![]() |
Out of subs, and a DQ
Team A is down to 5 eligible team members. A1 commits his fifth personal foul. Coach is notified, player is notified. Coach has no subs available, so Team A will continue the game with only 4 players. Coach asks if he still gets his 20 seconds for the replacement period.
Do we give it? |
Quote:
No. MTD, Sr. |
They only have 4, no subs. That being said, whats another 20 seconds? Be compassionate...
|
Quote:
|
And if a coach tells his players to "come over here".....
|
Quote:
Quote:
Does anybody think this is a bad approach? |
If I were the coach I'd say I have an available sub in the locker room putting his shoes on... then say he's become sick and is no longer available.
|
Quote:
I think I'd find a middle path: "No, I can't give you the 20 seconds, coach, but it might take me 20 seconds to get ready to put the ball in play." Not that this is decisive, but what's the other coach going to say about that, that I'm slow? |
Why?
I don't see anything about having to have an eligible substitute to give the time? All I see if a player is disqualified and we shall direct the timer to give a maximum of 20 seconds.
The fact that the coach has no eligible substitutes doesn't stop him/her from having the allotted time to determine he has no eligible substitutes. 3-12-5 |
Quote:
Somebody ripped some pages out of my book :eek: |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Had a disqualification this past Saturday. NCAA-M rules, so calling official went opposite and I came tableside. Before I even had a chance to finish sentence "Coach, that's 5 on..." the coach already had a sub at the table and says "I know, thanks, that's his sub". As I beckon the sub on the OPPOSING coach calls his players over and I have tell him "Let's go coach, sub is already in". Definitely caught him off-guard that I wouldn't allow him to huddle. |
Let's Go To The Rulebook ...
Quote:
seconds (maximum) permitted for replacing a disqualified or injured player, or for a player directed to leave the game. |
Rulz Is Rulz ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
While I agree that the time is there for a replacement, who cares what the coach is really using that time for? In most cases the coach doesn't need 20 seconds and they know who the sub is prior to us starting the clock. But they almost always bring their kids over and have a quick word, then finally send the kid in to sub. JMO |
Quote:
And, if a player is added to the book, then s/he is in the game, and the "replacement interval" is over. OF course, the coach can talk to the team while the FTs are being shot. ;) |
Quote:
I can't remember exactly where the ruling appeared. It was: No sub available = no replacement period Just get the game underway after removing the DQ'd player. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Meaning he isn't getting a free 20 second TO. MTD, Sr. |
There's a mechanism available if a coach wants to talk to his team. ITS CALLED A TIMEOUT. By letting him steal a 30, gives him an unfair advantage and makes us look like we are playing favorites.
|
Quote:
And why would the other team not be able to talk to their players during this interval? This would be the only reason that it would look like favorites. The referee's just called a foul that disqualified a player, I doubt anyone will say "Man that referee sure does like that team, they keep calling fouls on them.":confused: |
Quote:
|
If the official isn't aware that no replacements are available, then that is a slightly different situation.
You can only act upon what you know. Most coaches will quickly say, "I don't have anyone else" or something similar. When you learn that, you resume play immediately. Now it may be the case that a player was injured earlier in the contest and the coach may go see if he can return at this time. I have no problem allowing for some time for him to determine that. |
The King Is Dead, Long Live The King ...
Quote:
|
Here's NFHS 10-5-2:
The head coach shall replace or remove a disqualified/injured player, or player directed to leave the game, within 20 seconds when a substitute is available. and NCAA 10-4-5/10-6-2g The head coach shall replace a disqualified or injured player within 20 seconds when a substitute is available. It's in the penalty section but both codes specify replacing a disqualified player when a substitute is available. I had this happen in a D-3 game last season. The home team had five players. One fouled out about 10 minutes into the second half. The coach asked for the 20 seconds and the official closest to her said "no, you don't have any subs" and we played on. I know we want to be charitable at times but there really isn't any gray area given the way the rule is written. Besides, we're just opening up a can of worms in terms of dealing with the other coach. As for the coach potentially saying there's another player in the locker room, let's think: before the game don't we tell the scorekeeper to write down the name of anyone who might show up/play? I know I do. In that game where the team had five players we asked beforehand if they thought anyone else would show. What I'm saying is a response like "there's another player in the locker room" shouldn't even be on the table. We should know if someone has a chance of showing up. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I'll have to use that as my excuse for being unable to pinpoint some rulings recently. I'll be fine by the time that I take the court for postseason. |
More Players In Book Than On Floor ???
Quote:
|
Signed, Epstein's Mother ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Any game played using NFHS or NCAA Rules: A team can always have more names in the book than the number of players they initially have dressed on the bench.
