would have been deciding between a "regular" technical foul, and a flagrant technical foul. I probably would have gone with the former.

26 Year Gap Sun Jun 03, 2012 12:50pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scrapper1 (Post 844574)
3 boys AAU games last night, probably 17U.

First game is a blow-out. Losing team player gets fouled during a 3-point try as the horn sounds. Game over. No free throws, as they would not affect the outcome of the game. Losing coach insists the kid gets to shoot his free throws. Says to me "If this was the NBA, he'd get to shoot them". All I could do was shake my head.

As soon as both teams arrive for the second game, I put 4 minutes on the clock for warm-ups (which is specifically provided in the tournament rules). Coach says the game's not scheduled to start till 7:40 and insists we put 6 minutes on the clock for warm-ups. I tell him the rules say 4 minutes, and that's what we're going with. He insists I put up 6 minutes and says he's not putting his team out on the floor till 7:40. I ask him, "Is this really how you want to start this game, fighting over 2 minutes?" He says, "Yes!" So I said, "Well, we're starting at the end of the 4 minutes. We can start with you having 5 guys on the floor, or we can start with them shooting free throws for your T." We started 5-on-5 when at the end of the 4 minutes.

Third game is close, but very low quality play. The score was 8-6 after about 9 minutes of play. Ugh. Early in the game, as the ball is live and in play, I'm Lead watching the 2 post players. B5 bends down and tries to untie A5's shoes. I have never seen this before. I was so surprised, I blew the whistle to say, "Hey, don't do that nonsense". Then realized I probably had to call something. So I T'd him up.

That wasn't even all of the crap in those games. I was very glad to get home.

If you hadn't caught him, he'd have tied his shoes together.

bainsey Sun Jun 03, 2012 03:22pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 844576)
I would have done more than shake my head: "Coach, it's not the NBA."

+1

You'll get rule set confusion like that from time to time. I had a sixth grade rec game a few months ago: Team A scores, goes up four. Coach B requests and is granted the time out, then asks me to advance the ball after the time out.

I explain that rule only exists in the NBA, and the coach concedes, but let me know an official in his previous game allowed that for the other team. :eek:

BillyMac Sun Jun 03, 2012 03:33pm

Three Stooges ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 26 Year Gap (Post 844587)
If you hadn't caught him, he'd have tied his shoes together.

Better yet. How about a good old fashioned hot foot?

Wait? Sorry. I thought this was the Baseball Forum. Never mind.

BillyMac Sun Jun 03, 2012 03:37pm

Migrant Basketball Official ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bainsey (Post 844595)
Let me know an official in his previous game allowed that for the other team.

I hear about this guy all the time here in Connecticut. Now he's working up in Maine? Man. This guy really gets around.

Scrapper1 Sun Jun 03, 2012 04:11pm

I forgot to include that I called 2 intentional fouls from behind during fast-breaks (one shirt-grab, one bear hug).

My partner called an intentional foul for fouling the inbounder. He was going to call it a technical, I had to correct him. During the free throws, I had this conversation with the coach who got the free throws.

Him: Is it a flagrant or a technical?
Me: It's an intentional personal, Coach.
[Long pause]
Him: So is that 2 foul shots or 4?
Me: [rolling eyes] Just 2, Coach.

BillyMac Sun Jun 03, 2012 04:18pm

James 5:11 ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Scrapper1 (Post 844606)
Him: Is it a flagrant or a technical?
Me: It's an intentional personal, Coach.
Him: So is that 2 foul shots or 4?
Me: Just 2, Coach.

Quality of a great basketball official: Having the patience of Job.

BktBallRef Sun Jun 03, 2012 05:55pm

Sounds like we were on the same floor.

26 Year Gap Sun Jun 03, 2012 10:49pm

I swear that some coaches think all of the rules are on that tournament sheet at the table.

Adam Mon Jun 04, 2012 03:47pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by 26 Year Gap (Post 844643)
I swear that some coaches think all of the rules are on that tournament sheet at the table.

