Player not in book

[cmathews]

Nevadaref,
Good points. I don't know if I agree with the interp about when it is "discovered" but you certainly have valid arguments. In the original post I am not sure the player ever participated. Maybe the coach sent the kid in, realized what could happen and took them back out before the ball became live....If that were the case even with your interp I would not T them up..I can't find my case book, but I would like to look at it before I jump on board your bandwagon......but right now I could be convinced...