Quote:
Originally posted by Camron Rust
Quote:
Originally posted by Back In The Saddle
However, in this case you have a fairly specific exception to the foul rule and we're debating how/if it applies to the oob rule. There's no case on it (as far as I know), no official interpretation (again, as far as I know) and the result of the literal application pits head against gut.
|
What about the one that says the last player to touch the ball before it goes OOB is the one that has violated? 
|
You could easily argue that the lack of a case or official interpretation is in fact a tacit endorsement of the literal interpretation. But we're all pretty much in agreement that the literal interpretation is "wrong." Not wrong by rule, wrong by feel. Which is why pretty much everyone has said they'd give the ball back to A. We only differ in the reasoning we'd apply to support our decision.
Tue Jul 19, 2005, 06:35pm
Threaded Mode