MTD, Sr, |
Quote:
Play #4 - Before the game the referee notes that there are 11 team members of Team A warming up. However, there are twelve names in the scorebook. When the referee asks the coach about this, he says that one player missed the bus. The referee orders the player's name and number removed from the book stating that an individual must be present to have their name entered in the book. Was the referee correct? Answer: The referee was NOT correct. Although the definition of team member implies that the individual must be present to be entered in the scorebook, it was not the intent of the NFHS to prohibit the inclusion of individuals in the scorebook who may be late or may not show up. (References: Rule 3.2.1, NFHS Interpretation) I ask if anyone else is showing up - especially when a team has few players on the court - to prevent handing out technical fouls later on. By the same token, when a scorekeeper - usally a kid - tells me "so and so" isn't going to play so I'm not putting them in, I tell them to put them in the scorebook. You never know what could happen. What if a fight breaks out and kid #14, 15 or even 16 on the bench has to play? To me it's a way of stopping trouble before it starts. Which brings me back to the scenario of the coach saying "someone is in the locker room." Well, they're not on the bench and they're not in the book so why make touble for ourselves by waiting for this 'phantom' player? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Please Don't Make Me Look It Up, I Have Over 30 Years Of Refresher Exams On File ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
To be honest I can't believe an IAABO Board Interpreter would make such an interpetation. If the interpreter had just asked Peter Webb, he would have set him straight because the NFHS (and NCAA) intepretation is actually an interpretation that goes back to the NBCUSC days, meaning over 50 years. MTD, Sr. |
Quote:
|
That IAABO ruling from 2005
Found it. From 2005. (This is Billy Mac's post.)
Missed The Bus <hr style="color:#D1D1E1; background-color:#D1D1E1" size="1"> 2005 IAABO Refresher Exam 73) Squad member #45 missed the bus and is not present at the time the squad list and starting lineup must be submitted for team members. During the pregame warm up, the referee counts eleven team members for team A, but while checking the book, team A has twelve team members listed. Referee informs the coach that the squad member who is not present may not be placed in the book, even if he/she will get to the game late. Is the referee correct? 73) Yes: Rule 3, Section 2, Article 1, Rule 4, Section 34, Article 4. Almost every one in my local board got this question wrong. We disagreed with the answer and citation then, and we still disagree with the answer and citation. If I recall, we got some type of explanation involving the definition of a "team member" involving a squad member being ready and eligible to play. When I'm the referee, I'm pleased to see that there are more names in the book than there are on the floor during warmups. During the 25 years that I coached middle school basketball, I would put all 14 of my team members' names and numbers, in numerical order, in the book for every game, even if I knew that they would miss the game due to injury or illness. |
I coach high school basketball....here is what happened to me earlier this year.
I handed my scorebook to the scorekeeper. During pre-game one of the referees counts that I have 15 in the book, but only 13 in uniform. He makes the scorekeeper cross out (or white out) those kids not in uniform. One of them was injured, but the other was actually sick and I didn't know if he would play or not. Is this right? |
Nope
|
Quote:
Quote:
While he's wrong, I wouldn't argue too much. Just report it to your state org for them to deal with after the game. |
I didn't argue it... because I wasn't even notified of it. I didn't know about it until after the game when I noticed the names whited out of my book. So I asked my scorekeeper who told me the referee told him to do it. I am going to report it to the state org just so it isn't done again. Thanks for the help.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
One of my mentors - who is now one of my assignors - told a bunch of us years ago that sometimes we're our own worst enemies on the court because we think too much. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Does it matter if the player is in street clothes behind the bench and you are not intending on playing him because of injury?
Also, if the state backs the ref that's fine... I just want to know the rule for future reference. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Thanks again. |
Misty Water Colored Memories ...
Quote:
An important reminder. This was not a NFHS refresher exam, nor was it a 2005 NFHS interpretation. It's 100% IAABO. Was Peter Webb the IAABO interpreter in 2005? |
Let's Go To The Videotape ...
Quote:
shall supply the official scorer with the name and number of each team member and designate the five starting players. Failure to comply results in a technical foul (see 10-1-1 Penalty). 4-34-4: A team member is a member of bench personnel who is in uniform and is eligible to become a player. |
Broken Flux Capacitor ...
Quote:
|
The Whole Nine Yards ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
2009-2010 Week 4 It is from an IAABO board in South Carolina. |
Quote:
Rosters aren't my business, I only make sure no names are added after the 10 minute mark without penalty. To do that, we check to make sure there are at least as many names as bodies warming up. If not, I will assume players are either in the locker room, on the way, partying in Vegas, or flying to the moon. I'm not even asking. |
What's It Gonna Be Boy (Meatloaf) ???
