zebraman |
Mon Dec 22, 2008 01:11pm |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spence
(Post 560645)
A1 coming down on a break with the ball heading to the basket. B1 sees him coming and plants himself under the basket. A1 shoots the ball and then makes contact with B1. Contact is in the torso.
Is there ever a situation where this is a no-call? I let one go Friday night because I didn't think it had any bearing on the play. However, after thinking about it I'm not sure if I'm justified in using that as a reason to not call the PC foul.
|
It's a judgment play. If you thought that A1 put B1 to the floor, i's an easy P/C. If you thought that B1 flopped, then it's a tougher decision. Even if B1 gave ground, if the contact by A1 was "to and through" the defender and B1 had LGP, it's a charge.
Some block/charge plays are 50/50's, even when you look at them on tape later. In general, I think a no-call seems to get us in more trouble than anything else.
|