The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   A player's shoe comes off during a live ball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/42757-players-shoe-comes-off-during-live-ball.html)

TonyT Sun Mar 16, 2008 10:42am

A player's shoe comes off during a live ball
 
Saw this in a game Sat. Team A has the ball and is driving for the basket and a player on team B looses his shoe, one of the officials blows his whistle and stops play, the shot goes in. OH BOY!!!! The officials have a conference and decide to give the ball back to Team A and basket doesn't count. First I don't believe the whistle should of been blown to start with ( I believe the other 2 officials knew this) But after this happened I think they did the only they could and that was give the ball back to Team A and resume play. Have any of you had this happen to you? (The shot came just after the whistle, so you can't count the basket)

26 Year Gap Sun Mar 16, 2008 11:11am

That is an IWCOA. [Inadvertent Whistle Chewing Out After}

Mark Padgett Sun Mar 16, 2008 11:28am

Quote:

Originally Posted by TonyT
whistle show

I went to a whistle show once. It had dancing whistles and some of them even took their lanyards off! :eek:

26 Year Gap Sun Mar 16, 2008 11:34am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett
I went to a whistle show once. It had dancing whistles and some of them even took their lanyards off! :eek:

If it included any of these, I think I saw the same show.
http://slpaccessories.com/cart/images/SlideWhistles.jpg

TonyT Sun Mar 16, 2008 11:37am

Thanks I edited the post
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett
I went to a whistle show once. It had dancing whistles and some of them even took their lanyards off! :eek:

Just wondering. If you are a big time ref then why are you reffing these 5th and 6th grade girls games and rec games?

Dan_ref Sun Mar 16, 2008 11:41am

Quote:

Originally Posted by TonyT
Just wondering. If you are a big time ref then why are you reffing these 5th and 6th grade girls games and rec games?

This outghta be good. I'll keep you out of my ignore file for now so I can see how you handle the sh1tstorm I expect this will start.

Mark Padgett Sun Mar 16, 2008 11:41am

Quote:

Originally Posted by TonyT
Just wondering. If you are a big time ref then why are you reffing these 5th and 6th grade girls games and rec games?

So 5th and 6th grade girls games and rec games are two different things? Huh?

And, just to satisfy your misplaced curiosity, I've been on the board of our local kids rec league for over 15 years and I personally kept it from folding twice, once due to lack of funds and the other time due to lack of volunteers. I take my relationship with this league very seriously. It's just one of the many community volunteer efforts with which I'm associated.

BTW - keep it light. You're in the big leagues here. We only get "personal" with fanboys.

26 Year Gap Sun Mar 16, 2008 11:48am

Quote:

Originally Posted by TonyT
Just wondering. If you are a big time ref then why are you reffing these 5th and 6th grade girls games and rec games?

But once quoted, it's etched in stone. You have to edit pretty quickly around here.

just another ref Sun Mar 16, 2008 12:09pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by TonyT
Just wondering. If you are a big time ref then why are you reffing these 5th and 6th grade girls games and rec games?

Just wondering. Are you also a "big time ref" or is this some kind of hero worship thing?

BillyMac Sun Mar 16, 2008 12:18pm

It's The Game, It's The Players ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TonyT
Just wondering. If you are a big time ref then why are you reffing these 5th and 6th grade girls games and rec games?

I've been on our local IAABO board for twenty-seven years, working varsity high school games for over twenty of those twenty-seven years. Although I've never worked a state tournament game, I have worked conference tournament games, including conference tournament finals.

I also work in a Catholic school league, that includes boys, and girls, from the lower grades through eighth grade. Games on weeknights involve the older players. Games on weekends involve only younger players.

This past Friday, my supervisor let me leave work two hours early, and lose two hours pay, to work a Special Olympics Unified Games tournament, for free. I worked five games, and two involved kids playing in wheelchairs, being pushed by high school volunteer partners. I didn't make any calls, other than out of bounds all afternoon, not a foul, not a travel, not an illegal dribble, but I felt appreciated, not a single critical comment about my calls, or lack of, by players, coaches, and fans. I don't ask my supervisor to leave work early to do varsity games, but I do every year for this tournament.

So, here I am, a pretty good high school varsity official, working a game with fourth and fifth graders on a Sunday afternoon? Why? Because I love officiating interscholastic basketball. Why should I be sitting in my Lazy-Boy watching a college, or professional, game on television, when I can be out there on the floor running up and down the floor with the kids.

I love this game. I love interacting with the players, coaches, and fans, no matter what the level. Yet I still consider myself to be a "big time" official.

