Validation

[Clark Kent]

I'm looking for validation on the following question.

The head coach may leave the coaching box to go to the scorer’s table to rectify a scoring mistake only if beckoned by an official.

I would agree with that statement with the logic that rectifying the score is not one of the reasons to which the coach may approach the scorer's table (10-5-1) however if her is beckoned by an official I would believe that to be appropriate.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Clark Kent

The head coach may leave the coaching box to go to the scorer’s table to rectify a scoring mistake only if beckoned by an official.

Read rule 10 concerning head coaches.

[Clark Kent]

So let me get this straight....you are saying that rule 10-5-1c that states....

"The head coach may stand and/or leave the coaching box to confer with personnel at the score's table to request a time-out as in 5-8-4."

That he/she as the coach may approach the scorer's table without being "beckoned" by the official?

Because 5-8-4 says....

"....Responds to the score's signal to grant a coach's request that a correctable error, as in 2-10, or a timing, scoring or alternating-possession mistake be prevented or rectified. The appeal to the official shall be presented at the scorer's table where a coach of each team may be present."

So now as I re-read that it seems that it is permissible for the coach to leave the box in order to "rectify" a score even if the official doesn't beckon him, and consequently making the statement false because it says "only if".

[jritchie]

False, a coach can go to the scorers table to bring an error to the attention of the score keeper and officials without being beckoned. How would the officials know to beckon the coach if they don't even know there is an error yet?

[Indianaref]

The head coach may also confer with personnel at scorer's table to request a 60-second time-out (or one 30-second time-out if that is the only type of time-out remaining) for a correctable error as in 2-10, or to prevent or rectify a timing or scoring mistake or alternating possession mistake.

I can not find anywhere in the rule book that says the coach must be beckoned to the table to rectify a mistake. Not sure where you get that. There is a timeout charged to his team if there is no correction made.

[Clark Kent]

Originally Posted by Indianaref

I can not find anywhere in the rule book that says the coach must be beckoned to the table to rectify a mistake. Not sure where you get that. There is a timeout charged to his team if there is no correction made.

It wasn't from the rule book rather one of the test questions that stated that a coach could only approach the scorer's table if beckoned by an official.

[Clark Kent]

Originally Posted by Indianaref

I can not find anywhere in the rule book that says the coach must be beckoned to the table to rectify a mistake. Not sure where you get that. There is a timeout charged to his team if there is no correction made.

Do you know where that rule is that states that if no correction is made a timeout will be charged to the team?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by Clark Kent

Do you know where that rule is that states that if no correction is made a timeout will be charged to the team?

Yes, I do.

In case you want to know (and, I guess, even if you don't), it's 5-11-3