The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   chicken wing? (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/61215-chicken-wing.html)

fullor30 Wed Jan 26, 2011 01:16pm

chicken wing?
 
Talked with an official friend who had a big game last night and was approached by coach to look out for an opposing player who 'chicken wings' down low. Never heard that term before. Offensive player has defender on his back and extends arms back virtually locking him in. IMHO a tough call to make if pressure isn't much on defender. Friend eventually called a double foul as defender had his knee up players behind. Seems like the right call to end jostling underneath.

A team control hold call may be in order? Anyone ever have this call?

My question is, I see it from time to time. How to call it.
Advantage disadvantage? Early on, "knock it off" verbal warning? Typical play seems to be arms back and defender trying to push through or throw A aside

HTBT probably applies but thought I'd toss it out there.

Adam Wed Jan 26, 2011 01:19pm

If the defender isn't attempting to get around the offensive player, it seems like nothing. If he is, and it stops him, easy TC call (if you're looking at it).

Loudwhistle Wed Jan 26, 2011 01:25pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 721884)
If the defender isn't attempting to get around the offensive player, it seems like nothing. If he is, and it stops him, easy TC call (if you're looking at it).

+1 Just had this same call in my last game. A little earlier in the game I had yelled at the kid to quit holding.

tref Wed Jan 26, 2011 01:32pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Loudwhistle (Post 721886)
+1 Just had this same call in my last game. A little earlier in the game I had yelled at the kid to quit holding.

Did the opposing coach ask if you were gonna coach his kid too?

Loudwhistle Wed Jan 26, 2011 01:44pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 721890)
Did the opposing coach ask if you were gonna coach his kid too?

No,
I'm pretty consistent at the beginning of all my games to say it on both ends. This sometimes sets the tone so rough play doesn't escalate. As time goes by, (the last 30 years) basketball is getting to be way more physical, unfortunately in my opinion, bball should not resemble football, I've always believed bball is more of a game of finesse. 30 years ago way less contact was allowed especially with screens and blocking out.

bob jenkins Wed Jan 26, 2011 01:45pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by fullor30 (Post 721880)
Talked with an official friend who had a big game last night and was approached by coach to look out for an opposing player who 'chicken wings' down low. Never heard that term before. Offensive player has defender on his back and extends arms back virtually locking him in. IMHO a tough call to make if pressure isn't much on defender. Friend eventually called a double foul as defender had his knee up players behind. Seems like the right call to end jostling underneath.

A team control hold call may be in order? Anyone ever have this call?

My question is, I see it from time to time. How to call it.
Advantage disadvantage? Early on, "knock it off" verbal warning? Typical play seems to be arms back and defender trying to push through or throw A aside

HTBT probably applies but thought I'd toss it out there.

It's holding / hooking and is called / judged the same way as any other action that impedes movement.

Loudwhistle Wed Jan 26, 2011 01:48pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 721900)
It's holding / hooking and is called / judged the same way as any other action that impedes movement.

Had a BV game last week, and the coach yelled out to me, "hey watch it out there, my guys are getting ocean waved!" WTH does that mean? I interepreted it to mean that his guys were getting plowed over, but I sure didn't see it, my partners didn't either.

tref Wed Jan 26, 2011 01:49pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Loudwhistle (Post 721899)
No,
I'm pretty consistent at the beginning of all my games to say it on both ends. This sometimes sets the tone so rough play doesn't escalate. As time goes by, (the last 30 years) basketball is getting to be way more physical, unfortunately in my opinion, bball should not resemble football, I've always believed bball is more of a game of finesse. 30 years ago way less contact was allowed especially with screens and blocking out.

I agree, but generic terms such as "straight" or "easy" arent directed to the O or D & is less subject to being interpreted as coaching.

I'm sure the coach of the kid being chicken winged wanted the foul...

chartrusepengui Wed Jan 26, 2011 02:13pm

happens a lot around here. Tweet - team foul - hold.

They learn quick. If I see it starting again I might say "straight up" once. Then if they need the hard lesson we can do it all over again.

APG Wed Jan 26, 2011 07:04pm

The "chicken wing" I was envisioning is the play where the post player does a drop step/spin move and in the process uses an elbow out at the side to get past the defender.

But to the OP, I have called this before. If the defender is attempting to get around the offense player, it's an easy foul going the other way. If the defender is content with his position, then I have nothing.

chymechowder Wed Jan 26, 2011 11:02pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Loudwhistle (Post 721904)
Had a BV game last week, and the coach yelled out to me, "hey watch it out there, my guys are getting ocean waved!" WTH does that mean? I interepreted it to mean that his guys were getting plowed over, but I sure didn't see it, my partners didn't either.

