The Official Forum - Thorw-In Spot

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)

- Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)

- - Thorw-In Spot (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/106571-thorw-spot.html)

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 1055106)

Where does it say a throw-in violation changed to one of the 8 spots if the original violation was not at the 8 spots?

PENALTY
The ball becomes dead when the throw-in provision violation occurs.
1. When a throw-in violation occurs during a throw-in following an
out-of-bounds violation, the offended team is awarded the ball for a
designated-spot throw-in from the applicable throw-in spot.

"Applicable" not "original".

And only for an original out of bounds violation, not all violations.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1055121)

PENALTY
The ball becomes dead when the throw-in provision violation occurs.
1. When a throw-in violation occurs during a throw-in following an
out-of-bounds violation, the offended team is awarded the ball for a
designated-spot throw-in from the applicable throw-in spot.

"Applicable" not "original".

And only for an original out of bounds violation, not all violations.

Well, if it's a violation other than OOB (or defensive GT, BI), then the throw-in is ALREADY from one of the 8 spots. So, a throw-in violation would go back to the same one of 8 spots.

And if it's defensive GT / BI, the team is running the end line, and a throw-in violation would result in the other team getting a throw-in at one of the 8 spots on the end-line.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1055119)

E

Original spot (sure surprised me).

When a throw in violation occurs during a throw‑in for a violation, foul or other stoppage, the offended team is awarded the ball for a designated‑spot throw‑in from the original throw‑in spot.

Right from 23-24 Interps: SITUATION 1: Team A has an alternating possession throw-in at the division line to start the second quarter. (A) Team A commits a violation by taking longer than five seconds to release the ball, (b) A2 commits a common foul in Team A's backcourt near the free throw line before the bonus is in effect. RULING: In (a) Team B is awarded a division line throw-in and in (b) Team B is awarded a throw-in from one of the designated spots closest to where the foul was committed. COMMENT: A throw-in violation that occurs during a division line throw-in remains at the division line. When a foul occurs during a division line throw-in the spot of the in-bound will be based on where the foul occurred. (5-4-2, 7-5-3a, 7-5-4)

Quote:

Rather than rely on some general "rules of thumb", I decided to use the "penalty" section of different rules (common fouls, violations, etc.) that would subsequently lead to a throwin.

By definition (I assume; I didn't really look this up), "rules of thumb" are wrong in some specific circumstances.

Always Listen To bob ...

Throw violation during a throwin following a technical foul, or at the start of a period? Original spot, or one of eight spots?

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 1055123)

23-24 Interps: SITUATION 1: Team A has an alternating possession throw-in at the division line to start the second quarter. (A) Team A commits a violation by taking longer than five seconds to release the ball, (b) A2 commits a common foul in Team A's backcourt near the free throw line before the bonus is in effect. RULING: In (a) Team B is awarded a division line throw-in and in (b) Team B is awarded a throw-in from one of the designated spots closest to where the foul was committed. COMMENT: A throw-in violation that occurs during a division line throw-in remains at the division line. When a foul occurs during a division line throw-in the spot of the in-bound will be based on where the foul occurred. (5-4-2, 7-5-3a, 7-5-4)

Thanks, bob jenkins. Perfect interpretation pairing to my rule citation.

When a throw in violation occurs during a throw‑in for a violation, foul or other stoppage, the offended team is awarded the ball for a designated‑spot throw‑in from the original throw‑in spot.