Had a coach reach into his bag this summer to try to prove that they only got two TOs for the entire game rather than per half. He never brought it to me, though. Good thing for him that I was right.

Adam Mon Jun 04, 2012 03:48pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bainsey (Post 844595)
+1

You'll get rule set confusion like that from time to time. I had a sixth grade rec game a few months ago: Team A scores, goes up four. Coach B requests and is granted the time out, then asks me to advance the ball after the time out.

I explain that rule only exists in the NBA, and the coach concedes, but let me know an official in his previous game allowed that for the other team. :eek:

Ironically, the only time they seem to know there's a difference between the rule sets is when you count a basket after a foul.

Camron Rust Mon Jun 04, 2012 03:56pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 844752)
Ironically, the only time they seem to know there's a difference between the rule sets is when you count a basket after a foul.

Huh??? What difference? (The only one I can think of is a charge after the release of a shot....counts if it does in NCAA, doesn't count in NFHS).

tref Mon Jun 04, 2012 03:57pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 844752)
Ironically, the only time they seem to know there's a difference between the rule sets is when you count a basket after a foul.

Official: Score the basket, 1 FT.
coach: This isnt the NBA!

2 plays later following a timeout in the 1st half

coach: Dont we get it at halfcourt.
Official: Only in 4thQ under 2 min & its the 28' line... in the NBA!
coach: Well, when do we get to advance in HS?
Official: :rolleyes:

Adam Mon Jun 04, 2012 04:47pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Camron Rust (Post 844754)
Huh??? What difference? (The only one I can think of is a charge after the release of a shot....counts if it does in NCAA, doesn't count in NFHS).

That's why I said "ironically," because they pick the one rule where it's the same and claim "we're not in the NBA." Then, they want traveling called when the shooter catches his airball, they want the ball advanced after a TO, or they want some other NBA rule to be applied.

Adam Mon Jun 04, 2012 04:48pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 844755)
Official: Score the basket, 1 FT.
coach: This isnt the NBA!

2 plays later following a timeout in the 1st half

coach: Dont we get it at halfcourt.
Official: Only in 4thQ under 2 min & its the 28' line... in the NBA!
coach: Well, when do we get to advance in HS?
Official: :rolleyes:

Bingo!

Multiple Sports Wed Jun 06, 2012 09:55am

A classic.....
 
At a Bigshots event in Richmond, Va. over Memorial Day weekend, a player from a team from Baltimore(ever seen "The Wire") that neighborHOOD, came off the bench when one of his players on the court was swinging at a referee.

Well it turned into a HUGE throwdown...cops from VCU and the Richmond PD came into the Siegel Center....

The funniest thing was that one of the kids mother's came down and of course she was saying her kid was not at fault, but she handed the boys child for him to hold while he was being interviewed by the police.....

"Yes officer, when I am not an 18 hoodlum fighting on the basketball court
I am an upstanding father in the community!!!!!"

And in a complete irony, the referee involved in the fight had been assigned to that teams next game!!!! No he didn't work it someone else did...

Raymond Wed Jun 06, 2012 10:12am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Multiple Sports (Post 844965)
At a Bigshots event in Richmond, Va. over Memorial Day weekend, a player from a team from Baltimore(ever seen "The Wire") that neighborHOOD, came off the bench when one of his players on the court was swinging at a referee.

Well it turned into a HUGE throwdown...cops from VCU and the Richmond PD came into the Siegel Center....

The funniest thing was that one of the kids mother's came down and of course she was saying her kid was not at fault, but she handed the boys child for him to hold while he was being interviewed by the police.....

"Yes officer, when I am not an 18 hoodlum fighting on the basketball court
I am an upstanding father in the community!!!!!"

And in a complete irony, the referee involved in the fight had been assigned to that teams next game!!!! No he didn't work it someone else did...