"It's fun to find out what makes an ocean wave wave!"

anyone from Massachusetts remember this museum of science commercial? :)

YouTube - Museum of Science Vintage Commercial

(copyright 1977? :eek: omg, i'm old)

BktBallRef Thu Jan 27, 2011 12:31am

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 721907)
I agree, but generic terms such as "straight" or "easy" arent directed to the O or D & is less subject to being interpreted as coaching.

You're overanalyzing it. Absolutely nothing wrong with "Don't push!" "Don't hold," "Get out of the lane." It preventive officiating. It's got nothing to do with coaching.

mbyron Thu Jan 27, 2011 09:06am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BktBallRef (Post 722158)
You're overanalyzing it. Absolutely nothing wrong with "Don't push!" "Don't hold," "Get out of the lane." It preventive officiating. It's got nothing to do with coaching.

Agree. Compare: "get open in the post" or "set a pick." One is about avoiding fouls and violations, which we enforce; the other is about strategy and tactics.

tref Thu Jan 27, 2011 10:26am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BktBallRef (Post 722158)
You're overanalyzing it. Absolutely nothing wrong with "Don't push!" "Don't hold," "Get out of the lane." It preventive officiating. It's got nothing to do with coaching.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 722227)
Agree. Compare: "get open in the post" or "set a pick." One is about avoiding fouls and violations, which we enforce; the other is about strategy and tactics.

I guess its all about where one lives, the levels one works & who one works for...

I've been taught "dont" & "get" suggests to one of the coaches that something illegal is happening & leads to "just call the foul/violation!!"

Speaking directly to the defense, "dont hold" is coaching the defense out of a foul in some peoples opinion. "Easy" or "straight" is less subjective. You could be talking to either or both players.

That being said, I'm all for preventitive officiating. I just do it in a different manner.

Welpe Thu Jan 27, 2011 10:32am

Purely out of curiosity, how do you encourage players out of the paint?

tref Thu Jan 27, 2011 10:49am

Up until last Saturday I would simply say "lane" but someone at a level I aspire to work told me "not to trouble trouble."

We were watching the womens game prior to our game from the top of the arena & you could hear the lead say "lane" way up there. Like clockwork, the fans then the coach start screaming for 3 seconds & a whistle as a shot goes up.

His thinking is, we have more than enough junk going on out there to be adding our own junk into the game.
If the ball is up high in the f/c & he's in the lane for a bit... SO WHAT!
Once the fans start screaming "3 seconds" that will be his encouragement to move.
Let the coach/fans get players out of the lane for you, was the mindset here.

fullor30 Thu Jan 27, 2011 10:53am

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 722250)
I guess its all about where one lives, the levels one works & who one works for...

I've been taught "dont" & "get" suggests to one of the coaches that something illegal is happening & leads to "just call the foul/violation!!"

Speaking directly to the defense, "dont hold" is coaching the defense out of a foul in some peoples opinion. "Easy" or "straight" is less subjective. You could be talking to either or both players.

That being said, I'm all for preventitive officiating. I just do it in a different manner.

I'll say 'watch the lane' or 'watch the hands' in first few minutes of game at BOTH ends, after that, they're on their own.

addendum: to your comment, I'm certainly not yelling anything that can be heard outside of a small area such as the paint.

tref Thu Jan 27, 2011 11:00am

Quote:

Originally Posted by fullor30 (Post 722259)
I'll say 'watch the lane' or 'watch the hands' in first few minutes of game at BOTH ends, after that, they're on their own.

Right! You're L on As end & you say "watch the lane" so the player moves, no whistle. Your partner the T who doesnt use any verbal on the court (OOB just points no color, travel just a signal & point) becomes the new L on the next play & gives no warning, just hits em with a 3 seconds... how fair is that to Team B?

fullor30 Thu Jan 27, 2011 11:14am

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 722263)
Right! You're L on As end & you say "watch the lane" so the player moves, no whistle. Your partner the T who doesnt use any verbal on the court (OOB just points no color, travel just a signal & point) becomes the new L on the next play & gives no warning, just hits em with a 3 seconds... how fair is that to Team B?

Other than kids games, I don't work two man, so I may say it as a C also. Anybody can say watch the hands.

I'm not obligated to ensure both teams hear my watch the lane comment. They know the rules. I'm responsible for my area, and that's what I choose to do. By the way, sometimes I say nothing, depends if I'm in a philanthropic mood. Also if post player on defense hears first 'watch the lane' I'm assuming it registers with him when he's on offense.

