Another backcouirt question
:eek: Player A1 has ball in front court , player B1 slaps ball away , ensuing scrum leaves ball in player B1's posession (still in A's frontcourt ) , just after B1 has posession A2 deflects ball away from B1 to team A's backcourt. Player A3 retrieves ball from the backcourt and is called for backcourt violation.
A fellow parent told me of this and had " commented " to the official about posession and the official commented back that the ball was still in A's posession. I have talked with a fellow official and we have went back and forth,,,,,,,, unfortunately I think the answer is right in front of me and I'm not seeing it. Thanks ps At least I'm educating my fellow parents ........... they aren't commenting 3 SECONDS, 3 SECONDS. Tip |
I suppose the ref thought the ball had never gone to B and because A was the last to touch it in the frontcourt it was backcourt once A got the ball. If B did have possession which you write then no it should not have been backcourt.
|
Who was the last to touch in the front court?
Who was the first to touch in the back court? Did that team have team control when it was touched in the back court? |
Quote:
Did A have team control? No - no violation. |
Team A had control initially ( start of thread ) , prior to all of the deflections. The last deflection by A2 that ended up in the backcourt was a deflection (slapped the ball away from B1).
The official who called the violation also works college games ..... didn't know if there is a difference in the ruling. Thanks for the help Tip |
Whoa, RT. You first write that B retained possession. As noted above by others, if B gets possession, there's no b/c violation for A. But now if you're just saying it was pinball time, and only deflections all around, we have a different ballgame.
|
Quote:
Reftip, the word you used was possession. What did you mean by that? |
Just got back from a game and talked with the parent again . He said that player B retreived the ball and held the ball for about second or so then player A2 "slapped " it away. The ball then went from front court of A to back court .
Tip |
Quote:
|
BTW the NCAA rule on backcourt works the same as the NFHS rule.
There are wording and structure differences, but all plays have the same result. |
Looks to me like the parent thought B had gained possession, and the official disagreed.
More accurately, it looks like the official thought B had not gained possession, and the parent disagreed. It happens. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Also, did this official respond during the game? That's a no-no. Did he respond to the parent during a dead ball? Also a no-no. |
He responded as he was running down the court.
Thanks all for the responses .............. I'll encourage the parent to keep it down. Last year I was able to convince two parents to get licensed and they are now in their first year. Tip |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:12pm. |