The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Legally Equipped? Why Do We Ask? (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/59417-legally-equipped-why-do-we-ask.html)

Kingsman1288 Wed Oct 20, 2010 03:59am

Quote:

Originally Posted by chseagle (Post 697146)
So what would happen if a parent or other spectator mentions to you about a player being in the game with an illegal item? Are you going to tell them the same thing? "It's none of your concern, just watch the game".

Show me documentation otherwise that says that the table crew are not part of the officiating crew then your argument MIGHT stand a chance.

1) I wouldn't even say that to them. I pay no attention to what comes from the stands.

2) Have you ever read 2-11 or 2-12? Show me where it gives you all these powers you seem to think it gives you.

grunewar Wed Oct 20, 2010 04:30am

Ho Hum....
 
I purposely avoided "the Eagle" confrontation, but knew others would pick up the chase......

Kingsman1288 Wed Oct 20, 2010 04:38am

Quote:

Originally Posted by grunewar (Post 697149)
I purposely avoided "the Eagle" confrontation, but knew others would pick up the chase......

Never actually took part in one so I decided to give it a shot today :D

chseagle Wed Oct 20, 2010 05:32am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kingsman1288 (Post 697148)
1) I wouldn't even say that to them. I pay no attention to what comes from the stands.

2) Have you ever read 2-11 or 2-12? Show me where it gives you all these powers you seem to think it gives you.

So what if that parent gets overly irate at you for not allowing their child to play? (comes out of the stands & gets in face or raises such a ruckus play has to be suspended)

No where am I saying "All powerful", everything I have done is as an assistance to the floor officials, not a hinderance. I always review things in my mind before doing them. I know how not to overstep the boundaries.

chseagle Wed Oct 20, 2010 05:37am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kingsman1288 (Post 697148)
1) I wouldn't even say that to them. I pay no attention to what comes from the stands.

2) Have you ever read 2-11 or 2-12? Show me where it gives you all these powers you seem to think it gives you.

2-11 & 2-12 talk about duties only, not responsibilities. An official (no matter if they're on the field of play or off the field) has a responsibility to safety/security of those participating in the contest (no matter a player, coach/bench personnel, or fans).

chseagle Wed Oct 20, 2010 05:40am

Quote:

Originally Posted by grunewar (Post 697149)
I purposely avoided "the Eagle" confrontation, but knew others would pick up the chase......

Feel free to join in, the more the merrier LMAO :D:cool:

Kingsman1288 Wed Oct 20, 2010 05:59am

Quote:

Originally Posted by chseagle (Post 697153)
So what if that parent gets overly irate at you for not allowing their child to play? (comes out of the stands & gets in face or raises such a ruckus play has to be suspended).

So officials are now supposed to answer questions/comments/concerns from the stands on why little Johnny/Sally didn't get to play? That's the coaches job, not ours. Or did I miss that POE this year? If they do decide to do something that dumb, it's bye-bye for them.

While you may think you're being helpful, IMO you're being an annoyance by overstepping your duties. Let us do our job, and you do yours. If you're so concerned with everything else, step out on the floor and put on the stripes and a whistle. I would be more than happy to work a game with you.

BillyMac Wed Oct 20, 2010 06:21am

Parents Can Sometimes Help ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kingsman1288 (Post 697148)
I pay no attention to what comes from the stands.

So after you whistle a violation, and start bringing in substitutes from the table, when parents in the bleachers start saying, "Clock, clock, clock", you're not going to look up at the clock to realize that it hadn't stopped when the violation occurred?

C'mon. Let's be honest.

Kingsman1288 Wed Oct 20, 2010 06:24am

Billy,

You're right. I should have said 99% of what comes from the stands. I stand corrected.

chseagle Wed Oct 20, 2010 06:44am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kingsman1288 (Post 697156)
So officials are now supposed to answer questions/comments/concerns from the stands on why little Johnny/Sally didn't get to play? That's the coaches job, not ours. Or did I miss that POE this year? If they do decide to do something that dumb, it's bye-bye for them.

While you may think you're being helpful, IMO you're being an annoyance by overstepping your duties. Let us do our job, and you do yours. If you're so concerned with everything else, step out on the floor and put on the stripes and a whistle. I would be more than happy to work a game with you.

I would love to be a floor official, however thanks to an incident last January I am unable to physically do the duties required.

The times I have assisted on situations like with the bobbie pins I have been thanked by the floor officials. These happenings are few & far between, on average maybe only once a season. Majority of the time for me, it's telling the scorer & visiting book that they need to be impartial or that they need to pay more attention to the game than talking to their friends.

ref2coach Wed Oct 20, 2010 12:01pm

Personally I would appreciate the help. In my other primary sport we often ask the people at the "table" to look for illegal equipment and jersey tuck when the player approaches and tells them the number of the player they are replacing. For me it prevents delay, I always check the incoming player, should they be illegally or improperly equipped, I have to take the time to disallow the substitution. When I delegate to the table to "pre-screen" the players I have fewer delays and less "perturbed" players and coaches from disallowing the sub.

JRutledge Wed Oct 20, 2010 12:10pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 697157)
So after you whistle a violation, and start bringing in substitutes from the table, when parents in the bleachers start saying, "Clock, clock, clock", you're not going to look up at the clock to realize that it hadn't stopped when the violation occurred?

C'mon. Let's be honest.

C'mon Billy, I am not listening to a fan about the clock. I am not putting time based on the fan or what they are complaining about. If you do you will get it wrong most times as they do not know the rule or the reason you are changing the clock. If that is your position, then do you call a travel because a parent complains there is a travel too?

Peace

just another ref Wed Oct 20, 2010 12:38pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by chseagle (Post 697153)
So what if that parent gets overly irate at you for not allowing their child to play? (comes out of the stands & gets in face or raises such a ruckus play has to be suspended)

Now that's when I expect security/crowd control to step in and wrestle this offender to the ground. At this point an inspection for illegal hair pins can also be performed on this person, just in case.

rsox34 Wed Oct 20, 2010 02:13pm

Chseagle--you are not a game official...
 
...You are a Table Official. Numerous posters on this board have told you you are not a game official (referee/umpire) who wears a striped shirt, whistle, and lanyard. You are a table official (scorer or timer.) Kingsman1288strongly suggested that you read/study/adhere to rule 2-11 and 2-12. Those rules detail your duties and responsibilities. You are not a game official until you are able to take a rules test, pass a floor test, and start running up and down a gym floor. Let the people who have studied the rules, passed the tests, and know how to apply the rules by reffing many games do the officiating. The guys in the stripes with the whistles have their jobs to do and you have your jobs to do as the scorer, timer, crowd control person, etc. Concentrate on you jobs.

Jurassic Referee Wed Oct 20, 2010 02:46pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by just another ref (Post 697236)
Now that's when I expect security/crowd control to step in and wrestle this offender to the ground. At this point an inspection for illegal hair pins can also be performed on this person, just in case.

Personally I think that the dedicated table officials like chseagles should be issued tasers. It can be used at his own discretion on players with illegal equipment, officials who won't follow his direction, etc.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:39pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1