The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   i should know these answers, but... (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/57059-i-should-know-these-answers-but.html)

drshawnpet Thu Feb 11, 2010 02:16am

i should know these answers, but...
 
Greetings!

New to the site -- already addicted!

2 questions:

A) When are properly reported subs beckoned to court when 2 FTs are being administered for a technical foul?

B) Is it allowable for a team to use both baskets for warm-ups once one team has retreated to locker room for last-minute instructions prior to a game? Doesn't rules book state something about warming up at basket opposite the bench prior to game? I see this done all the time but not sure it's technically allowed?

Thank you for any replies!

representing Thu Feb 11, 2010 02:21am

Quote:

Originally Posted by drshawnpet (Post 660627)
Greetings!

New to the site -- already addicted!

2 questions:

A) When are properly reported subs beckoned to court when 2 FTs are being administered for a technical foul?

B) Is it allowable for a team to use both baskets for warm-ups once one team has retreated to locker room for last-minute instructions prior to a game? Doesn't rules book state something about warming up at basket opposite the bench prior to game? I see this done all the time but not sure it's technically allowed?

Thank you for any replies!

A) I might be quoting it wrong but it is before the last of the shots that is live. So 1-and-1, it would be the first shot since that could be the last live shot. 2, after the first shot... 3, after the second shot.

B) in NFHS, no they cannot not. In college ball though, I see this done all the time so I'm assuming it is allowed but I'm not a college ref. But once the team comes back out they have to retreat back to their half of the court.

drshawnpet Thu Feb 11, 2010 02:29am

Sorry, I should have specified NFHS in OP...

representing Thu Feb 11, 2010 02:33am

Quote:

Originally Posted by drshawnpet (Post 660629)
Sorry, I should have specified NFHS in OP...

Nah, most of the discussions with regards to rules is usually NFHS, and sometimes FIBA (which I'm not familiar with). Sometimes College rules come into play, but usually only when someone brings up an NCAA game that was on TV and ask about a certain play or whatnot.

Welcome to the board!

just another ref Thu Feb 11, 2010 02:46am

Quote:

Originally Posted by drshawnpet (Post 660627)
Greetings!



A) When are properly reported subs beckoned to court when 2 FTs are being administered for a technical foul?

Quote:

Originally Posted by representing (Post 660628)
A) I might be quoting it wrong but it is before the last of the shots that is live. So 1-and-1, it would be the first shot since that could be the last live shot. 2, after the first shot... 3, after the second shot.

Before the last of the shots that is live?

Let's puzzle on that one a bit.

First the language of that sentence. What the hell does it mean?

Next, which shot on a technical foul is "live?"

representing Thu Feb 11, 2010 02:48am

Quote:

Originally Posted by just another ref (Post 660631)
Before the last of the shots that is live?

Let's puzzle on that one a bit.

First the language of that sentence. What the hell does it mean?

Next, which shot on a technical foul is "live?"

Did I not say I probably have the wording wrong? Thank you

representing Thu Feb 11, 2010 02:50am

had it packed away but I dug the rulebook out. This is what I was trying to say:

3-3-1c:

During multiple free throws resulting from personal fouls, substitutions may be made only before the final attempt in the sequence and after the final attempt has been converted.

just another ref Thu Feb 11, 2010 03:00am

Quote:

Originally Posted by representing (Post 660634)
had it packed away but I dug the rulebook out. This is what I was trying to say:

3-3-1c:

During multiple free throws resulting from personal fouls, substitutions may be made only before the final attempt in the sequence and after the final attempt has been converted.

Yet the question in the OP remains unanswered.

representing Thu Feb 11, 2010 03:04am

Quote:

Originally Posted by just another ref (Post 660635)
Yet the question in the OP remains unanswered.

ah, you're right. Didn't see "technical".

I've looked through the rulebook, can't seem to find the answer for this one. I think you would wait until all FTs are administered, then beckon the subs before the throw-in.

representing Thu Feb 11, 2010 03:22am

Ok, I am correcting myself on this one.

During Technical FTs, subs can be made before the first shot, or at any time in between shots, and after the shots are taken. Any substitutes can also attempt the Technical Free Throws.

Back In The Saddle Thu Feb 11, 2010 03:24am

You have to infer the answer to the first question from NFHS 8-3: "The free throws awarded because of a technical foul may be attempted by any player of the offended team, including an eligible substitute or designated starter. The coach or captain shall designate the free thrower(s)."

In order for "an eligible substitute" to attempt the FTs, that substitute must be able to enter the game before either the first or second FT. And since the two free throws may be attempted by different players, it may be required to allow a substitution before both the first and second FT.

As far as I know the rules book only specifies that each team must occupy the bench designated by game management and that they begin the game shooting at the basket farthest from their bench. I know of no rule that specifies that they must warm up at that same basket, although obviously that is how it's done. There is no rule, in the rules book at least, that says that a team cannot warm up at both baskets if the other team leaves the floor. And it's generally accepted that if the rules don't say it's illegal, it's legal. However, I believe the NFHS had something to say on the subject a few years ago, at least in regards to prohibiting teams from running through the other teams warmups, circling the floor, competing over the center circle, etc. And I understand some states have policies on the subject as well. So, in your state, this practice may very well be prohibited.

Back In The Saddle Thu Feb 11, 2010 03:25am

Quote:

Originally Posted by representing (Post 660641)
Ok, I am correcting myself on this one.

During Technical FTs, subs can be made before the first shot, or at any time in between shots, and after the shots are taken. Any substitutes can also attempt the Technical Free Throws.

