#12 vs #12

[golfdesigner]

Need some feed back on this one.

BJV game, we go to table to check book at 11 minute mark, to make sure all is good. V Coach comes up and says we have 2 #12, [1 a Soph coming up to JV game and 1 from V squad playing in JV game] he says all is okay though because the table knows the difference.

We say okay let's proceed.

With 4 minutes to go in game I as L call foul on #12,report foul to table [yep you guessed it] table sounds horn and says "that's 5 on #12.

I can't really recall if both #12s were in game at the same time, I don't think so.


V Coach jumps up yelling "no way" that's only like maybe three"

Table says "no that's 5" [Let me add V team had a table representative working their own book during the entire game.]

We go to table check what is the discrepancy, "official" book shows 5 visitors book shows 3 on #12...

Granted these are volunteer students doing the books for both teams, not adults that are paid...

What do we have?

I would have expected that between the two books, since the "table" knows the difference, we would not have had an issue like this...

Neither my partner or I had definite knowledge that #12 had eitehr 3 or 5 fouls.

Any suggestions for next time?