The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Ever have a hard time with OOB calls? (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/56036-ever-have-hard-time-oob-calls.html)

Hartsy Mon Dec 21, 2009 02:56pm

Ever have a hard time with OOB calls?
 
My last game was OK as far as my mechanics and calling violations and fouls, everything other than OOB calls anyhow. Seemed like every time I signaled direction and color, someone had a gripe about it. A few times they were probably right. Aside from pausing briefly before indicating possession and watching where the players start to move, anything I could do to keep this from happening? It seems to hit me every now and then. Maybe I was just getting more than my share of close calls. I don't mind going to the AP arrow on occassion, but not every time the ball lands OOB in my primary.

j51969 Mon Dec 21, 2009 03:03pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hartsy (Post 644589)
My last game was OK as far as my mechanics and calling violations and fouls, everything other than OOB calls anyhow. Seemed like every time I signaled direction and color, someone had a gripe about it. A few times they were probably right. Aside from pausing briefly before indicating possession and watching where the players start to move, anything I could do to keep this from happening? It seems to hit me every now and then. Maybe I was just getting more than my share of close calls. I don't mind going to the AP arrow on occassion, but not every time the ball lands OOB in my primary.

Where are most of the calls coming from? I am assume you are getting one's as the lead, opposite side, end line? If you didn't see it maybe your partner can help. Pre-gaming this situation can help.

JRutledge Mon Dec 21, 2009 03:03pm

When players a both near the ball those calls are going to be contested. Maybe you body language is not strong enough or you are not forceful in calling the close ones. I would not say I had problems calling these, but I have had many calls contested. Heck it is the nature of the best sometimes. But I have found when I sell a close call or indicate the number it went out on, and then I get less crap. But you are going to get crap from time to time. And I would never go to the AP arrow just to go there. I would really have to not have an idea to do that.

Peace

representing Mon Dec 21, 2009 03:05pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hartsy (Post 644589)
My last game was OK as far as my mechanics and calling violations and fouls, everything other than OOB calls anyhow. Seemed like every time I signaled direction and color, someone had a gripe about it. A few times they were probably right. Aside from pausing briefly before indicating possession and watching where the players start to move, anything I could do to keep this from happening? It seems to hit me every now and then. Maybe I was just getting more than my share of close calls. I don't mind going to the AP arrow on occassion, but not every time the ball lands OOB in my primary.

Do you mean in closely double-touched situations? As in, two opponents touching the ball near-simultaneous? For me, it happens more when I'm the Lead than when I am the Trail, and more in girls games than in boys. My theory is that first, Boys are able to jump higher and grab stronger than girls are. Secondly, this happens mostly during rebounds of a missed shot. So again, more as a Lead, more in girls games than in boys.

I know I just opened myself up for debates. I got a few minutes before i gotta get ready for my game tonight:)

representing Mon Dec 21, 2009 03:07pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 644593)
When players a both near the ball those calls are going to be contested. Maybe you body language is not strong enough or you are not forceful in calling the close ones. I would not say I had problems calling these, but I have had many calls contested. Heck it is the nature of the best sometimes. But I have found when I sell a close call or indicate the number it went out on, and then I get less crap. But you are going to get crap from time to time. And I would never go to the AP arrow just to go there. I would really have to not have an idea to do that.

Peace

Going along with the "selling" point... I'm a loud referee when it comes to making calls. The closer the call is, the louder my voice and more forceful with my hand signal I am.

bas2456 Mon Dec 21, 2009 03:10pm

I think it's a mistake to watch the body language of the players. The onus is on you to make a decision, quickly and decisively. Sell it.

A close out of bounds is one of the toughest calls, IMO. We all kick one from time to time. Sell it and move on.

fullor30 Mon Dec 21, 2009 03:15pm

As Jeff mentioned, body language is important. It's OK to 'take a picture' of what you saw before you make the call. If there is a second of hesitation, calmly, and with confidence, make your call as if it was a clear cut one that needs no embellishment. There are times to ''sell it' of course. I'm weak on OOB calls as lead and it happens bang, bang in front of me. I like to work deeper.

