Was reading my rule book tonight....
for the first time in a while. I don't know them like I used to and its been bugging me.
Was reading where coaches can not use video-tape of the current game at half-time for coaching purposes, but I did not see any specific penalty. Coaches are pulling out the stops these days to win. So what do you do if a coach uses video during half-time? |
If you can verify this, then the proper penalty is a team technical foul. Nothing gets charged either directly or indirectly to the head coach.
The reference is 10-1-3 and the chart on page 72. |
I think it also merits a report to the state association.
|
Quote:
It's just another rule that has been infringed and the proper penalty given. Nothing more needs to be made out of it. |
Quote:
I know other states (Iowa, for example) that only require notification when there's an disqualification (ejection) by multiple technical fouls or flagrant involved. Also, at the JV level, they want us to send a report if there is a jv home team not wearing white. They don't want the Ts called below varsity level, but they want to know about it. |
Quote:
My point was that I don't agree with reporting some Ts and not others just because the T is for an unusual reason and the official doesn't encounter it that often. Treat them all the same. |
I'm not sure I agree on this one, as it's a clear example of attempting to cheat rather than just an example of poor sportsmanship. It's not even just "bending the rules," IMO. It's more akin to the Patriots' little gaffe this season.
I'd also consider reporting to the state if I had other examples of cheating. I think this might fit a different category from most technical fouls. |
Aren't all rule infractions that get caught and penalized by definition an attempt to cheat? ;)
|
Quote:
Breaking this rule is different. IMO, of course. |
How about removing the scorebook from the table at halftime? :D
How about a coach sending a team member with five fouls to the table to sub in, but the scorer catches it and prevents the kid from entering? |
Quote:
Your second option, isn't that a flagrant T on the coach? If not, I would include that in the cheating category worthy of a report to the appropriate governing body. |
Quote:
|
Since you are trying to place the offenses in categories, how about this one:
10-3-3 ... Purposely and/or deceitfully delay returning after legally being OOB. What's more clearly an attempt to cheat than a purposeful and deceitful act? |
Quote:
In general, the more unusual an incident or situation is, the more likely that the state should be informed about it. And no, I'm not suggesting that we should be filing a report after every game. |
Sorry, BITS, but the point that I'm making is that the NFHS has already made the determination for us on what is "blatant cheating" and what is not. For those acts that are the NFHS has provided a penalty of a flagrant foul. However, for those acts which the NFHS does not consider to rise to this level, just a normal technical foul is required.
You are putting your own personal feelings into this instead of just administering the rules as written as the NFHS instructs us to do. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:39am. |