Solve this one

[Grant]

Offensive player goes to dunk and misses while holding the rim he reaches back grabs the ball with the other hand and dunks it just as the whislte is going for hanging on the rim.

[RookieDude]

Originally posted by Grant
Offensive player goes to dunk and misses while holding the rim he reaches back grabs the ball with the other hand and dunks it just as the whislte is going for hanging on the rim.

T

[totalnewbie]

How about this:

T for hanging on the rim, the dunk after is irrelevant (though it sure makes your T look good).

No different than a guy lobing up a shot after the play is dead. You dont want them doing it, but it doesnt get another whistle.

Clark

[Grant]

what about possesson AP

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally posted by Grant
Offensive player goes to dunk and misses while holding the rim he reaches back grabs the ball with the other hand and dunks it just as the whislte is going for hanging on the rim.

Technical foul and offensive basket interference.

[totalnewbie]

what does that matter? its a T, so you shoot 2 and the opponent gets the ball at the division line opposite. no need to even go to the arrow. am i missing something?

[totalnewbie]

no need to even get to the offensive BI is there? the T made it a dead ball so the basket couldnt have counted anyway, right?

[Adam]

Originally posted by totalnewbie
no need to even get to the offensive BI is there? the T made it a dead ball so the basket couldnt have counted anyway, right?

Hanging on the rim made the ball dead. I don't care if the whistle blows after he makes the dunk and lands on the floor. No basket. Technical foul. No other call is necessary here.

[Grant]

but then there is no possession so how do we restart certainly not at center

[RookieDude]

Originally posted by Grant
but then there is no possession so how do we restart certainly not at center

Huh?
In this sitch, NFHS rules, technical foul, you go opposite table at the division line.

[cmckenna]

Here is something I have always wondered....

If your not supposed to contact the rim while the ball is in contact with the rim, howcome a dunk is legal??? As you can tell, I am bored today....

[bob jenkins]

Originally posted by cmckenna
Here is something I have always wondered....

If your not supposed to contact the rim while the ball is in contact with the rim, howcome a dunk is legal??? As you can tell, I am bored today....

Because the BI rule alows for a ball to be carried from outside the cylinder to inside the cylinder.

On the original play:

1) T for hanging on the rim
2) T for dunking with a dead ball
3) T on the coach when you call #2.

[BoomerSooner]

Just to complicate things, but what if he had been hanging to prevent injury and had rebounded and dunked the ball in the previously described manner.

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally posted by BoomerSooner
Just to complicate things, but what if he had been hanging to prevent injury and had rebounded and dunked the ball in the previously described manner.

No T but BI is called. Case book play 10.3.4SitB(a).

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally posted by bob jenkins

Because the BI rule alows for a ball to be carried from outside the cylinder to inside the cylinder.

On the original play:

1) T for hanging on the rim
2) T for dunking with a dead ball
3) T on the coach when you call #2.

I get it. You wanna be MTD Sr. when you grow up.