.

tref Thu Jan 27, 2011 11:23am

Quote:

Originally Posted by fullor30 (Post 722268)
Other than kids games, I don't work two man, so I may say it as a C also. Anybody can say watch the hands.

I'm not obligated to ensure both teams hear my watch the lane comment. They know the rules. I'm responsible for my area, and that's what I choose to do. By the way, sometimes I say nothing, depends if I'm in a philanthropic mood. Also if post player on defense hears first 'watch the lane' I'm assuming it registers with him when he's on offense.

.

Hey, I'm not arguing who/whats right. What you do works for you & Im trying something new.

Rich Thu Jan 27, 2011 11:34am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Welpe (Post 722255)
Purely out of curiosity, how do you encourage players out of the paint?

A 3-second violation will get the point across, for certain. :D

I went 2 seasons without calling one. I've called 5 this year already.

fullor30 Thu Jan 27, 2011 11:42am

Quote:

Originally Posted by RichMSN (Post 722275)
A 3-second violation will get the point across, for certain. :D

I went 2 seasons without calling one. I've called 5 this year already.

All I know is every time I'm drawn to a potential 3 second call, I miss something. Murphy's law.

Don't make it your favorite call, as the saying goes, is so true.

dsqrddgd909 Thu Jan 27, 2011 11:47am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Loudwhistle (Post 721899)
No,
I'm pretty consistent at the beginning of all my games to say it on both ends. This sometimes sets the tone so rough play doesn't escalate. As time goes by, (the last 30 years) basketball is getting to be way more physical, unfortunately in my opinion, bball should not resemble football, I've always believed bball is more of a game of finesse. 30 years ago way less contact was allowed especially with screens and blocking out.

+1^9 (Wait that's still 1) Could not agree more.

Welpe Thu Jan 27, 2011 11:53am

Quote:

Originally Posted by tref (Post 722257)
Up until last Saturday I would simply say "lane" but someone at a level I aspire to work told me "not to trouble trouble."

We were watching the womens game prior to our game from the top of the arena & you could hear the lead say "lane" way up there. Like clockwork, the fans then the coach start screaming for 3 seconds & a whistle as a shot goes up.

His thinking is, we have more than enough junk going on out there to be adding our own junk into the game.
If the ball is up high in the f/c & he's in the lane for a bit... SO WHAT!
Once the fans start screaming "3 seconds" that will be his encouragement to move.
Let the coach/fans get players out of the lane for you, was the mindset here.

Interesting. That is different than what I've been told but I will keep this in mind.

tref Thu Jan 27, 2011 12:02pm

Yeah, the source is a DI official who was slumming on a JUCO game with me... but he worked it like a Final Four game. I gotta listen & apply that advice!

Jurassic Referee Thu Jan 27, 2011 02:10pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by RichMSN (Post 722275)
A 3-second violation will get the point across, for certain. :D

I went 2 seasons without calling one. I've called 5 this year already.

They're no different than technical foul calls. If it's there, call it. And don't analyze it unless you're sure you can learn something from it. And don't make up excuses not to call it.

I've seen several 3-second calls in D1 games this year. Life as we know it went on.

Welpe Thu Jan 27, 2011 02:10pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee (Post 722373)
They're no different than technical foul calls. If it's there, call it. And don't analyze it unless you're sure you can learn something from it. And don't make up excuses not to call it.

I've seen several 3-second calls in D1 games this year. Life as we know it went on.

Hey if there are NBA officials calling it.... ;)

Loudwhistle Thu Jan 27, 2011 03:09pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by fullor30 (Post 722259)
I'll say 'watch the lane' or 'watch the hands' in first few minutes of game at BOTH ends, after that, they're on their own.

addendum: to your comment, I'm certainly not yelling anything that can be heard outside of a small area such as the paint.

Exactly my style!

Rich Thu Jan 27, 2011 03:10pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee (Post 722373)
They're no different than technical foul calls. If it's there, call it. And don't analyze it unless you're sure you can learn something from it. And don't make up excuses not to call it.

I've seen several 3-second calls in D1 games this year. Life as we know it went on.

Exactly right. In the games I've worked players seem to know to get in and out of the lane. When they don't, I call the violation. I'm not much for talking players out, have to say, as I don't see a lot of problems with this in the first place.

I'm not looking to make it my best call, either. I had a coach tell me that a player's toe on the weak side was over the lane line for more than 3 seconds and I was left completely speechless.

Adam Thu Jan 27, 2011 03:18pm

We're expected to talk them out of the lane here, but I'm not turning into Chatty Kathy to do it. I'll say "lane" once, but I have found a 3 second call is far more effective.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:50am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1