The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Is this a T (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/24904-t.html)

ATLBrvs326 Fri Feb 10, 2006 07:41pm

A1 dribbles ball into the corner and is being closely guarded by B1 and the corner. Instead of throwing the ball at B1s feet he throws it at his face? Is this a Technical on A1?

zebraman Fri Feb 10, 2006 08:07pm

Quote:

Originally posted by ATLBrvs326
A1 dribbles ball into the corner and is being closely guarded by B1 and the corner. Instead of throwing the ball at B1s feet he throws it at his face? Is this a Technical on A1?
If you feel that it was an intentional sportsmanlike act, give a T. Don't guess. See Case Play 10.3.7 Situation B.

Z

assignmentmaker Sat Feb 11, 2006 01:23am

Quote:

Originally posted by ATLBrvs326
A1 dribbles ball into the corner and is being closely guarded by B1 and the corner. Instead of throwing the ball at B1s feet he throws it at his face? Is this a Technical on A1?
Good God! I had this tonight, too! What is happening . . .

Only a variant. A1, trying to control a ball ponging around post rebound, is going out of bounds over the endline and throws the ball with two hands backwards over her shoulder. Pow, right in the kisser of B1. B1 toughed it out, and there was zero intention involved, so, in this case, I gave the ball to A1 for a throw-in.

I certainly agree with those who have previously suggested that if this happens (ball in face) and there is any possibility that the defender had a choice about where to throw the ball, one ought err on the side of intentional personal foul, lest WWIII ensue.

Nevadaref Sun Feb 12, 2006 02:08am

Quote:

Originally posted by assignmentmaker
Quote:

Originally posted by ATLBrvs326
A1 dribbles ball into the corner and is being closely guarded by B1 and the corner. Instead of throwing the ball at B1s feet he throws it at his face? Is this a Technical on A1?
Good God! I had this tonight, too! What is happening . . .

Only a variant. A1, trying to control a ball ponging around post rebound, is going out of bounds over the endline and throws the ball with two hands backwards over her shoulder. Pow, right in the kisser of B1. B1 toughed it out, and there was zero intention involved, so, in this case, I gave the ball to A1 for a throw-in.

I certainly agree with those who have previously suggested that if this happens (ball in face) and there is any possibility that the defender had a choice about where to throw the ball, one ought err on the side of <font color = red>intentional personal foul</font>, lest WWIII ensue.

I guess this depends upon how you define illegal contact, but I think that it means some body part of one player touching some body part of an opponent. IOW I believe that to deem contacting the opponent with the ball an intentional personal foul would be an error. I have to go with an unsporting technical foul.

assignmentmaker Sun Feb 12, 2006 02:38am

Quote:

Originally posted by Nevadaref
Quote:

Originally posted by assignmentmaker
Quote:

Originally posted by ATLBrvs326
A1 dribbles ball into the corner and is being closely guarded by B1 and the corner. Instead of throwing the ball at B1s feet he throws it at his face? Is this a Technical on A1?
Good God! I had this tonight, too! What is happening . . .

Only a variant. A1, trying to control a ball ponging around post rebound, is going out of bounds over the endline and throws the ball with two hands backwards over her shoulder. Pow, right in the kisser of B1. B1 toughed it out, and there was zero intention involved, so, in this case, I gave the ball to A1 for a throw-in.

I certainly agree with those who have previously suggested that if this happens (ball in face) and there is any possibility that the defender had a choice about where to throw the ball, one ought err on the side of <font color = red>intentional personal foul</font>, lest WWIII ensue.

I guess this depends upon how you define illegal contact, but I think that it means some body part of one player touching some body part of an opponent. IOW I believe that to deem contacting the opponent with the ball an intentional personal foul would be an error. I have to go with an unsporting technical foul.

I agree. Thanks.

Dribble Sun Feb 12, 2006 03:24am

If those stupid AND1 tour games aren't on TV all the time, then less people would even think about bouncing the ball off someone's face! Can you imagine being assigned to work one of those games? Might as well swallow your whistle or leave it in your pocket.

Anyway, automatic T for me if it was intentional. No question...

In the situation listed above though, did you think he did it intentionally or was he possibly trying to pass out of the corner and made incidental contact with the face? From the way you posted it, it definitely sounds intentional and that would be a T.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:35am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1