Crew Integrity
I was watching a boys varsity game tonight and I was able to watch the progression of how an official can undermine a partner without realizing it.
I'm sitting right behind the V bench. Early 1st quarter, H1 throws a pass towards H2. V1 deflects it, though, and it hits the C in the feet before going OOB. Coach thinks it hit H2's feet, and protests the call. C explains it to him, takes a bit long doing it, and she tells him he needs to get back into the coaching box. Just as she's about to put the ball in play, the T hits his whistle and comes across to try to give her new info. She tells him what happened, and he agrees and they play on. T's approach egged on the V coach. Fast forward to another close OOB call near the other bench, where she (I think) points the wrong way. Same partner approaches her and she agrees and they give the ball to V. As they're talking, V coach in front of me yells: "You've got to help her out!" It was interesting. If you heard it, who here would have T'd him for that last comment? |
Wasn't there, may not appreciate the context, but for that comment alone I would emphatically say no T.
|
While I wouldn't be happy to hear the comment, the comment be itself wouldn't earn a technical foul from me.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
as to that point it doesnt mean that her partner was undermining anyone. the story sounds weak. |
Quote:
It doesn't. The coach was yelling for her partner to help her, implying that she was not able to handle the job. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
The scenario presented itself relatively slowly, as the C took allowed the coach a good amount of rope when questioning the call. When the T came over and hit his whistle, I thought he was stepping up as R to end the back and forth between the coach and the C. When he instead chose to question her call, it gave the coach the message that the R didn't really trust his partner. If nothing else, it provided him what looked like a wedge to try to work the officials. |
Quote:
Let's assume the play happened in front of the coach's bench again, and this time he yells across to the T on the other court, "You've got to help her out!" With the history of the previous play, where he's obviously not just appealing to another official but is instead making a direct comment about her competence; do you "just inbound the ball already?" |
Quote:
And for further clarification I should have been specific that I was speaking to Leeballenfant because he said about T'ing if he were the woman but not the other ref. No big deal. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Or, the bald official... Or, the disheveled official... |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Good question, and no, I'm not saying they shouldn't try to get it right for fear of anything. If he had come over immediately, it wouldn't have "looked" bad. Instead, he stood opposite the table and let her flesh it out with the coach for a little bit and only came over to question her after it was clear the coach wasn't to let it go. It was at least 15 seconds after her initial call before the T came over to offer help.
He came over, blew his whistle for everyone to see, then had a 5 second discussion with her before turning around and heading back opposite. It looked like the coach's argument made him, from across the court, question his partner's judgment. Now, the coach was a d1ckhead anyway, so you're probably right; he would have found something else. |
But you're still just guessing about why he came over and what he said, so the leap to "undermining an official's authority" seems overblown to me. Perhaps it was poor timing, perhaps not. I'm only arguing that no one's authority was undermined based on what you know and how you painted it.
|
Quote:
|
Agreed, normally I'd like to see the T come over immediately on this; but it's possible he wasn't looking when she signaled and didn't know what her call was.
|
Or maybe he came over to help her get away from the coach as their conversation may have been lasting too long in his opinion. We just don't know, so to speculate and go so far as to call it undermining is just not fair.
|
Quote:
Reviewing it in my head again, he may have used the quick conference as a way to confirm her call and get the ball back in play. My initial thought as I was watching was that she was allowing the coach way too much time to debate the call. In the end, the chance of it appearing that way may well have been worth it to cut that conversation short. |
That's How People Refer To Me ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
#1 if any partner has addl. info. to share about a play, they MUST share it ON THE COURT (don't bring it back into the locker room! it does us no good there...). I have no problem w/ the partner coming in to talk w/ said official. #2 how is the coach making a "direct comment about her competence"? #3 the official simply pointed in the wrong direction...that happens...and when it does, you can expect to get a little grief/comment/hassle from the coach who thought he/she was getting the ball and now is not. #4 how does a T fit the game here? the coach griped about two out of bounds calls...big deal...talk w/ him/her and get thru it....and simply inbound the ball already. |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:31am. |