Mars Blackmon (Spike Lee) said "It's gotta be the shoes." He was wrong. It's the game. It's the players.

jsblanton Sun Mar 16, 2008 03:13pm

Big time?
 
I like to consider myself a big time middle school ref. I get to work a middle school camp for our local 8th grade coach this summer. I am kind of excited about it. To me, "a game is a game" no matter what level it is.

BillyMac Sun Mar 16, 2008 03:37pm

"Big Time" Attitude
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jsblanton
To me, "a game is a game" no matter what level it is.

Amen. To those kids, that game is the most important game of the day. The officials should treat it likewise.

Adam Sun Mar 16, 2008 03:41pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by TonyT
Just wondering. If you are a big time ref then why are you reffing these 5th and 6th grade girls games and rec games?

Quite possibly the most stupidest post this month.

Loudwhistle Mon Mar 17, 2008 01:37am

TonyTravesty?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells
Quite possibly the most stupidest post this month.

Sorry to disagree with you Snaqwells, but that is the stupidest post I've ever read yet on this forum! An unbelievable travesty to the officials that are part of this group. When I first started viewing this sight, I only had to read about two of Mark's posts to discern that he loves the game and kids and that's all that matters. (Same for me by the way, care less what level or gender, just love the game, glad to be a part in any way.) I never want to be a "big time" reff in TonyT's book!

DonInKansas Mon Mar 17, 2008 03:25am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett

BTW - keep it light. You're in the big leagues here. We only get "personal" with fanboys.

Oh noes.....is he questioning your fanhood?

Barbed wire baby...all the way around.:D

Raymond Mon Mar 17, 2008 08:07am

Quote:

Originally Posted by TonyT
Just wondering. If you are a big time ref then why are you reffing these 5th and 6th grade girls games and rec games?

WOW!

Me, I worked Over-40 Men's Rec League games last night.

I call a foul on a veteran rec-league guy who's an asst. coach for a BV team I ref regularly.

He asks me what he did. I said "you fouled him". He asks "how?" I said "with your right hand."

Then he says to "call the game right. This isn't about you" :rolleyes:

Yeah, 7:00 games on a Sunday night for $18 is really an ego boost for me. :eek:

Adam Mon Mar 17, 2008 08:46am

Sounds like a T to me.

Back In The Saddle Mon Mar 17, 2008 08:55am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef
WOW!

Me, I worked over 40 Men's Rec League games last night. :eek:

WOW! is right. My limit is 20 in a season. I can't imagine working 40+ in one night! :eek:

Raymond Mon Mar 17, 2008 09:53am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Back In The Saddle
WOW! is right. My limit is 20 in a season. I can't imagine working 40+ in one night! :eek:

Nice try BITS, but I noticed your little editing job on my quote. :p

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells
Sounds like a T to me.

Not in this situation. We were side-by-side during the free throws. I made sure I got the last word in. :D

TonyT Mon Mar 17, 2008 09:55am

I come in peace
 
My reply was a joke just like the whistle show. ( which I thought was funny by the way) Mark I don't know you but have a lot of respect for all you do, as I respect everyone who blows the whistle. I asked a honest question about a play I saw and then I am getting made fun of for a wrong word ( i will double check my posts from now on) I really enjoy this forum and reading about all of the different things that happen during a game. Now again I apologize so can we move on to what this is intended for?

Adam Mon Mar 17, 2008 10:11am

Nicely put, TonyT.

BTW, you're not the first one to misspell a word and catch hell for it. :)

I'll add that I think your OP was correct. Shouldn't blow the whistle for that, but once it's done, it's done.

socalreff Mon Mar 17, 2008 10:15am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef
WOW!

Me, I worked Over-40 Men's Rec League games last night.

I call a foul on a veteran rec-league guy who's an asst. coach for a BV team I ref regularly.

He asks me what he did. I said "you fouled him". He asks "how?" I said "with your right hand."

Then he says to "call the game right. This isn't about you" :rolleyes:

Yeah, 7:00 games on a Sunday night for $18 is really an ego boost for me. :eek:

You guys need a pay raise.

fullor30 Mon Mar 17, 2008 11:10am

Quote:

Originally Posted by TonyT
Saw this in a game Sat. Team A has the ball and is driving for the basket and a player on team B looses his shoe, one of the officials blows his whistle and stops play, the shot goes in. OH BOY!!!! The officials have a conference and decide to give the ball back to Team A and basket doesn't count. First I don't believe the whistle should of been blown to start with ( I believe the other 2 officials knew this) But after this happened I think they did the only they could and that was give the ball back to Team A and resume play. Have any of you had this happen to you? (The shot came just after the whistle, so you can't count the basket)

