The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Moronic coach comment of the day (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/32205-moronic-coach-comment-day.html)

Scrapper1 Mon Feb 26, 2007 02:26pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChrisSportsFan
why we are to "stare at his pants"

It just confuses the heck out of them. :)

81artmonk Mon Feb 26, 2007 04:33pm

curious
 
A TF cannot be given prior to a game can it?? If it can I am wondering how can a foul be handed out when nothing has started. Again this is just my opinion without any knowledge of the rule, but I can see if two players get into a fight prior to game time that they should be removed and/or ejected. simpley for fighting. But how can a foul be handed out prior to something not even in affect yet?? Just wondering?

Jurassic Referee Mon Feb 26, 2007 04:38pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by 81artmonk
A TF cannot be given prior to a game can it?? If it can I am wondering how can a foul be handed out when nothing has started. Again this is just my opinion without any knowledge of the rule, but I can see if two players get into a fight prior to game time that they should be removed and/or ejected. simpley for fighting. But how can a foul be handed out prior to something not even in affect yet?? Just wondering?

You really should get a rulebook if you're going to coach. And I'm not being smart-azzed when I say that either.

The officials' jurisdiction starts as soon as they step on the court- which is usually at least 15 minutes before game time. From that time on until all of the officials have left the court at the end of the game, you are governed by all the "technical foul" rules when it comes to behavior, etc. If you don't believe that, tell 3 of your players to dunk the ball in warm-ups. :D

bgtg19 Mon Feb 26, 2007 04:44pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.
Of course he took exception to my explanation and told me that he thought I was in idiot if I thought I could keep her from playing as long as she had her earrings covered with bandaides. I told him that I may well be an idiot, but his opponents were going to start the game shooting two free throws and then get the ball for a throw-in at the division line and that he had lost the coaching box for the entire game. He asked why, and I told him he had just committed a TF for calling me an idiot. The then told me that I could not T him before the game started. I informed him I could and had just did. At that point he said that the next thing I was going to tell him that I could eject him from the game before it even started. I told him that I could to which he replied that I was a bigger idiot than he thought I was, to which I replied, that he could leave the court right now because he was ejected.

Great story, well told!

81artmonk Mon Feb 26, 2007 04:57pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee
The officials' jurisdiction starts as soon as they step on the court- which is usually at least 15 minutes before game time. From that time on until all of the officials have left the court at the end of the game, you are governed by all the "technical foul" rules when it comes to behavior, etc. If you don't believe that, tell 3 of your players to dunk the ball in warm-ups. :D


I believe you, but that brings up so many issues that could cause a riot. What if the game is over, players are congradulating the other team and someone says something to the ref. What you say is the ref can T up the player. So the game is over and about 2/12 minutes has gone by and Team A has won. Are you saying that the ref can send Team B to the line for freethrows and win the game even after the game has ended?? What if the refs hadn't left yet and were walking toward the door and a player verbally abused a ref?? What happens in those scenrios?? You can't send a player to the line for freethrows can you?? And if you can't do that, how can you justify the same thing before a game?? Just questions about what would happen?? Not questioning your knowledge. just wondering??

jdw3018 Mon Feb 26, 2007 05:06pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by 81artmonk
I believe you, but that brings up so many issues that could cause a riot. What if the game is over, players are congradulating the other team and someone says something to the ref. What you say is the ref can T up the player. So the game is over and about 2/12 minutes has gone by and Team A has won. Are you saying that the ref can send Team B to the line for freethrows and win the game even after the game has ended?? What if the refs hadn't left yet and were walking toward the door and a player verbally abused a ref?? What happens in those scenrios?? You can't send a player to the line for freethrows can you?? And if you can't do that, how can you justify the same thing before a game?? Just questions about what would happen?? Not questioning your knowledge. just wondering??

Yes, actually, an official can call a T after the game, but before they've left the court. And if the FTs could have an impact on the outcome of the game, then they are administered as part of the 4th quarter.

I did, however, bold part of your statement above - if I'm officiating, I can't think of a scenario in which I'm still on the court 2 1/2 minutes after the game has ended unless there are things playing out that will impact the game...

