Violent collision, equal opportunity to the ball?

[PS2Man]

Originally posted by gordon30307

Hi Mick, I disagree that a no call after a collision is an "easy out". Normally with one or two players on the floor with no call your going to hear from one or both coache's complaining. Somewhere in the rule or case book there a statement that talks about collisions sometimes violent (obviously no advantage) that are considered to be "incidental contact" Now the type of play I'm referring to is a long pass where A1 and B1 get there at the same time with a violent collision. You have something like this and you have one or both coaches begging for a call.

You cannot make calls just because a coach wants one. The rules make it very clear that a violent collision can take place and nothing should be called. This is all laid out clearly in rule 4-27-2.