Was he from Hamsterdam? :D

Funny, I was going to work that tournament for the local assignors but I didn't hear back from them in time...glad I missed it. :cool:

Adam Wed Jun 06, 2012 11:23am

VG summer game the other night. After the first game, I'm standing at the table getting ready for the next game and all of a sudden a fan is standing in front of me. He says something about the travels, and I just look at the door. "I'm going anyway, but you need to...." I cut him off, "You need to go." He started to repeat himself before I cut him off again, "Just go."

So many things I wanted to say.

"Don't make me angry, you wouldn't like me when I'm angry."

tref Wed Jun 06, 2012 01:46pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 844977)
VG summer game the other night. After the first game, I'm standing at the table getting ready for the next game and all of a sudden a fan is standing in front of me. He says something about the travels, and I just look at the door. "I'm going anyway, but you need to...." I cut him off

Classes begin in the fall come out & get your certification, then YOU sir, can call all the marginal travels you like in YOUR ballgames :D

Raymond Wed Jun 06, 2012 02:01pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 845003)
Classes begin in the fall come out & get your certification<strike>, then YOU sir, can call all the marginal travels you like in YOUR ballgames</strike> :D

Too much verbiage :cool:

tref Wed Jun 06, 2012 02:07pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 845007)
Too much verbiage :cool:

Real season, I agree... Summer time, I get my point across.

Raymond Wed Jun 06, 2012 03:26pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 845010)
Real season, I agree... Summer time, I get my point across.

When addressing a fan? The season, it matters not.

Adam Wed Jun 06, 2012 03:34pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 845010)
Real season, I agree... Summer time, I get my point across.

I was tempted, but I would have been more likely to use sarcasm.

"So, how long have you officiated?"

Or I could have been sincere,

"Do you really think I need a stranger to come up to me in order to get me to care more about what I'm doing?"

tref Wed Jun 06, 2012 03:38pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 845028)
When addressing a fan? The season, it matters not.

I hear you BNR. I'm a 4-6 nights a week, Jan-Dec kinda guy & I deal with much more BS in the off-season for less pay... so I do what I do.

Welpe Wed Jun 06, 2012 03:41pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 845031)

"Do you really think I need a stranger to come up to me in order to get me to care more about what I'm doing?"

"Go stage your intervention elsewhere."

Adam Wed Jun 06, 2012 03:46pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Welpe (Post 845035)
"Go stage your intervention elsewhere."

I was really tempted to light him up, explaining to him that I was driving 40 miles round trip to work two games for $28, missing another night with my kids. I'm doing these games to get better at what I do.

But, instead, I said, "Just go."

Raymond Wed Jun 06, 2012 03:48pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 845033)
I hear you BNR. I'm a 4-6 nights a week, Jan-Dec kinda guy & I deal with much more BS in the off-season for less pay... so I do what I do.

Personally, I'm not discussing much with fans, winter/summer/spring/or fall. In fact folks must detect the a-hole in me b/c it's been about 7-8 years since I've had a fan come up to me after any type of game.

Conversations with fans are always better when they run into you at Applebee's or TGI Friday's :D

tref Wed Jun 06, 2012 03:51pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 845039)
Personally, I'm not discussing much with fans, winter/summer/spring/or fall. In fact folks must detect the a-hole in me b/c it's been about 7-8 years since I've had a fan come up to me after any type of game.

Conversations with fans are always better when they run into you at Applebee's or TGI Friday's :D

I respect your discipline!

Welpe Wed Jun 06, 2012 03:55pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 845038)
I was really tempted to light him up, explaining to him that I was driving 40 miles round trip to work two games for $28, missing another night with my kids. I'm doing these games to get better at what I do.

But, instead, I said, "Just go."

I know that feeling! When I was working games while my daughter was a newborn, I was ready to tell a few fans to stuff it mainly because I was running on no sleep. :)

Raymond Wed Jun 06, 2012 03:57pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 845041)
I respect your discipline!

