The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   First big goof-up- (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/11698-first-big-goof-up.html)

sleebo Wed Jan 14, 2004 10:31am

My partner and I "dropped the ball" last night...As we opened up the fourth quarter, we accidentally let the teams go the wrong way. White took the throw in from half court like they should have, but we sent them going away from their bench instead of toward it. They inbound the ball, bring it into the (wrong) frontcourt, pass it around and then drill a 3. About 14 seconds run off the clock and then we realize we screwed up. I was the U in this two-whistle game, so luckily I didn't have to make the final decision, but I still had input into the decision that was made (I'm almost positive we did it wrong). Here's what we did: since the basket was scored in red's basket, we gave 3 points to red and gave the ball OOB to red for a throw-in during which they were permitted to run the baseline if needed. After getting home and taking a look at the books, it seems from the simplified and illustrated book that we should have given the basket to the white team, instructed the teams to go the right way from that point forward and it would have been red ball with the baseline run permitted. SO...TWO QUESTIONS...WERE WE WRONG IN WHAT WE DID? and IS MY "RIGHT" ANSWER REALLY CORRECT?

*Note: The white team was up by about 30 points when this happened, so we were fortunate that our mistake(s) did not play into the outcome of the game :)

bob jenkins Wed Jan 14, 2004 10:35am

Quote:

Originally posted by sleebo
SO...TWO QUESTIONS...WERE WE WRONG IN WHAT WE DID? and IS MY "RIGHT" ANSWER REALLY CORRECT?


Yes. Yes.

danpri Wed Jan 14, 2004 10:49am

So then it should be....
 
Points go to those who scored them.

Reset direction correctly.

Give ball to team that did not score on the opposite side baseline (the one they should be on) with full run.


Hawks Coach Wed Jan 14, 2004 11:29am

Witnessed a bigger screw-up two days ago. Teams are aligned wrong for overtime jump ball. I was just an observer, but I noticed it right away and told the people sitting around me. There was a red violation on the jump, and the refs and some of the players on white understood that the teams were going the wrong way. Three white players are lined up at the true offensive end of the court, red has two players at each end and one in the middle, and everyone appears confused.

Instead of the refs clarifying, they hand the ball to the inbounder, she inbounded to a point guard in backcourt, and she comes to the front court (while the inbounder screams at her thinking it is a backcourt violation - she didn't even know what way they were going). While red tries to sort out what was going on, white passes to the block and gets the quick score. Red coach was understandably POd, red team gets distracted and loses ball, white team hits a three, and the rout is on.

Refs needed to get the teams set right before the re-start.

Dan_ref Wed Jan 14, 2004 11:52am

Quote:

Originally posted by Hawks Coach
Witnessed a bigger screw-up two days ago. Teams are aligned wrong for overtime jump ball. I was just an observer, but I noticed it right away and told the people sitting around me. There was a red violation on the jump, and the refs and some of the players on white understood that the teams were going the wrong way. Three white players are lined up at the true offensive end of the court, red has two players at each end and one in the middle, and everyone appears confused.

Instead of the refs clarifying, they hand the ball to the inbounder, she inbounded to a point guard in backcourt, and she comes to the front court (while the inbounder screams at her thinking it is a backcourt violation - she didn't even know what way they were going). While red tries to sort out what was going on, white passes to the block and gets the quick score. Red coach was understandably POd, red team gets distracted and loses ball, white team hits a three, and the rout is on.

Refs needed to get the teams set right before the re-start.

Speaking of screw-ups...

HS game, neither I nor my partner noticed the shot clock was at 30 instead of 35 to start the game. (Actually we saw it was at 35 when they tested it pregame but somehow it got moved to 30.) A wins the tip, scores in the first few seconds. B's coming up, I'm trail counting, I look up at shot clock and see it's at 29..."oh boy, here we go...note to self: talk to the shot clock operator at first dead ball"...normally I would have stopped the game right there but there was no BC pressure and I really, really, really expected B to get a shot off...and of course the clock gets down to 2 before they get off a shot which goes OOB. I go to table, tell her she screwed up & please remember to reset the clock. She and the clock operator look at me like I have 3 eyes and say "we did reset it!" Oh...now I'm thinking I'm glad I kept my mouth shut but wondering how I could have missed those 5 seconds.

