KU @ Texas
Thoughts on:
1. Review and intentional technical on Aldrich. 2. Morningstar's FT attempt for Aldrich (fouled out with the T). |
Quote:
Was Aldrich T a class B then? So they shoot them after the 1-and-1 -Josh |
Watching it real time, I'm not so sure the elbows came after the whistle. Seems like they were simultaneous.
Couldn't they just say intentional or flagrant foul then? I'm not too familiar with NCAA rules... |
Quote:
2. That was pretty funny. Don't think I've seen that one before. :) |
1. I thought the elbow wasn't swinging faster than the torso. If the fouls occurred the same time, would have gone with the double personal. Apparently they did not. In which case, yes, intentional technical was the right call for dead ball contact.
2. Ref should have whistled it dead as soon as the ball popped out of his hand. Looked like a try. Never seen that happen before. |
My take
1. The left elbow was purposely swung at the opponent. He extended.
The ball became dead when the player from Texas fouled. The timing of the whistle doesn't matter. Therefore, this is an intentional technical foul. In NCAAM, an INT T for dead ball contact is administered in the order of occurrence, in the NFHS manner, because possession to the opponent at the division line is also awarded. 2. Should have been whistled dead when the thrower's foot broke the plane of the FT line. The loss of the ball is okay as long as he can catch it again without violating. |
Agree with your take Nevada. Pretty sure the officials were as caught off guard on the FT attempt as I was!
|
I watched the second half while loathing my elliptical machine.
There was a drive to the bucket where the player was gathering, fouled, and finished. The official counted the bucket, correctly. Bob Knight, of course, disagreed with this. Real time I thought, "They'll go to the monitor and call it a dead ball technical foul" and I was right. There have been a few of these the past week and regardless of the player landing on the Kansas player, I *did* think the elbow came around faster than the torso. |
I think John Adams wants this contact to be a Technical this year. I do not have my rule books, but I think I saw it on the NCAA pre-season bulletin
|
Quote:
It's the same in NFHS, I looked it up. I agree then. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I'm counting that every time. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
In my opinion, simply gathering the dribble is not enough. The official needs to see some kind of habitual motion that is part of the shooting action prior to the release of a try in order to award FTs. Just what I take from the rules. |
Quote:
Admittedly, it's a fine line. I've watched a lot of NCAAM the past few weeks (mostly recorded games as I've been working) and it seems like they are calling more of these shooting fouls than I remember in the past. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:33pm. |