The arrow is the last thing I want to go with. If I'm lead and it goes out on my line, opposite side, and I'm not sure, I have no problem blowing, arm up looking to C for help.

If it's in front of me, and I'm not sure, I give it my best shot, coaches seem to be OK with it as long as you look confident and they figure you had the best look at it.

Scratch85 Mon Dec 21, 2009 03:18pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bas2456 (Post 644598)
We all kick one from time to time. Sell it and move on.

Agreed. The OOB call may be the easiest call of all to sell. It doesn't require a lot of "finger brushing", pointing or gyrating. Just clearly state a color and point. Nothing else is required.

Oh, except maybe getting the ball back in play quickly for all of those that weren't "sold." :)

JRutledge Mon Dec 21, 2009 03:19pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bas2456 (Post 644598)
I think it's a mistake to watch the body language of the players. The onus is on you to make a decision, quickly and decisively. Sell it.

A close out of bounds is one of the toughest calls, IMO. We all kick one from time to time. Sell it and move on.

I think you can use the players as a guide, but you should not rely on them to make what might be a close call. If everyone is heading in that direction and you are unsure, I have no problem if you make a call based on that. It is after all just one call and if everyone is convinced you are going in a certain direction, you can just go with that. But it also takes some art to do that and you cannot rely on this to always work. But then again I have also learned to not be too quick to point. I just blow the whistle and wait before I call the color, then point. But that took time to do that consistently.

Peace

bas2456 Mon Dec 21, 2009 03:27pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 644604)
I think you can use the players as a guide, but you should not rely on them to make what might be a close call. If everyone is heading in that direction and you are unsure, I have no problem if you make a call based on that. It is after all just one call and if everyone is convinced you are going in a certain direction, you can just go with that. But it also takes some art to do that and you cannot rely on this to always work. But then again I have also learned to not be too quick to point. I just blow the whistle and wait before I call the color, then point. But that took time to do that consistently.

Peace

Good point. I should have qualified my statement a little more. If you're looking to the players with an expression that says "I have no idea, help me out guys", then you're going to have 5 guys pointing one way and 5 pointing the other way. Then what do you do?

Mark Padgett Mon Dec 21, 2009 03:49pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bas2456 (Post 644606)
Good point. I should have qualified my statement a little more. If you're looking to the players with an expression that says "I have no idea, help me out guys", then you're going to have 5 guys pointing one way and 5 pointing the other way. Then what do you do?

Have the captains arm wrestle for it. ;)

JRutledge Mon Dec 21, 2009 03:57pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bas2456 (Post 644606)
Good point. I should have qualified my statement a little more. If you're looking to the players with an expression that says "I have no idea, help me out guys", then you're going to have 5 guys pointing one way and 5 pointing the other way. Then what do you do?

Your partner should help you out then. I am just saying that if the play is "close" and all the players head in that direction, if you go in that direction (and you are unsure in the first place) no one is going to give you much crap if you go in the direction everyone thinks it should be going. And if you ultimately get it wrong, it is not the end of the world that happens from time to time. That ball has a funny way of bouncing from time to time.

Peace

Adam Mon Dec 21, 2009 04:07pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bas2456 (Post 644606)
Good point. I should have qualified my statement a little more. If you're looking to the players with an expression that says "I have no idea, help me out guys", then you're going to have 5 guys pointing one way and 5 pointing the other way. Then what do you do?

Answer: Don't do that. Use the clues subtlely.

fullor30 Mon Dec 21, 2009 04:39pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 644622)
Answer: Don't do that. Use the clues subtlely.

Sometimes just the body language of the head down, shoulders slumped, or the pained look of a player involved will tip you off.

Additionally, in a thirty point blowout, if I'm guessing, you know who is getting the ball.

tjones1 Mon Dec 21, 2009 04:47pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by fullor30 (Post 644629)
Additionally, in a thirty point blowout, if I'm guessing, you know who is getting the ball.

The squirrel? :p

wanja Mon Dec 21, 2009 05:01pm

Talk to yourself. It sure helps me. For example, when the ball approaches your line of responsibility say "my line". When there is a touch that could potentially cause an out of bounds say the team color to yourself. Then when you need to make the call your prepped to come out strong.

