Judge does the wrong thing!

[rockyroad]

Originally posted by Snaqwells
The question is how conclusive was the video tape regarding who was fighting and who was peacemaking? If it's difficult to tell, then you must either make arbitrary decisions on shaky evidence or punish everyone.

Or punish the ones that you KNOW were fighting, and not punish everyone arbitrarily at all...if you miss some of the fighters then you miss some, but you don't punish kids who weren't part of it...