Learned long ago that fans really don't give a damn about our rationale/thought process/rules/etc. They just want to vent and/or blame. This lesson was taught to me by a co-worker/friend who is an avid HS sports fan. He'd have D1 officials working his games and I'd still hear how terrible they were.

Lcubed48 Wed Jun 06, 2012 06:02pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 844968)
Was he from Hamsterdam? :D

Funny, I was going to work that tournament for the local assignors but I didn't hear back from them in time...glad I missed it. :cool:

I'm glad that I was in St Louis visiting my grandson, or I might have been there also.

Adam Fri Jun 08, 2012 10:21pm

VB summer tourney, A1 dives for a loose ball, then lays there as B1 and B2 come in and try to grab it. A coach gets a TO called in time.
B coach says it was a travel.
My mistake was responding. "no, it's not."
Coach, "Yeah, you know everything."
Me: :/

bainsey Fri Jun 08, 2012 11:09pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 845045)
Learned long ago that fans really don't give a damn about our rationale/thought process/rules/etc.

I re-learned that lesson yesterday, sitting amongst parents.

As I'm finishing my workout at my office's exercise room, I get a text from my kid (high school junior) that his friends' high school playoff baseball game is going into extra innings, 1-1. This is a little surprising, considering his school was the region's #8 seed playing the #1 seed and top rival. The game is mile away, so I make the quick drive to see the finish.

I sit alone among my town's contingency on the third base side, though surrounded by familiar faces. Maybe I should have taken a spot behind the plate, because it bordered on embarrassing being around some parents. I really don't know why I was surprised -- yelling at the plate ump on balls/strikes (never mind that our position to judge is lousy), yelling at base umpires to "ask for help" (like that ever works), or screaming that a center fielder dropped a ball (not even close!) when making a semi-diving catch. Oh, and yelling at the kid for making the catch! ("You should be ashamed of yourself!") I had to contain myself from pointing out what @$$es they were making of themselves.

Still, it didn't ruin a 3-2 eleventh inning victory, sparked by our star basketball center, er, first baseman, drilling one over the left field fence. I just hope I remember to sit amongst people who aren't motivated solely by their kids' victories.

BillyMac Sat Jun 09, 2012 06:24am

Sportmanship ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bainsey (Post 845376)
Oh,and yelling at the kid for making the catch! ("You should be ashamed of yourself!")

All three of my children participated on various high school sports teams. When I attended their games and an opposing player would make a great play, I would politely clap. I was always the only one in the crowd who applauded. They would all look at me like I was from Mars.

JugglingReferee Sat Jun 09, 2012 10:53am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 845374)
VB summer tourney, A1 dives for a loose ball, then lays there as B1 and B2 come in and try to grab it. A coach gets a TO called in time.
B coach says it was a travel.
My mistake was responding. "no, it's not."
Coach, "Yeah, you know everything."
Me: :/

These types of comments make me chuckle.

The reason why most of us participate in dialogue, go to camp, watch video, etc, is so that we do know things, and can apply the proper ruling.

A phrase I like to use, if I have to, is, "not that one, sir".

BillyMac Sat Jun 09, 2012 03:45pm

John 8:7 ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 845394)
All three of my children participated on various high school sports teams. When I attended their games and an opposing player would make a great play, I would politely clap. I was always the only one in the crowd who applauded. They would all look at me like I was from Mars.

Full disclosure. I will admit that I did occasionally "moan" about a referee's, or umpire's, call. No yelling. No name calling. No disrespect. Just a simple, "Oh, c'mon ump."

Adam Sat Jun 09, 2012 05:30pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 845419)
Full disclosure. I will admit that I did occasionally "moan" about a referee's, or umpire's, call. No yelling. No name calling. No disrespect. Just a simple, "Oh, c'mon ump."

I wondered yesterday how many times I yelled "but he was moving!" after an offensive foul.

Adam Tue Jun 12, 2012 02:54pm

Had to tell a coach last night that if I'm close enough to hear his comments to his AC, then he's talking to me.

