The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Was this done correctly? (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/30607-done-correctly.html)

Teigan Thu Jan 04, 2007 12:12am

Was this done correctly?
 
I worked a game the other night and we had this scenario. Player was driving to the basket, and got a bump. My partner who was trail called the push...The player dribbling the ball continued his drive, just for the fun of it i guess........He went up for his layup, and got a body check type of thing. It was not "unsporting, flagrant, or intentional" but it was enough that it needed to be called. So I blew it. This whole little scenario maybe was done in a total of 6 seconds. We both reported the foul, and gave the ball back to the offended team. I was wondering did we do this correctly, and is there any rule interpretations that someone could provide.

budjones05 Thu Jan 04, 2007 12:48am

You and your partner should of came together and see what foul came first. It sounds like the bump came first to me, but I would of not called a false double foul.

lorenj Thu Jan 04, 2007 01:00am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Teigan
I worked a game the other night and we had this scenario. Player was driving to the basket, and got a bump. My partner who was trail called the push...The player dribbling the ball continued his drive, just for the fun of it i guess........He went up for his layup, and got a body check type of thing. It was not "unsporting, flagrant, or intentional" but it was enough that it needed to be called. So I blew it. This whole little scenario maybe was done in a total of 6 seconds. We both reported the foul, and gave the ball back to the offended team. I was wondering did we do this correctly, and is there any rule interpretations that someone could provide.

It sounds like the "body check" (as you described it) definitely came after your partner called the push. If this is the case, you cannot call the second foul unless it is intentional or flagrant. The first foul caused the ball to become dead, so any contact afterward should be ignored unless it is intentional or flagrant. If you rule that it is intentional or flagrant, you should call a technical foul for dead-ball contact (10-3-8).

Case book play 10.3.8 deals with a similar situation. Note that in your situation, this would be a false multiple-foul rather than a false double-foul if you penalize the dead-ball contact, since it only involves fouls by one team:
"SITUATION: B1 fouls A1 during an unsuccessful try. While the calling official is reporting the foul, A1 pushes B1 into another player.
RULING: Intentional contact while the ball is dead constitutes an intentional technical foul. If other dead-ball contact is not intentional or flagrant, it should be ignored. The foul by A1 creates a false double-foul situation."

budjones05 Thu Jan 04, 2007 01:01am

You and your partner should of came together and see what foul came first. It sounds like the bump came first to me, but I would of not called a false double foul.

rainmaker Thu Jan 04, 2007 01:14am

I doubt it took 6 seconds.

Assuming it was more like two seconds, the shot still should not have been taken, and the body check still should not have happened. But it wasn't a foul unless it was "flagrant, intentional or unsporting." If you blew your whistle, and then told the players, "Hey, play's dead, knock it off." that's not calling the foul, and is an acceptable way to let the defender know that the contact was out of line. If you reported the whistle as a foul, meaning if your crew reported two fouls, you goofed. Why did you decide that the appropriate penalty was to give the ball back to the offended team?

Adam Thu Jan 04, 2007 01:34am

If you thought the contact was severe enough it needed to be called, you should have called it a technical foul since the ball was dead. Two shots and the throw-in at half-court. False-multiple, not false-double.

ncaabbref Thu Jan 04, 2007 10:22am

correct Snaqwells. if severe enough also, this can be flagrant as well...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:46am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1