Quote:
I'm in TX where school districts are usually set up by individual towns or cities (as opposed to "Unified School Districts"...as in CA by counties). The State's educational governing body for inter-school competitions (both acedemic and athletic) is UIL. UIL states in their constitution that schools should...yes should...use only TASO officials for all varsity high school competitions. For this reason, we have to be a member of one of the 14 TASO Chapters to work varsity games. Each Chapter has an Assignment Secretary that is a paid position within that Chapter. So most officials here have only one assignor for all their games (yes...I finally got to my point... :eek: ). I also worked for about 5 years in Sacramento (ending in 1999) where it worked much the same way. What's it like in MA...??? |
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
I get their purpose, and it's a nice thought. There's just no reason to have the officials standing there postgame when everyone's emotions are heated. As scrappy said, do it before the game if you want the refs there. |
Quote:
How would a pregame handshake when there are no emotions and thoughts that decisions have gone against someone be in anyway similar? How would it teach people to cope with what happened in the game? It wouldn't. |
The problem really isn't the players and coaches, as has been alluded to, there is ample authority to deal with them even if the score is set. The problem is the fans.
1. You're not going to "teach" them anything in this setting. 2. You're setting up stationary targets at mid-court with their back to half the crowd. 3. What happens when an AD is either intimidated or incompetent, as Scrappy (I think) dealt with last season? I'm not sure what details could be changed to make this acceptable. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Why does it require officials to do a PGHS? Aren't the coaches and administrators supervising the kids and being the adults? When the game ends, the officials' role is over. And all this is theoretical, anyway. No way this ever goes national. Too many states, I bet, would find the emphasis on this to be moronic. (Wasn't MA the state that tried requiring mouthguards and also made a boy wear a skirt to play field hockey?) |
Rich,
Go back and look at post #34 in this thread for my thoughts on what you have just written. |
Quote:
I will always shake a player's or coach's hand if they present it to me. I just don't think it's all as simple as the MIAA does. I wonder how many of those policymakers have ever put on a whistle and officiated. |
Perhaps we should be looking ahead to the next generation of fans sitting in the stands. If these people are the kids playing today and they learn to view and interact with the game officials differently, then perhaps down the road things will be better when they are the ones who are sitting in the stands.
I agree that it will be very difficult, if not impossible, to change the beliefs of the older folks who are the current bleacher bums. It has been said that if you wish to better the world, then teach a child something good. |
Quote:
There have been a number of retirements and resignations by assignors in the last few years, which has changed the landscape. When I started about 10 years ago, I worked exclusively for one assignor, who had five or six leagues -- boys and girls and who had been around forever. When he retired his leagues were given to at least four assignors. |
Quote:
<img src="http://www.runemasterstudios.com/graemlins/images/twocents.gif" title="image: two cents">: I'm all for promoting good sportsmanship, but It's my own opinion that if you make a PGHS mandatory, it loses some of its significance and meaning and is a statement that whoever made the rule doesn't trust the participants to do it on their own. |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:54pm. |