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
IAABO is a basketball officials association no different from any other official association. The best way to describe it is that it is comparable to the California Basketball Officials Association (CBOA). It is a large association with many Local Boards just like the CBOA. Its members officiate at the high school (NFHS), college (NCAA Men's/Women's), international (FIBA), and professional (NBA/WNBA).
The idea of an IAABO interpretation is just as illogical as the idea of a CBOA interpretation or a Wood Co. Bkb. Off. Assn. interpretation. Every Fall the Rules Editors of the NFHS and NCAA Men's Rules Committees address the Interpreters of the Local Boards of IAABO because IAABO Interpreters just like all interpreters of any other local officials associations are obligated to issue interpretations that are true to the appropriate rules set. MTD, Sr. |
Quote:
Doing the championship in a "Small School Showcase" up here a few weeks ago. A player fouls out and the coach says that he wants his timeout. I told the coach he needed to replace the player first. Coach says ok and provides a sub.. I then ask if he wants a 30 or 60 and he flips! He says he doesn't want to use a charged time out he just wants to huddle with his players during the DQ... I inform him why that isn't permissible and off we go but the coach had clearly never heard that rule before... or any other for that matter... |
Quote:
:rolleyes: |
Quote:
When IAABO makes its exams and they put a screwy question on there that isn't addressed by any NFHS case play, the answer they provide (supposedly for ALL members) is the IAABO interpretation of that play. That's not illogical, that's a fact. It's how they expect their members to call that play. The fact that those screwy interpretations aren't collected into one IAABO Case Book doesn't imply that they are not still interpretations of those plays. Quote:
|
In My Little Corner Of Connecticut, We Choose Not To Follow This Rule ...
Quote:
3-2-1: At least 10 minutes before the scheduled starting time, each team shall supply the official scorer with the name and number of each team member. 4-34-4: A team member is a member of bench personnel who is in uniform and is eligible to become a player. Maybe you meant to say that the rules do not address who's not allowed to be entered into the book. |
Quote:
Absent a case ruling, there is no official ruling here. Give them the 20 seconds. |
I agree that the rule itself seems to not allow for the time without an actual replacement, but there is room for interpretation here. In the absence of a ruling, go with what your locals say, or your instinct. Personally, I'm not inclined to give him a free time out just because his player fouked out.
|
Quote:
|
Hall Of Famer ???
Quote:
Quote:
|
Why Can't They Be Like We Were, Perfect In Every Way ???
Quote:
If kids wouldn't miss the bus, we wouldn't be having this debate. What's the matter with kids today? We never missed this bus. We walked to all of our games, home, and away, in the snow, in our short shorts, uphill, both ways. |
Quote:
|
Missed The Bus ...
Quote:
IAABO Board 403 Catawba River (South Carolina) Basketball Officials Association: I have recently been made aware of an interpretation on the IAABO Board 403 Catawba River (South Carolina) Basketball Officials Association website. It appears under the heading 2009-2010, Plays of the Week, Week 4: Play #4 - Before the game the referee notes that there are eleven team members of Team A warming up. However, there are twelve names in the scorebook. When the referee asks the coach about this, he says that one player missed the bus. The referee orders the player's name and number removed from the book stating that an individual must be present to have their name entered in the book. Was the referee correct? Answer: The referee was not correct. Although the definition of team member implies that the individual must be present to be entered in the scorebook, it was not the intent of the NFHS to prohibit the inclusion of individuals in the scorebook who may be late or may not show up. (References: Rule 3.2.1, NFHS Interpretation) This rule interpretation appears to be in direct opposition to an interpretation that appeared on the 2005 IAABO Refresher Exam: 73) Squad member #45 missed the bus and is not present at the time the squad list and starting lineup must be submitted for team members. During the pregame warm up, the referee counts eleven team members for team A, but while checking the book, team A has twelve team members listed. Referee informs the coach that the squad member who is not present may not be placed in the book, even if he/she will get to the game late. Is the referee correct? 73) Yes: Rule 3, Section 2, Article 1, Rule 4, Section 34, Article 4. Here are the citations listed: 3-2-1: At least ten minutes before the scheduled starting time, each team shall supply the official scorer with the name and number of each team member and designate the five starting players. Failure to comply results in a technical foul (see 10-1-1 Penalty). 