Welpe Tue Jun 12, 2012 03:39pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 845693)
Had to tell a coach last night that if I'm close enough to hear his comments to his AC, then he's talking to me.

Rabbit ears. :D

rockyroad Tue Jun 12, 2012 03:42pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 845693)
Had to tell a coach last night that if I'm close enough to hear his comments to his AC, then he's talking to me.

Stop getting so close, then...:D

Adam Tue Jun 12, 2012 03:47pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by rockyroad (Post 845700)
Stop getting so close, then...:D

"So move."
"Know where you're supposed to be."

I ignored those, although the second one came from the AC (my back was turned, but I knew his voice), so I should have probably rang him up.

I was back at the division line for the first of 2 FTs, waiting to call in some subs. And he wasn't using his inside voice.

As I told an airman many years ago when she tried to get mad at me for listening to her conversation, "Don't have a private conversation in public if you don't want others to hear it."

tref Tue Jun 12, 2012 04:08pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 845701)
As I told an airman many years ago when she tried to get mad at me for listening to her conversation, "Don't have a private conversation in public if you don't want others to hear it."

Bingo! I hate when they use the excuse of "not talking to you" while talking about you loud enough for you to hear.

Raymond Tue Jun 12, 2012 09:04pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 845702)
Bingo! I hate when they use the excuse of "not talking to you" while talking about you loud enough for you to hear.

Had one of those a few weeks ago with a coach addressing his player. I told the coach he needs to keep those comments out of my earshot.

ODog Thu Jun 14, 2012 06:40pm

Tourney in CT last weekend:

New partner, never met her before. 1 minute into the game, I'm the trail, a shot bounces on the top of the backboard, falls back into play and my partner (lead on the endline underneath the basket) whistles out of bounds. Ughhh, long day ahead: PCA -- fail; Rules -- fail. At the first timeout, I say, "On that shot a minute or so ago, looked to me like it just bounced on the top of the backboard. What'd you see there?"

"Oh, well I'm from Massachusetts," (so am I) "and up there, top of the backboard is out of bounds." I tried to explain the rule but she just said, "We can do it your way." So we did it "my" way for that game, but be forewarned: she's out there and was unswayed by my attempts at polite reform.

So it's not just the fans, coaches and players, fellas. The horror show is across the board.

Same tourney, different game. A1, inbounding on the endline, passes to a teammate across the free-throw lane, the ball hitting the net as it enters the court. Team B coach asks, "Isn't the net out of bounds?" Just when you think you've heard it all, you discover there's a whole other level of thought you never knew was possible.


I went the sarcasm route -- never advisable -- and said, "That'd make scoring pretty tough, wouldn't it?" and luckily that was the proper tack with this coach, who laughed and gave an "Oh ... right" look.

AAU is like an outlaw society.

26 Year Gap Thu Jun 14, 2012 06:52pm

It had to be.....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ODog (Post 846026)
Tourney in CT last weekend:

New partner, never met her before. 1 minute into the game, I'm the trail, a shot bounces on the top of the backboard, falls back into play and my partner (lead on the endline underneath the basket) whistles out of bounds. Ughhh, long day ahead: PCA -- fail; Rules -- fail. At the first timeout, I say, "On that shot a minute or so ago, looked to me like it just bounced on the top of the backboard. What'd you see there?"

"Oh, well I'm from Massachusetts," (so am I) "and up there, top of the backboard is out of bounds." I tried to explain the rule but she just said, "We can do it your way." So we did it "my" way for that game, but be forewarned: she's out there and was unswayed by my attempts at polite reform.

So it's not just the fans, coaches and players, fellas. The horror show is across the board.

Same tourney, different game. A1, inbounding on the endline, passes to a teammate across the free-throw lane, the ball hitting the net as it enters the court. Team B coach asks, "Isn't the net out of bounds?" Just when you think you've heard it all, you discover there's a whole other level of thought you never knew was possible.