Mark Padgett Mon Dec 21, 2009 05:08pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by wanja (Post 644633)
Talk to yourself. It sure helps me.

But my shrink says I've got to stop doing this. :eek:

26 Year Gap Mon Dec 21, 2009 05:09pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett (Post 644635)
But my shrink says I've got to stop doing this. :eek:

Are you going to listen to HIM, or the 1000 crazy voices in your head?

BillyMac Mon Dec 21, 2009 08:52pm

When Half Right Is 100% Right ...
 
If you know for sure it went off Blue, but are a little confused about the direction, just put your hand up to stop the clock and yell "White". Look over at the benches, figure out if it's the first or second half, and then give the direction.

In a half court set, if all you know for sure is that it went off the offensive team, but are a little confused about which color is the defensive team, just put your hand up to stop the clock and point downcourt. Look over at the benches, figure out if it's the first or second half, and then give the proper color.

In a half court set, if all you know for sure is that it went off the defensive team, but are a little confused about which color is the offensive team, just put your hand up to stop the clock and point in the direction that the offensive team was going in their half court set. Look over at the benches, figure out if it's the first or second half, and then give the proper color.

In the last two cases, you may want to yell, "That way", or, "Stay here", but many evaluators may discourage this, and so, "When in Rome ...".

fullor30 Mon Dec 21, 2009 09:16pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 644670)
If you know for sure it went off Blue, but are a little confused about the direction, just put your hand up to stop the clock and yell "White". Look over at the benches, figure out if it's the first or second half, and then give the direction.

In a half court set, if all you know for sure is that it went off the offensive team, but are a little confused about which color is the defensive team, just put your hand up to stop the clock and point downcourt. Look over at the benches, figure out if it's the first or second half, and then give the proper color.

In a half court set, if all you know for sure is that it went off the defensive team, but are a little confused about which color is the offensive team, just put your hand up to stop the clock and point in the direction that the offensive team was going in their half court set. Look over at the benches, figure out if it's the first or second half, and then give the proper color.

In the last two cases, you may want to yell, "That way", or, "Stay here", but many evaluators may discourage this, and so, "When in Rome ...".

I have no problem with color, I'll goof direction occasionally. I have a frequent partner who always points direction rather than call color first. If you call right color, the sheep will follow, then I can properly point. To me if you point wrong direction first, you are open to discussion.

Forksref Mon Dec 21, 2009 09:34pm

I think my biggest problem, as lead, is when I get too close to the endline. I need to back off the endline farther. In doing so, I get a clearer picture. When I am really close to the play, I can't see the quick tip or which foot the ball hit last. So, mechanically, I can help myself make better judgments.

CMHCoachNRef Tue Dec 22, 2009 12:02am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 644670)
If you know for sure it went off Blue, but are a little confused about the direction, just put your hand up to stop the clock and yell "White". Look over at the benches, figure out if it's the first or second half, and then give the direction.

In a half court set, if all you know for sure is that it went off the offensive team, but are a little confused about which color is the defensive team, just put your hand up to stop the clock and point downcourt. Look over at the benches, figure out if it's the first or second half, and then give the proper color.

In a half court set, if all you know for sure is that it went off the defensive team, but are a little confused about which color is the offensive team, just put your hand up to stop the clock and point in the direction that the offensive team was going in their half court set. Look over at the benches, figure out if it's the first or second half, and then give the proper color.

In the last two cases, you may want to yell, "That way", or, "Stay here", but many evaluators may discourage this, and so, "When in Rome ...".

BillyMac,
You disappointed me. I thought that you would certainly recommend a coin toss.:rolleyes:

SmokeEater Tue Dec 22, 2009 03:28pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett (Post 644635)
But my shrink says I've got to stop doing this. :eek:

Your shrink is a quack though! :D

26 Year Gap Tue Dec 22, 2009 04:34pm

This is him
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SmokeEater (Post 644885)
Your shrink is a quack though! :D

http://edans.org/Image14.gif


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:22pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1