Partner goes to inbound the ball, I look at the shot clock & it resets to 30. Ah-ha! Tweet! We get it straightened out and coach B asks if he can have those 5 seconds back later, when he needs it.


missinglink Wed Jan 14, 2004 11:57am

wrong way continued
 
Quote:

Originally posted by bob jenkins
Quote:

Originally posted by sleebo
SO...TWO QUESTIONS...WERE WE WRONG IN WHAT WE DID? and IS MY "RIGHT" ANSWER REALLY CORRECT?


Yes. Yes.

A twist on above. Last night at JV girls, I am a spectator and observed this with about three minutes left in 2nd quarter. A1 scores on a try.
SCOREBOARD: A 17, B 21.
B1 inbounds to B2 in A's free throw lane. B2 is confused and makes field goal in A's basket.
SB: A 19, B 21.
To prove that brain farts are contagious, A1 takes the ball on the end line and passes in to A2 who proceeds up the court and scores in B's goal.
SB: A 19, B23.
B3 takes the ball on the end line and passes into B2 who promptly scores a goal in B's basket.
SB A 19, B 25.

At this point official grants time out to Coach A who has had enough fun. Officials huddle with scorer and timer, leave all scores on the board and game continues with Team A throw in and both teams going the right direction.

First question: No question that the first wrong way bucket by B2 stays on the board but was the throw in by A1 a violation? I believe it was, but couldn't find an exact reference. Violation or not, when was the last point the officials could have whistled (something) and set things right?

2nd: While 4.5.4 applies in the case that started this thread, it doesn't seem to apply througout the followup I have provided and the scoreboard results should stand?




LSams Wed Jan 14, 2004 12:26pm

just another thought on this situation.

If a player takes a shot at the wrong basket from behind the 3-point arch, and hits the shot. Yes points are awarded to the other team -- but only 2 points -- as the players actions are by definition not a shot attmempt, because the player was not shooting at the proper basket. On the same note, if this player were to have been fouled while making this "shot attempt" it would be a common foul, not a shooting foul, and his/her team would be awarded the ball out of bounds or given bonus free-throws.


bob jenkins Wed Jan 14, 2004 12:49pm

Re: wrong way continued
 
Quote:

Originally posted by missinglink
Quote:

Originally posted by bob jenkins
Quote:

Originally posted by sleebo
SO...TWO QUESTIONS...WERE WE WRONG IN WHAT WE DID? and IS MY "RIGHT" ANSWER REALLY CORRECT?


Yes. Yes.

A twist on above. Last night at JV girls, I am a spectator and observed this with about three minutes left in 2nd quarter. A1 scores on a try.
SCOREBOARD: A 17, B 21.
B1 inbounds to B2 in A's free throw lane. B2 is confused and makes field goal in A's basket.
SB: A 19, B 21.
To prove that brain farts are contagious, A1 takes the ball on the end line and passes in to A2 who proceeds up the court and scores in B's goal.
SB: A 19, B23.
B3 takes the ball on the end line and passes into B2 who promptly scores a goal in B's basket.
SB A 19, B 25.

At this point official grants time out to Coach A who has had enough fun. Officials huddle with scorer and timer, leave all scores on the board and game continues with Team A throw in and both teams going the right direction.

First question: No question that the first wrong way bucket by B2 stays on the board but was the throw in by A1 a violation? I believe it was, but couldn't find an exact reference. Violation or not, when was the last point the officials could have whistled (something) and set things right?

2nd: While 4.5.4 applies in the case that started this thread, it doesn't seem to apply througout the followup I have provided and the scoreboard results should stand?




No question that the first "wrong" basket counts, and no question that the last one doesn't. See 10.something (10.1.9?) "A specific unsportsmanlike act" for how to treat the last "wrong basket."

The issue is what to do with's A's inbounding (which should have been caught and dealt with by the same case), or A's backcourt violation, or A's "wrong" basket.

These (well, the time period for correction) aren't covered in the rules, so (almost) anything the officials do with that is correct.