I went the sarcasm route -- never advisable -- and said, "That'd make scoring pretty tough, wouldn't it?" and luckily that was the proper tack with this coach, who laughed and gave an "Oh ... right" look.

AAU is like an outlaw society.

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-j0kzKX3J0V...0/thatgirl.jpg

BillyMac Thu Jun 14, 2012 07:38pm

Benefit Of The Doubt ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ODog (Post 846026)
A1, inbounding on the endline, passes to a teammate across the free-throw lane, the ball hitting the net as it enters the court. Team B coach asks, "Isn't the net out of bounds?".

Maybe he was thinking of the "side baskets" we occasionally see in the "down position" on a few of the courts where we may officiate. Usually with Catholic middle school kids, I say, before handing the ball to the inbounder, "Be careful, that (pointing up) basket is out of bounds." I hate to admit it, but here, in my little corner of Connecticut, we have a few high school courts like that.

Adam Thu Jun 14, 2012 07:48pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by 26 Year Gap (Post 846028)

Impossible. I'be worked with That Girl this summer, and she's not from Massachusetts.

Scrapper1 Thu Jun 14, 2012 08:28pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ODog (Post 846026)
"Oh, well I'm from Massachusetts," (so am I) "and up there, top of the backboard is out of bounds."

Being from MA, I take offense at that. :mad:

ODog Thu Jun 14, 2012 09:26pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scrapper1 (Post 846039)
Being from MA, I take offense at that. :mad:

Yup. As did I.

I think she thought, because we were in Conn., that invoking her out-of-stateness would make me think, "Oh, there must be fundamental differences in the basic rules of basketball from state to state" and cause me to just let her consistently enforce her fantasized rules from outside her PCA.

She wasn't banking on me being from the next town over from her. The MSBOA patch (with the state outline) on my sleeve didn't tip her off that her alibi wouldn't check out. Alas geography, much like basketball, just isn't her thing.

But you'd never convince her of that. She was definitely "that girl," as one of you so eloquently (and visually) put it. Sadly, she was no Marlo Thomas.

Scrapper, if it's any consolation, she wasn't an IAABO official.

Scrapper1 Thu Jun 14, 2012 09:30pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ODog (Post 846047)

Scrapper, if it's any consolation, she wasn't an IAABO official.

It's not a consolation, but it definitely explains a little bit. Not that all IAABO officials know all the rules, but the non-IAABO officials -- in my region, anyway -- are really bad. Really. Bad.

ODog Thu Jun 14, 2012 09:41pm

I hear you. In our neck of the woods, we have two IAABO boards and a "women's" board. I'm not sure what the board's intent was when it first began, but members of this board (who are both male and female, btw) can now officiate both girls and boys high school hoops in our area. And, obviously, those of us on the IAABO boards can also officiate both genders.

So I'm not really sure what the point of the rogue board is, but it's a painfully weak lot, with a few pleasant exceptions.

Maybe someone can help me out here: One of the things they do on "their" board is have the trail stand tableside on free throws, which conflicts directly with our mechanic. I also find it incredibly ineffective because A.) they're right in position to take an earful from the coaches, and B.) they are COMPLETELY oblivious to subs (which might be the case regardless of their position).

I've asked some of the officials on their board why they do this and their answer has consistently been, "That's the NFHS mechanic."

For reasons A and B, if no others, this couldn't possibly be true, could it? Any non-IAABO officials weigh in here?

JetMetFan Thu Jun 14, 2012 11:47pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ODog (Post 846054)
I hear you. In our neck of the woods, we have two IAABO boards and a "women's" board. I'm not sure what the board's intent was when it first began, but members of this board (who are both male and female, btw) can now officiate both girls and boys high school hoops in our area. And, obviously, those of us on the IAABO boards can also officiate both genders.

So I'm not really sure what the point of the rogue board is, but it's a painfully weak lot, with a few pleasant exceptions.