Ya beat me to it, O Speedy One. :)

representing Thu Feb 11, 2010 03:29am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Back In The Saddle (Post 660645)
Ya beat me to it, O Speedy One. :)

haha.:) I accidentally came across 8-3 while looking this up in the rulebook and had the same exact interpretation, that in order for a sub to take the FTs, substitution must be allowed after the referee reports the technical fouls.

justacoach Thu Feb 11, 2010 04:23am

Quote:

Originally Posted by representing (Post 660628)
A) I might be quoting it wrong but it is before the last of the shots that is live. So 1-and-1, it would be the first shot since that could be the last live shot. 2, after the first shot... 3, after the second shot.

B) in NFHS, no they cannot not. In college ball though, I see this done all the time so I'm assuming it is allowed but I'm not a college ref. But once the team comes back out they have to retreat back to their half of the court.

CAUTION!!!!!

Relying on rules interpretations fabricated by this individual will severely impact your reputation, career and sanity.

You have been duly warned!!!!!

Back In The Saddle Thu Feb 11, 2010 04:31am

On an early morning crusade? :)

Rich Thu Feb 11, 2010 08:26am

In A, the subs can be made anytime -- as said, a sub can enter and take either or both technical free throw, so a substitution needs to be legal there.

In B, check with your local authority. Personally, I hate this practice (one day there will be a brawl that comes from this nonsense), but we have no rule against it here, so I just make sure to be vigilant when the other team returns.

I have more interesting questions, like why the teams always run drills into the one spot on the sideline where I want to stand during warmups?

drshawnpet Thu Feb 11, 2010 09:11am

I appreciate the responses. To be more specific: If no one is entering to shoot the throw(s), and there are some players that had properly reported prior to the tech, when should they be beckoned? Before the 1st? Between throws? After the 2nd? We discussed the other night and had different answers amongst my crew... Just want to do it right, in case anything silly happened during the throws, want to have the correct players on the floor; I don't know if it makes sense to bring them in between throws, since the ball will be dead after the second throw? Anyone know definitively? Thanks for the help!

truerookie Thu Feb 11, 2010 09:19am

Quote:

Originally Posted by drshawnpet (Post 660684)
I appreciate the responses. To be more specific: If no one is entering to shoot the throw(s), and there are some players that had properly reported prior to the tech, when should they be beckoned? Before the 1st? Between throws? After the 2nd? We discussed the other night and had different answers amongst my crew... Just want to do it right, in case anything silly happened during the throws, want to have the correct players on the floor; I don't know if it makes sense to bring them in between throws, since the ball will be dead after the second throw? Anyone know definitively? Thanks for the help!

Common practice for me, I usually wait until the final free-throw..

bob jenkins Thu Feb 11, 2010 09:26am

Quote:

Originally Posted by drshawnpet (Post 660684)
I appreciate the responses. To be more specific: If no one is entering to shoot the throw(s), and there are some players that had properly reported prior to the tech, when should they be beckoned? Before the 1st? Between throws? After the 2nd? We discussed the other night and had different answers amongst my crew... Just want to do it right, in case anything silly happened during the throws, want to have the correct players on the floor; I don't know if it makes sense to bring them in between throws, since the ball will be dead after the second throw? Anyone know definitively? Thanks for the help!


You can bring them in at any time. If one of the subs is for the player who got the T, I get the sub(s) in ASAP to get the problem off the floor.

If not, then I usually wait.

Adam Thu Feb 11, 2010 09:53am

Quote:

Originally Posted by drshawnpet (Post 660684)
I appreciate the responses. To be more specific: If no one is entering to shoot the throw(s), and there are some players that had properly reported prior to the tech, when should they be beckoned? Before the 1st? Between throws? After the 2nd? We discussed the other night and had different answers amongst my crew... Just want to do it right, in case anything silly happened during the throws, want to have the correct players on the floor; I don't know if it makes sense to bring them in between throws, since the ball will be dead after the second throw? Anyone know definitively? Thanks for the help!

By rule, the requirements for a sub are met.
1. Dead ball
2. Clock stopped.

The exceptions built into the rules don't apply here:
1. reporting after warning horn of timeout or intermission.
2. PF FTs with more shots to follow.

No need to infer anything from the ability to bring a sub in to shoot TF FTs. You just need to realize when the exceptions apply and when they don't.

As has been stated with the full court drills: there's no NFHS rule against it. Your state/conference/governing body may rule otherwise, however.

Juulie Downs Thu Feb 11, 2010 12:52pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 660698)
As has been stated with the full court drills: there's no NFHS rule against it. Your state/conference/governing body may rule otherwise, however.

I seem to remember something about this in Oregon a few years ago, but I think it applied more to introductions than warm-ups when one team was clear off the floor.

I know that that year I had one game, rivalry, where home was introducing one girl from each team alternating (weird sentence, oh well). They were crowding into the center circle for some reason. Girls from one team on one side, other team on the other. One girl reached across the division line and goosed an opponent pretty significantly. Partner and I, standing at half-court saw it perfectly. I started to march out and whack her, but partner grabbed my arm and stopped me. He looked at the coach, who screamed at the girl, problem solved. Both that girl and I learned something that day.

Loudwhistle Thu Feb 11, 2010 03:19pm

I hear you!
 
I have more interesting questions, like why the teams always run drills into the one spot on the sideline where I want to stand during warmups?

I love it, in last weeks game I told my partner the same thing!:) I've felt like a target lately.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:09am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1