Some would apply the correctable error time period, some would say that the error can only be corrected "immediately".

Personally, I think I'd allow the first two "wrong" baskets, disallow the third and give A the ball on the baseline with the score A19, B23.


Hawks Coach Wed Jan 14, 2004 01:10pm

I think Bob's solution is probably best, but you could make a case for taking it back to the baseline under A's basket and giving ball to B as well, and just realize that everybody here screwed up quite a bit to get to this point. Not sure that I consider B's act to be unsporting, as everybody tends to assume that after one team puts ball in bucket, other team gets ball. So inbounding it after A has done same at opposite end is not unsporting, and scoring in your own basket because you realize everybody else's error is similarly not unsporting.

What a wacky play though, complicated by officials who were no mor ewith it than the players.

BktBallRef Wed Jan 14, 2004 01:33pm

Re: So then it should be....
 
Quote:

Originally posted by danpri
Points go to those who scored them.

Reset direction correctly.

Give ball to team that did not score on the opposite side baseline (the one they should be on) with full run.

The ball is put in play at the point of interruption. It does not change ends of the floor.

We discussed this in a thread last week.

Adam Wed Jan 14, 2004 01:36pm

Re: wrong way continued
 
Quote:

Originally posted by missinglink
A twist on above. Last night at JV girls, I am a spectator and observed this with about three minutes left in 2nd quarter. A1 scores on a try.
SCOREBOARD: A 17, B 21.
B1 inbounds to B2 in A's free throw lane. B2 is confused and makes field goal in A's basket.
SB: A 19, B 21.
To prove that brain farts are contagious, A1 takes the ball on the end line and passes in to A2 who proceeds up the court and scores in B's goal.
SB: A 19, B23.
B3 takes the ball on the end line and passes into B2 who promptly scores a goal in B's basket.
SB A 19, B 25.

At this point official grants time out to Coach A who has had enough fun. Officials huddle with scorer and timer, leave all scores on the board and game continues with Team A throw in and both teams going the right direction.

First question: No question that the first wrong way bucket by B2 stays on the board but was the throw in by A1 a violation? I believe it was, but couldn't find an exact reference. Violation or not, when was the last point the officials could have whistled (something) and set things right?

2nd: While 4.5.4 applies in the case that started this thread, it doesn't seem to apply througout the followup I have provided and the scoreboard results should stand?

If the officials are aware of what's happening. After B's mistaken basket in A's hoop (which was correctly credited to A), B should have the ball again. Once A grabbed it, you've got two options to stop the madness. Give A a delay of game warning (they should have known better, they'd just scored down there), give B the ball running the endline, and remind the teams which direction they are going. Or you could just blow it dead and give B the ball without a warning. I'd be inclined to warn them.

Once you've allowed A to inbound the ball after B put the ball in the wrong basket. You could have called A for a backcourt violation. It gives B the ball that they should have had, and punishes A for not paying attention, too.

w_sohl Wed Jan 14, 2004 02:01pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Hawks Coach
Witnessed a bigger screw-up two days ago. Teams are aligned wrong for overtime jump ball. I was just an observer, but I noticed it right away and told the people sitting around me. There was a red violation on the jump, and the refs and some of the players on white understood that the teams were going the wrong way. Three white players are lined up at the true offensive end of the court, red has two players at each end and one in the middle, and everyone appears confused.

Instead of the refs clarifying, they hand the ball to the inbounder, she inbounded to a point guard in backcourt, and she comes to the front court (while the inbounder screams at her thinking it is a backcourt violation - she didn't even know what way they were going). While red tries to sort out what was going on, white passes to the block and gets the quick score. Red coach was understandably POd, red team gets distracted and loses ball, white team hits a three, and the rout is on.

Refs needed to get the teams set right before the re-start.

I completely disagree! It is the players job to know which way they are going just as much as it is ours. It is not our responsibility to tell the players they are going the wrong way. Look at it this way, and this is a true story. Coach runs a play where his player line up under the wrong basket for an inbound in an attempt to confuse the other team and catch a break when one of the players breaks for the correct basket. Now if you are going to tell teh players that they are going the wrong way you are going to completely take away any advantage that that team had. The coaches and players need to know just as much as we do.

