The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   B1 deflect a A1 pass, ball go backcourt (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/57822-b1-deflect-a1-pass-ball-go-backcourt.html)

mendi Tue Apr 06, 2010 05:46pm

B1 deflect a A1 pass, ball go backcourt
 
if B1 touch the ball backourt, is it backourt violaiont? or because its only deflection and not control in the ball its not violation.

bas2456 Tue Apr 06, 2010 05:51pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by mendi (Post 672936)
if B1 touch the ball backourt, is it backourt violaiont? or because its only deflection and not control in the ball its not violation.

If B1 deflects the ball into the backcourt, without the ball touching anyone else, it wouldn't be a violation for A1 to pick it up.

This is all assuming A1 had team control of course.

If B1 deflects a pass from A1 to A2, and A3 touches it before it goes into the back court, then is the first to touch it in the back court, you would have a violation.

Rule of Thumb:
  1. Team control
  2. Last to touch in frontcourt
  3. First to touch in backcourt

Adam Tue Apr 06, 2010 05:58pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bas2456 (Post 672937)

Rule of Thumb:
  1. Team control
  2. Last to touch in frontcourt
  3. First to touch in backcourt

Actual rule:
1. Team control.
2. Ball gains FC status.
3. Team with control is last to touch before it goes to the backcourt.
4. Team with control is first to touch after it goes to the backcourt.

With your rule of thumb, there are violations that would be missed. For one, there is no requirement that the team in control actually touch the ball in the FC for a violation to occur.

bob jenkins Tue Apr 06, 2010 05:58pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bas2456 (Post 672937)
If B1 deflects the ball into the backcourt, without the ball touching anyone else, it wouldn't be a violation for A1 to pick it up.

This is all assuming A1 had team control of course.

If B1 deflects a pass from A1 to A2, and A3 touches it before it goes into the back court, then is the first to touch it in the back court, you would have a violation.

Rule of Thumb:
  1. Team control
  2. Last to touch in frontcourt
  3. First to touch in backcourt

1) Team Control
2) Ball in front court
3) Last to touch before ball goes to BC
4) First to touch after ball goes to BC

mendi Tue Apr 06, 2010 06:09pm

Let me explain the case
 
The ball is in team A control and they start to move from their backourt. the ball is in team B FC (team A BC). A1 try to pass to A2. B1 is in team B FC and he deflect the ball and the ball goes to team B BC. B2 touch the ball BC. violation?

B1 was the last to touch (deflect) FC
B2 was the first to touch BC.

But what about control? deflection (slap the ball with one hand) is control?

bob jenkins Tue Apr 06, 2010 07:33pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by mendi (Post 672942)
The ball is in team A control and they start to move from their backourt. the ball is in team B FC (team A BC). A1 try to pass to A2. B1 is in team B FC and he deflect the ball and the ball goes to team B BC. B2 touch the ball BC. violation?

B1 was the last to touch (deflect) FC
B2 was the first to touch BC.

But what about control? deflection (slap the ball with one hand) is control?

The deflection was not (as described) team control. Team control starts when there's first player control. Player control starts when a player is holding or dribbling the ball inbounds.

(The above is FED / NCAA. FIBA might be different.)

Mark Padgett Tue Apr 06, 2010 08:44pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 672946)
The deflection was not (as described) team control. Team control starts when there's first player control. Player control starts when a player is holding or dribbling the ball inbounds.

(The above is FED / NCAA. FIBA might be different.)

Bob - I'm sure you meant a live ball inbounds. Sorry. I'm just feeling nit-picky today.

bas2456 Tue Apr 06, 2010 08:48pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 672938)
Actual rule:
1. Team control.
2. Ball gains FC status.
3. Team with control is last to touch before it goes to the backcourt.
4. Team with control is first to touch after it goes to the backcourt.

With your rule of thumb, there are violations that would be missed. For one, there is no requirement that the team in control actually touch the ball in the FC for a violation to occur.

Thanks for the help.

Pantherdreams Wed Apr 07, 2010 07:21am

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 672946)
The deflection was not (as described) team control. Team control starts when there's first player control. Player control starts when a player is holding or dribbling the ball inbounds.

(The above is FED / NCAA. FIBA might be different.)

FIBA that's back court . . .

SamIAm Wed Apr 07, 2010 08:42am

Quote:

Originally Posted by mendi (Post 672942)
The ball is in team A control and they start to move from their backourt. the ball is in team B FC (team A BC). A1 try to pass to A2. B1 is in team B FC and he deflect the ball and the ball goes to team B BC. B2 touch the ball BC. violation?

B1 was the last to touch (deflect) FC
B2 was the first to touch BC.

But what about control? deflection (slap the ball with one hand) is control?

There is a rule of thumb we use around here to help explain player control. If the player requests a time-out, would you grant the time-out. If not, then player control did not exist. Without player control occuring at some point, there is no team control.

Adam Wed Apr 07, 2010 11:53am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pantherdreams (Post 673006)
FIBA that's back court . . .

Really? Team control with FC status isn't required? Other FIBA officials concur?

APG Wed Apr 07, 2010 02:58pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 673047)
Really? Team control with FC status isn't required? Other FIBA officials concur?

Not a FIBA official but from their ruble book:

Art. 14 Control of the ball
14.1 Team control starts when a player of that team is in control of a live ball because he is holding or dribbling it or has a live ball at his disposal.

10.2 The ball becomes live when:
• During the jump ball, the ball is legally tapped by a jumper.
• During a free throw, the ball is at the disposal of the free-throw shooter.
• During a throw-in, the ball is at the disposal of the player taking the throw-in.

Art. 30 Ball returned to the backcourt
30.1 Definition
30.1.1 The ball goes into a team's backcourt when:
• It touches the backcourt.
• It touches a player or an official who has part of his body in contact with the backcourt.

30.1.2
The ball has been illegally returned to the backcourt when a player of the team in control of the live ball is:

• The last to touch the ball in his frontcourt, after which that player or a teammate is the first to touch the ball in the backcourt.
• The last to touch the ball in his backcourt, after which the ball touches the frontcourt and then is first touched by that player or team-mate in the
backcourt.

This restriction applies to all situations in a team's frontcourt, including throw-ins. However, it does not apply to a player who jumps from his frontcourt, establishes new team control while still airborne and then lands in his team’s backcourt.

30.2 Rule
A player whose team is in control of a live ball may not cause the ball to be illegally returned to his backcourt.

Adam Wed Apr 07, 2010 03:28pm

Interesting, it's worded differently (providing situations where a violation in NFHS would not be a violation in FIBA), but it appears this particular situation (the OP) would not be a violation in FIBA.

bas2456 Wed Apr 07, 2010 04:34pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by AllPurposeGamer (Post 673064)
Not a FIBA official but from their ruble book:

Aha...Haha. I see what you did there.

APG Wed Apr 07, 2010 06:50pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bas2456 (Post 673081)
Aha...Haha. I see what you did there.

Totally unintentional hahaha :p


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:29pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1