Maybe someone can help me out here: One of the things they do on "their" board is have the trail stand tableside on free throws, which conflicts directly with our mechanic. I also find it incredibly ineffective because A.) they're right in position to take an earful from the coaches, and B.) they are COMPLETELY oblivious to subs (which might be the case regardless of their position).

I've asked some of the officials on their board why they do this and their answer has consistently been, "That's the NFHS mechanic."

For reasons A and B, if no others, this couldn't possibly be true, could it? Any non-IAABO officials weigh in here?

ODog, I think I can help a little.

If you're in Western MA the women's board you're talking about appears to be borrowing from the women's board in NY. In NY you have to be certified separately to work girls' H.S. ball since they/we use modified NCAAW mechanics (you also don't have to be IAABO to be a member of the women's board). Those mechanics include the T going tableside on shooting fouls.

Adam Fri Jun 15, 2012 01:21am

Quote:

Originally Posted by JetMetFan (Post 846076)
ODog, I think I can help a little.

If you're in Western MA the women's board you're talking about appears to be borrowing from the women's board in NY. In NY you have to be certified separately to work girls' H.S. ball since they/we use modified NCAAW mechanics (you also don't have to be IAABO to be a member of the women's board). Those mechanics include the T going tableside on shooting fouls.

I think he's talking about two-whistle mechanics, and I believe they (NFHS) did move to table-side trail on FTs. Three-whistle always has had T tableside anyway.

Rich Fri Jun 15, 2012 02:09am

Quote:

Originally Posted by ODog (Post 846026)
Tourney in CT last weekend:

New partner, never met her before. 1 minute into the game, I'm the trail, a shot bounces on the top of the backboard, falls back into play and my partner (lead on the endline underneath the basket) whistles out of bounds. Ughhh, long day ahead: PCA -- fail; Rules -- fail. At the first timeout, I say, "On that shot a minute or so ago, looked to me like it just bounced on the top of the backboard. What'd you see there?"

"Oh, well I'm from Massachusetts," (so am I) "and up there, top of the backboard is out of bounds." I tried to explain the rule but she just said, "We can do it your way." So we did it "my" way for that game, but be forewarned: she's out there and was unswayed by my attempts at polite reform.

So it's not just the fans, coaches and players, fellas. The horror show is across the board.

Same tourney, different game. A1, inbounding on the endline, passes to a teammate across the free-throw lane, the ball hitting the net as it enters the court. Team B coach asks, "Isn't the net out of bounds?" Just when you think you've heard it all, you discover there's a whole other level of thought you never knew was possible.


I went the sarcasm route -- never advisable -- and said, "That'd make scoring pretty tough, wouldn't it?" and luckily that was the proper tack with this coach, who laughed and gave an "Oh ... right" look.

AAU is like an outlaw society.

Female official? She'll work the state HS finals in about 3 years and have a full D-1 schedule in about 5 and think it's because she's a great official.

amusedofficial Fri Jun 15, 2012 03:13am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Welpe (Post 845044)
I was working games while my daughter was a newborn

I T'd up my daughter when she was seven hours old. 20 years later I still can't call that second one.

BillyMac Fri Jun 15, 2012 06:12am

Diamonds, Daisies, Snowflakes ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 846037)
Impossible. I've worked with That Girl this summer, and she's not from Massachusetts.

Brewster, New York.

ODog Fri Jun 15, 2012 07:46am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 846078)
I think he's talking about two-whistle mechanics, and I believe they (NFHS) did move to table-side trail on FTs. Three-whistle always has had T tableside anyway.

I am indeed talking about a two-whistle game. That's insane to me that any federation would want the T to stand tableside on FTs in a two-whistle setting.

Forget putting yourself in the line of fire of barking coaches. You'll get your share throughout the game regardless of where you're positioned. But having your back turned to the scorer and all of the subs is just stupid.