ChuckElias Wed Jan 14, 2004 02:13pm

Quote:

Originally posted by w_sohl
It is not our responsibility to tell the players they are going the wrong way.
No, but it is our job to tell them which way they should be going before we put the ball in play. Fed Official's Manual, paragraph 217, page 30.

Indicate which direction they should be going. If they then get fooled by the backcourt ploy (ah, yes, I know it well!), it's their own fault.

PublicBJ Wed Jan 14, 2004 05:25pm

Quote:

Originally posted by w_sohl
I completely disagree! It is the players job to know which way they are going just as much as it is ours. It is not our responsibility to tell the players they are going the wrong way. Look at it this way, and this is a true story. Coach runs a play where his player line up under the wrong basket for an inbound in an attempt to confuse the other team and catch a break when one of the players breaks for the correct basket. Now if you are going to tell teh players that they are going the wrong way you are going to completely take away any advantage that that team had. The coaches and players need to know just as much as we do.
My alma matter tried this once when I was refereeing. They told me before the quarter started that they were going to do it, and would I please not give it away. I told them that "I would do what I always do at the start of a quarter." Alma matter lines up the wrong way (trying to draw the other team into going the wrong way. Just before I administer the throw-in, I say: "Red ball, going this way!" (Pointing the right direction.) Alma matter was upset with me...

But it's true: before every throw-in to start a period or any other pause in the game (timeout, etc.), I always give color and direction. I think that it's simple preventative officiating to avoid situations like this thread is talking about, and also prevents teams from doing crap like my alma matter wanted to do, which is not in the spirit of the game.

stripes Wed Jan 14, 2004 05:37pm

Quote:

Originally posted by sleebo
I was the U in this two-whistle game, so luckily I didn't have to make the final decision, but I still had input into the decision that was made (I'm almost positive we did it wrong).

Why is being the U a cop out to letting someone else take the heat. Step up! Be the ref who fixes problems. Take some heat if you have to, but cowboy up and get it done and done right. Back in the Saddle talked about this a week or so ago--stepping up and being "the man" on his game. This is one way to show the people who matter that you are ready to do more and better games.

Hawks Coach Wed Jan 14, 2004 05:56pm

Quote:

Originally posted by w_sohl
Quote:

Originally posted by Hawks Coach
Witnessed a bigger screw-up two days ago. Teams are aligned wrong for overtime jump ball. I was just an observer, but I noticed it right away and told the people sitting around me. There was a red violation on the jump, and the refs and some of the players on white understood that the teams were going the wrong way. Three white players are lined up at the true offensive end of the court, red has two players at each end and one in the middle, and everyone appears confused.

Instead of the refs clarifying, they hand the ball to the inbounder, she inbounded to a point guard in backcourt, and she comes to the front court (while the inbounder screams at her thinking it is a backcourt violation - she didn't even know what way they were going). While red tries to sort out what was going on, white passes to the block and gets the quick score. Red coach was understandably POd, red team gets distracted and loses ball, white team hits a three, and the rout is on.

Refs needed to get the teams set right before the re-start.

I completely disagree! It is the players job to know which way they are going just as much as it is ours. It is not our responsibility to tell the players they are going the wrong way. Look at it this way, and this is a true story. Coach runs a play where his player line up under the wrong basket for an inbound in an attempt to confuse the other team and catch a break when one of the players breaks for the correct basket. Now if you are going to tell teh players that they are going the wrong way you are going to completely take away any advantage that that team had. The coaches and players need to know just as much as we do.

My example is clearly different from yours. In my example, the officials allowed red to face white's bench and white to face red's bench, tossed the ball for a jump, and thereby started play the wrong direction. The incorrect direction had official blessing when the ball was tossed. On the subsequent violation, when the refs realized that they had erred in starting play the wrong way with the jump ball, they should correct it and make it known to both teams and both coaches.