4-34-4: A team member is a member of bench personnel who is in uniform and is eligible to become a player. Almost every one in my local board got this question wrong. We disagreed with the answer, and citation, back in 2005, and we still disagree with the answer, and citation. When I'm the referee, I'm pleased to see that there are more names in the book than there are on the floor during warmups. The opposite, more players on the floor than in the book, can, obviously, present problems. If I recall, IAABO "International" gave us some type of explanation involving the definition of a team member as a squad member being in uniform and eligible to play. My local interpreter disagreed with this interpretation, and locally, we still allow more names in the book than on the floor, but that may not be the correct IAABO "International" interpretation, nor may it be the correct NFHS interpretation. As far as I know, we, here in Connecticut, have never been "officially" informed by IAABO "International", or the NFHS, of any other interpretation. As far as we know, the refresher exam answer still represents the "Law Of The Land", a "Law" that we, under the rational guidance of our local interpreter, have chosen to ignore. I am not disagreeing with the interpretation on your website. I actually like your interpretation, it "fits" what we're actually doing here in Connecticut. Rather, I would like to know what your IAABO Board 403 Catawba River (South Carolina) Basketball Officials Association interpretation is based on? Have you received a new, i.e., newer than 2005, interpretation from either IAABO "International", or from the NFHS, and if so, could you please share that information with me? Here's their response: Regarding this play quite a few questions had been generated to the NFHS about the change that led to the situation where you couldn't have more names on the scorebook roster. As a result the NFHS issued a supplementary case play on their website. This case play never made it to the Case Book. The wording in the answer was lifted directly from that case play. Anybody got the "supplementary case play" in context? C'mon Nevadaref. "Now go do that voodoo that you do so well." |
Quote:
I searched the NFHS website for a case play with the word "bus" and did not find any. I don't doubt the IAABO board in South Carolina...but I would really prefer a ruling that includes a date, link, PDF file...anything specific. I am fairly sure this would have been seen by others...including many members of this forum. The interpretation is fine...and it is the one I am using. But if someone says it comes from a NFHS ruling, I sure would like to see that ruling. |
BayStateRef and BillyMac
I don't ever remember reading a Casebook Play or Approved Ruling that requires only names of the players who are present to be in the Scorebook. There has never been any rule in the NBCUSC, NFHS, and NCAA Rules Books that have prohibited the number of names in the Scorebook.
MTD, Sr. |
Quote:
There has been an IAABO test question on this (as Billy and I have shown.) You say it is wrong. It would not be the first time. I'd just like to see a definitive answer to what seems to be a simple question. |
Missed The Bus, Again ...
Quote:
For you lucky non-IAABO guys, "Move along. There's nothing to see here". What happens in IAABO, stays in IAABO. |
Pepperidge Farm Remembers ...
Quote:
I realize that it's not a "Casebook Play or Approved Ruling, but it does, or did, carry some weight among IAABO members. 73) Squad member #45 missed the bus and is not present at the time the squad list and starting lineup must be submitted for team members. During the pregame warm up, the referee counts eleven team members for team A, but while checking the book, team A has twelve team members listed. Referee informs the coach that the squad member who is not present may not be placed in the book, even if he/she will get to the game late. Is the referee correct? 73) Yes: Rule 3, Section 2, Article 1, Rule 4, Section 34, Article 4. 3-2-1: At least ten minutes before the scheduled starting time, each team shall supply the official scorer with the name and number of each team member and designate the five starting players. Failure to comply results in a technical foul (see 10-1-1 Penalty). 4-34-4: A team member is a member of bench personnel who is in uniform and is eligible to become a player. |
Quote:
Billy: I remember getting the 2005 IAABO Refresher Exam. BUT, here in Ohio members of Board #55 were not required to take the exam because Ohio was not then and still is not an IAABO state (:(). The answer given for Question #73 probably didn't register with me because I knew it to be wrong and that somebody else would notify IAABO. I received that Refresher Exam in early October 2004. I did not attend the Fall Interpreters Meeting in Cape Cod that year (last weekend of Sep. 2004). Junior was a FR in H.S., Andy was in 6th grade, Bonnie was attending college at night to finish her bachelor's degree, and she and I were both very active as volunteers with the various committees within the Toledo Public Schools, not to mention I had a full schedule of boys' and girls' H.S. soccer games that Fall as well as a full schedule of Fall baseball and fastpitch softball games. I am sure I went through the exam and made notes (I am not climbing up into the attic to check what notes I made, :p.) but I really didn't take umbrage over the mistake because I was sure that somebody would correct it eventually. MTD, Sr. P.S. Yes, and I do forget where I put car keys because I am a doddering bald old geezer. LOL |
What Goes Up, Must Come Back Down ...
Quote:
|
I've Been Searchin' So Long To Find An Answer (Chicago) ...
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:01pm. |