Welpe Fri Jun 15, 2012 07:48am

Quote:

Originally Posted by 26 Year Gap (Post 846028)

Filling in for Padgett in his absence? :D

Welpe Fri Jun 15, 2012 07:50am

Quote:

Originally Posted by amusedofficial (Post 846084)
I T'd up my daughter when she was seven hours old. 20 years later I still can't call that second one.

I'm teaching mine to signal "T". She's almost there and I think she has the ejection mechanic down more or less.

APG Fri Jun 15, 2012 07:53am

Quote:

Originally Posted by ODog (Post 846113)
I am indeed talking about a two-whistle game. That's insane to me that any federation would want the T to stand tableside on FTs in a two-whistle setting.

Forget putting yourself in the line of fire of barking coaches. You'll get your share throughout the game regardless of where you're positioned. But having your back turned to the scorer and all of the subs is just stupid.

I personally like going tableside...the not being able to see subs/scorer situation is a non issue, because all one had to do is peek over the shoulder to see what needs to be seen and if you miss anything, there's nothing stopping the lead official from beckoning subs in. Texas has been going tableside in two man even before NFHS went to the mechanic.

As far as talking to coaches, I'd rather deal with coaches near me with a quiet word, then have a coach try and yell across the court. When NCAA-M moved their officials opposite after foul calls, I noticed (at least for TV games) that this happened a lot more often.

Welpe Fri Jun 15, 2012 07:55am

Going tableside is all I know but I don't see the big deal about it. It is very rare I've had a coach get to the point of getting T'd up as a result of me being tableside and I think he would have gotten himself stuck anyways.

APG Fri Jun 15, 2012 08:00am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Welpe (Post 846118)
Going tableside is all I know but I don't see the big deal about it. It is very rare I've had a coach get to the point of getting T'd up as a result of me being tableside and I think he would have gotten himself stuck anyways.

Likewise...on it being all I've known and never really having issues with coaches.

Adam Fri Jun 15, 2012 11:16am

Quote:

Originally Posted by ODog (Post 846113)
I am indeed talking about a two-whistle game. That's insane to me that any federation would want the T to stand tableside on FTs in a two-whistle setting.

Forget putting yourself in the line of fire of barking coaches. You'll get your share throughout the game regardless of where you're positioned. But having your back turned to the scorer and all of the subs is just stupid.

I happen to prefer being table side as the calling official. We did that for a couple of years in three-man, but too many officials engaged the coaches too much rather than just when they needed to. I preferred it because it gave the coach a chance to ask the proper questions without yelling or delaying the game during free throws.

As for the T doing subs table-side. That's how it's done with three, and it's not a problem. Take a quick look before and after the last FT, then your eyes are on the play anyway. I don't think it's any harder to take one last glance from either side of the court after the final FT is made.

Adam Fri Jun 15, 2012 11:17am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Welpe (Post 846115)
I'm teaching mine to signal "T". She's almost there and I think she has the ejection mechanic down more or less.

I'll bet she already knows the coach's mechanic for "what was that?"

Welpe Fri Jun 15, 2012 12:29pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 846159)
I'll bet she already knows the coach's mechanic for "what was that?"

Arms extended out perpendicular to the body, palms up, exasperated look on her face? Not quite yet...give her another year or so. :eek:

Raymond Fri Jun 15, 2012 02:28pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 846158)
...
As for the T doing subs table-side. That's how it's done with three, and it's not a problem. Take a quick look before and after the last FT, then your eyes are on the play anyway. I don't think it's any harder to take one last glance from either side of the court after the final FT is made.

Except in 2-man the Trail is supposed to be down watching the free throw shooter and a lot of officials stay way up high to deal with subs and never get down to where they belong.

Adam Fri Jun 15, 2012 05:50pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 846205)
Except in 2-man the Trail is supposed to be down watching the free throw shooter and a lot of officials stay way up high to deal with subs and never get down to where they belong.

Well that's just poor coaching.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:50pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1