My situation is effectively no different than putting ball in play at the start of a period and both teams going the wrong way for a minute or two, with each scoring at the wrong end of the court, violating backcourt provisions in the process, etc. All points would be allowed. But the refs should not get the teams going opposite how they started to play (and were allowed by both officials to play) without clearly informing both teams of the error and getting them resituated.

Your situation is one team tricking another, which the officials do not have any responsibility to correct or clarify. You are not providing any official recognition that the players are going in one direction or another. But if you toss a jump ball with the players wrong, you have condoned their incorrect alignment and must correct this at the first opportunity when you note it.

w_sohl Wed Jan 14, 2004 06:19pm

Hawks Coach, I would agree 100% in that situation.

ChuckElias Wed Jan 14, 2004 07:59pm

Quote:

Originally posted by stripes
Take some heat if you have to, but cowboy up and get it done and done right.
Hmmm, now you're showing the true color of your sox. :)

sleebo Wed Jan 14, 2004 09:41pm

In relation to stripes' comment, I wasn't trying to totally cop out, I was just glad there wasn't a bunch of pressure on my back when I honestly didn't know the exact right way to handle the situation. I tried to step up and handle the situation (along with my partner) the best way I knew how to. I was just a little glad that I didn't have to make the total end-all decision as the R. That's all. Have a good one...

stripes Thu Jan 15, 2004 12:51am

Quote:

Originally posted by ChuckElias
Quote:

Originally posted by stripes
Take some heat if you have to, but cowboy up and get it done and done right.
Hmmm, now you're showing the true color of your sox. :)

I'll probably regret this, but what is the true color of my sox?

Jurassic Referee Thu Jan 15, 2004 01:03am

Quote:

Originally posted by stripes
Quote:

Originally posted by ChuckElias
Quote:

Originally posted by stripes
Take some heat if you have to, but cowboy up and get it done and done right.
Hmmm, now you're showing the true color of your sox. :)

I'll probably regret this, but what is the true color of my sox?

Red.

The BoSox used the "cowboy up" thingy as their theme last year.Hope you have more luck with it than they did.

ChuckElias Thu Jan 15, 2004 09:29am

In fact, I'd say that the Sox originated the phrase. Had anyone ever heard it before July or so last year? Not me.

dblref Thu Jan 15, 2004 10:30am

Quote:

Originally posted by ChuckElias
In fact, I'd say that the Sox originated the phrase. Had anyone ever heard it before July or so last year? Not me.
Not quite so fast there my vertically challenged friend. If you ventured south of the Mason-Dixon line (way, way, south), you might hear this expression quite often. I know I did when I grew up down thar. You hear "cowboy up" and "pony up" quite a bit.


ChuckElias Thu Jan 15, 2004 10:53am

Quote:

Originally posted by dblref
If you ventured south of the Mason-Dixon line (way, way, south), you might hear this expression quite often. I know I did when I grew up down thar. You hear "cowboy up" and "pony up" quite a bit.
Well, then I stand (yes, I am standing!) corrected. As a lifelong <s>Yan</s> (cough, cough, sputter, sputter) Northerner, I'd never heard "cowboy up" before, although "pony up" is common around here.

cmathews Thu Jan 15, 2004 11:03am

Out here in the west I have heard it my whole life. Then again I grew up rodeoing all the time so it shouldn't come as a surprise that I would have heard that term...will that start some other sort of curse for the Sox?? some sort of stealing rallying crys curse or something ;)

stripes Thu Jan 15, 2004 02:11pm

Didn't know that the BoSox used the phrase. If I knew, I would have used it more judiciously, as I would do most anything to avoid association with the hated Red Sox (not to mention all of the AL--get rid of the DH and play real baseball), but being from the western US, cowboy up is a very common phrase.

ChuckElias Fri Jan 16, 2004 09:58pm

Quote:

Originally posted by cmathews
Out here in the west I have heard it my whole life. Then again I grew up rodeoing all the time so it shouldn't come as a surprise that I would have heard that term...
I didn't realize it had been around so long, but apparently "cowboy up" was actually copyrighted 30 years ago, much like Pat Riley copyrighted "three-peat". At least, that's what Kevin Millar says: http://sports.espn.go.com/page2/s/questions/millar.html


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:02pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1