"And one" , shoe that is..........:eek:

RCBSports Mon Mar 17, 2008 02:49pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by TonyT
Saw this in a game Sat. Team A has the ball and is driving for the basket and a player on team B looses his shoe, one of the officials blows his whistle and stops play, the shot goes in. OH BOY!!!! The officials have a conference and decide to give the ball back to Team A and basket doesn't count. First I don't believe the whistle should of been blown to start with ( I believe the other 2 officials knew this) But after this happened I think they did the only they could and that was give the ball back to Team A and resume play. Have any of you had this happen to you? (The shot came just after the whistle, so you can't count the basket)

This too happened during a State Tourney game, but they didn't blow the ball dead. Which I am wondering, what is the ruling? If I am not mistaking, you continue play. If the basketball goes in, call a Official Time and allow the player to put the shoe back on? I will have to look this one up later on.

-Lucas

Adam Mon Mar 17, 2008 03:15pm

At the varsity level, let the player take responsibility and put his own shoe back on. I wouldn't blow it dead for this, even after a made basket.

Dan_ref Mon Mar 17, 2008 03:17pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by RCBSports
This too happened during a State Tourney game, but they didn't blow the ball dead. Which I am wondering, what is the ruling? If I am not mistaking, you continue play. If the basketball goes in, call a Official Time and allow the player to put the shoe back on? I will have to look this one up later on.

-Lucas

There's no such thing as 'official's time' (except for at the bar after the game :) ) so you can't do this.

You can blow the ball dead if there's a player safety issue but generally not while the team with the ball is attacking the basket. I've never considered an untied shoe or a missing shoe to be a safety issue. Strictly speaking this applies to seriously injured or unconscious players at the higher levels, more judgement required as the player's age and level of competition goes down.

ace Mon Mar 17, 2008 03:36pm

I wouldn't blow the whistle for this once you get to HS level. My rational: "This aint the Y or Jr. NBA Leagues anymore"

Infact in a freshman game I worked a few years ago a player lost shoe and was looking at me like "you going to blow this whistle?" I didn't pay any attention to him, and kept going. The play was over and his coach was yellin at him for not being down there. The player fired back" well the referee didn't blow the whistle when I lost my shoe." The coach looked like he was going to explode.
"WELL DUH! This is HIGH SCHOOL BASKETBALL, NOT THE Y!" so ever since then I've applied that line of thinking.

Adam Mon Mar 17, 2008 03:41pm

Let them lose out on defense a couple of times, and they'll learn how to tie their shoes.

26 Year Gap Mon Mar 17, 2008 08:01pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells
Let them lose out on defense a couple of times, and they'll learn how to tie their shoes.

And if they'd learn to use double knots, their opponents wouldn't be able to disable them while lining up for FTs.:D

BillyMac Mon Mar 17, 2008 09:17pm

Ucla ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 26 Year Gap
And if they'd learn to use double knots, their opponents wouldn't be able to disable them while lining up for FTs.

Didn't the great John Wooden show his players how to tie their shoes at their first practice? Seriously. Or is this one of those myths?

Adam Mon Mar 17, 2008 10:36pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac
Didn't the great John Wooden show his players how to tie their shoes at their first practice? Seriously. Or is this one of those myths?

And how to put their socks on(to prevent blisters), IMS. I've heard that, too, from the idiot red-head if I remember correctly.

HawkeyeCubP Mon Mar 17, 2008 10:42pm

FWIW, There was a video bulletin this year for NCAAW regarding this type of situation, and the directive was to allow play to continue until a team is granted a timeout.

Adam Mon Mar 17, 2008 10:43pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by HawkeyeCubP
FWIW, There was a video bulletin this year for NCAAW regarding this type of situation, and the directive was to allow play to continue until a team is granted a timeout.

What if there's a foul? Or a violation? ;)

Scrapper1 Tue Mar 18, 2008 07:07am

Quote:

Originally Posted by ace
in a freshman game I worked a few years ago a player lost shoe and was looking at me like "you going to blow this whistle?"

In the first half of a D3 game this year, a defensive player says to me, "Ref, my shoe's untied!" during the play. I'm C, bench side, so I hear it and his coach hears it. The coach says, "That's a safety issue! You gotta blow the whistle!" I just said, "Not while they're on offense, Coach."

Offense takes a shot, defensive rebound, outlet pass, TWEET! Kid says, "You takin' away a fast break?" I said, "It's a safety issue."

I didn't say, "Don't try to screw around with me again."


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:29pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1