Quote:
|
Quote:
In my situation, and at that moment, it appeared to me that this was an instance of advantage/disadvantage. |
Quote:
Are you telling me that if the players were facing each other and you have a clear held ball and because of the force of the players tugging on the ball they fall to the floor you have to have a foul? If that is what you are saying that is horrible judgment. The held ball took place first. Also just wrapping your arms around another player is not automatically a foul either. You do not have to agree with that, but remember you said there was no contact and now you are calling a foul. Not only is that bad judgment that is not using the rules the way they are supposed to be used. Peace |
Quote:
I am just not totally sold that a held ball is the absolute best call and was curious if advantage/disadvantage could and/or should be taken into account. |
Quote:
The issue is did the player gain an illegal advantage. The way you wrote your post I would say no. |
Quote:
If a player is athletic enough to go over another player's head, get the ball, and pull it back....all without contacting the player's body....that player deserves the rebound. Period. If pulling the ball causes the other player to fall, that it too bad. It is either a held ball or NOTHING (depending on how easily the player from behind was able to strip the ball). |
Quote:
You came here and asked a question. So far to a man (or woman, sorry Juulie you have not posted yet) everyone has told you very explicitly this is not a foul. All I know is you cannot call a foul without some contact. And contact can be severe and not be a foul if you simply read the rulebook. Now if you are convinced that everyone here is wrong that is your right to do so. But I will tell you that making calls like this are the reason why a lot of officials never get better opportunities (moving up, better games, better conferences, and playoffs). All you have done is tell us what happen and debate the answer. Peace |
Quote:
|
Quote:
This board seems clearly convinced a held ball is simply and only a held ball, regardless of the situation, as long as there is no contact. I've got no problem with this boards interpretation and following of the good old rules book. So "peace" to you my friend. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Huh?
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
When I see posters that have provided thousands of comments, I think these folks probably have something intelligent to add to my favorite avocation. Either way, I have always respected this board’s comments and opinions and will continue to frequent and pose questions for anyone to respond. |
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
What does advantage/disadvantage have to do with it if there is not any contact? How about this, 150lb A1 goes up for a shot, 260lb B1 blocks the shot before A1 releases the ball. The force of B1 blocking the shot forces A1 to fall to the floor and bang his head. Do you call a foul on B1 even though there was no contact at all? |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:11pm. |