NewNCref Mon Feb 26, 2007 05:06pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by 81artmonk
I believe you, but that brings up so many issues that could cause a riot. What if the game is over, players are congradulating the other team and someone says something to the ref. What you say is the ref can T up the player. So the game is over and about 2/12 minutes has gone by and Team A has won. Are you saying that the ref can send Team B to the line for freethrows and win the game even after the game has ended?? What if the refs hadn't left yet and were walking toward the door and a player verbally abused a ref?? What happens in those scenrios?? You can't send a player to the line for freethrows can you?? And if you can't do that, how can you justify the same thing before a game?? Just questions about what would happen?? Not questioning your knowledge. just wondering??

Everything you just said is perfectly legal. If a player is stupid enough to verbally abuse a referee after they've won the game, you better believe the T is coming. And yes, B could shoot, and in theory, win the game based off of that.

Adam Mon Feb 26, 2007 05:08pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by 81artmonk
I believe you, but that brings up so many issues that could cause a riot. What if the game is over, players are congradulating the other team and someone says something to the ref. What you say is the ref can T up the player. So the game is over and about 2/12 minutes has gone by and Team A has won. Are you saying that the ref can send Team B to the line for freethrows and win the game even after the game has ended?? What if the refs hadn't left yet and were walking toward the door and a player verbally abused a ref?? What happens in those scenrios?? You can't send a player to the line for freethrows can you?? And if you can't do that, how can you justify the same thing before a game?? Just questions about what would happen?? Not questioning your knowledge. just wondering??

Two and a half minutes after the game; I'm in the locker room. If there's a shower, I'm almost in it. If not, I've got my shoes changed and I'm doing a post-game with my partner, maybe even laughting at the coaches and/or fans.
That said, if you're not off the floor yet and a coach comes and verbally assaults you, you can still call the T. The final horn is not a blank check for the coaches. There is a case play on this exact scenario, where a coach whose team just finished regulation up by two approaches the ref and levels some obscenities at him. The ruling is to call the T and shoot the free throws to determine whether overtime will be played.
yes, you can send the player to the line for free throws.

Adam Mon Feb 26, 2007 05:10pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by jdw3018
- if I'm officiating, I can't think of a scenario in which I'm still on the court 2 1/2 minutes after the game has ended unless there are things playing out that will impact the game...

I can. AAU games, YMCA games, Rec games, etc. If that much time has gone by, we've started jurisdiction for the next game. I'll let game management deal with the idiot from the previous game.

jdw3018 Mon Feb 26, 2007 05:11pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells
I can. AAU games, YMCA games, Rec games, etc. If that much time has gone by, we've started jurisdiction for the next game. I'll let game management deal with the idiot from the previous game.

Touche...though I'm almost always going to step out the door somewhere for my drink of water or something that officially "changes jurisdiction."

Dan_ref Mon Feb 26, 2007 05:14pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by 81artmonk
Not questioning your knowledge. just wondering??

The rule is the official's jurisdiction lasts from the time they enter the area before the game until they leave the confines of the court afterwards.

Those are the rules, period. If someone wants to take a shot at the official during that time then they open themselves up for trouble.

Again, like it or not there it is.

JugglingReferee Mon Feb 26, 2007 05:21pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by 81artmonk
A TF cannot be given prior to a game can it?? If it can I am wondering how can a foul be handed out when nothing has started. Again this is just my opinion without any knowledge of the rule, but I can see if two players get into a fight prior to game time that they should be removed and/or ejected. simpley for fighting. But how can a foul be handed out prior to something not even in affect yet?? Just wondering?

The jurisdiction of the officials begins when they enter the court.

For example, if they're still in their change room, and a players dunks, nothing can be done. But once they're in the court, dunking is a T. Same with morons coaches, etc...

archangel Mon Feb 26, 2007 05:27pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by 81artmonk
A TF cannot be given prior to a game can it?? If it can I am wondering how can a foul be handed out when nothing has started. Again this is just my opinion without any knowledge of the rule, but I can see if two players get into a fight prior to game time that they should be removed and/or ejected. simpley for fighting. But how can a foul be handed out prior to something not even in affect yet?? Just wondering?


How about a player dunking during warmups??.....TF

Mark Padgett Mon Feb 26, 2007 05:30pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by archangel
How about a player dunking during warmups??.....TF

If the officials are on the court, it's a T.

BTW - the post way above didn't say 2 1/2 minutes after the game, it said 2/12 minutes. 2/12 of a minute is 10 seconds. :)

81artmonk Mon Feb 26, 2007 08:34pm

clarification
 
What does the rule define as court?? The acual playing boundries or beyond that? such as the stands or the bench or the scorers table??


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:02am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1