![]() |
you are correct, all i was trying to convey is that the throw in never ended..if the throw in never ended how could you be inbounding from a spot different from the original inbounds spot...can you think of a situation where you would?
|
Quote:
then again i don't believe in picking/chosing which rules to enforce. So I don't know. The best way to avoid this is not to have an IW :) |
Quote:
NCAA, they do it your way, IMS. |
Quote:
A non-throw-in violation (kicking, hitting with a fist, BI, throwing the ball through the basket). |
Quote:
|
Since the rules don't specify; I'd say to put the ball back in play at the original throwin spot since it makes the most sense.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
It ain't covered definitively. Everybody is free to follow their own "sense" as to which is the appropriate throw-in spot. My own personal sense says that it's the same throw-in and I'm just gonna duplicate it. Iow, it's going back to the original spot. That doesn't mean that Skippy's different "sense" is wrong though. This is another play that needs a FED interpretation. |
Quote:
Quote:
Could this be handled as an inadvertent whistle if the table hasn't been notified? |
Quote:
I would say the time-out request has already be recognized by the official. No. Why would you go IAW |
Quote:
|
Quote:
NCAA iaw says the whistle was blown as an oversight, with no call to make. edited - as snaqwells writes, either way you grant the timeout. |
Quote:
I understand it was an IW. Correct you must still grant the TO request. I was asking why should you try to treat as an IW and not grant the TO. Maybe, I did not make that clear enough in my response. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I'm thinking of a common situation (at least in youth basketball) where there's a scramble for a ball and in the midst of a tie up, someone asks for a timeout. Usually you'll see a held ball signal with no timeout granted, or a timeout granted with no held ball called, depending on the officials' judgment. Based on the quoted logic, should the timeout request be granted despite a held ball call? |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:16am. |