The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Apparel 3-5 (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/105598-apparel-3-5-a.html)

Zoochy Sun Jan 02, 2022 12:39pm

Apparel 3-5
 
https://www.stltoday.com/sports/high...539dcb.html#17
See 18th picture. Is anything illegal with #11's tights?

https://www.stltoday.com/sports/high...33130c7ac.html
See 1st picture. Is anything illegal with #1's tights? Do they need to be the same visual length?

BryanV21 Sun Jan 02, 2022 12:42pm

I believe as long as they don't normally show (like when a player just stands straight) then any color is fine. Otherwise, if they normally extend below the bottom of the shorts, they need to be the same basic color of the shorts.

At least I remember something like that.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

BillyMac Sun Jan 02, 2022 12:55pm

Colour My World (Chicago, 1970) ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BryanV21 (Post 1046256)
I believe as long as they don't normally show (like when a player just stands straight) then any color is fine. Otherwise, if they normally extend below the bottom of the shorts, they need to be the same basic color of the shorts.

BryanV21: 2017 called and wants their compression shorts back.

Headbands, wristbands, arm sleeves, knee sleeves, lower leg sleeves, compression shorts, and tights, shall be the solid color black, white, beige, or the predominant color of the jersey. All of these items shall be the same color as worn by each player. Additionally, all of these items shall be the same color for all members of a team who choose to wear them. Anything worn on the arm, and/or the leg (except a knee brace), is defined as a sleeve, including knee pads, and elbow pads, and must be the solid color black, white, beige, or the predominant color of the uniform jersey.

Previous to a rule change in 2016-17, compression shorts (tights) had to be the same color as the uniform shorts. Since then, tights (compression shorts) must be black, white, beige, or the predominant color of the jersey, depending on the color of all equipment (not knee braces, not hair control devices) worn by all members of the team.

There are no color restrictions on uniform shorts, they can be all the colors of the rainbow, and can be different colors for different team members, something we often see here in my little corner of Connecticut when junior varsity players play in the subsequent varsity game.

Also, as of 2014-15, there are no longer any rule references to "school colors", but we still have some players, coaches, and, unfortunately, officials that believe that "school color" rules still exist.

https://tse3.mm.bing.net/th?id=OIP.j...=0&w=300&h=300

BillyMac Sun Jan 02, 2022 01:13pm

Length Restrictions ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zoochy (Post 1046255)
Do they need to be the same visual length?

There are no "length restrictions" on any equipment (sans headbands and wristbands) except for undershirt sleeves.

Undershirts must be similar in color to the uniform jersey, and shall not have frayed edges. Undershirt sleeves shall be the same length. Note that this rule does not require all players to wear the same length sleeves on their undershirts, but each individual player must have sleeves the same length on the undershirt when worn.

Below: NFHS: Legal tights (assuming all teammates are wearing black color restricted equipment).

https://bloximages.newyork1.vip.town...size=990%2C808

Mike Goodwin Sun Jan 02, 2022 01:23pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zoochy (Post 1046255)
https://www.stltoday.com/sports/high...539dcb.html#17
See 18th picture. Is anything illegal with #11's tights?

That must be the oversized logo which shall be limited to 2¼ square inches and shall not exceed 2¼ inches in any dimension on any item. (3-6).

Edit: it's #10 Webster Groves' CJ Lang [<- search term] who has the tights with the illegal logo.

BillyMac Sun Jan 02, 2022 01:27pm

Hawk Eye Mike Goodwin ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike Goodwin (Post 1046261)
That must be the oversized logo which shall be limited to 2¼ square inches and shall not exceed 2¼ inches in any dimension on any item. (3-6).

Nice catch Mike Goodwin.

2¼ square inches? That's why I carry a tape measure along with a protractor, a slide rule, and an extra whistle in my pocket.

https://bloximages.newyork1.vip.town...size=990%2C926

BryanV21 Sun Jan 02, 2022 01:28pm

I'm getting old and losing my mind. [emoji17]

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

BillyMac Sun Jan 02, 2022 01:29pm

Old And Losing My Mind ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BryanV21 (Post 1046263)
I'm getting old and losing my mind.

Hey, that's my line.

https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/4oAAA...D72/s-l300.jpg

Zoochy Sun Jan 02, 2022 01:31pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike Goodwin (Post 1046261)
That must be the oversized logo which shall be limited to 2¼ square inches and shall not exceed 2¼ inches in any dimension on any item. (3-6).

Edit: it's #10 Webster Groves' CJ Lang [<- search term] who has the tights with the illegal logo.

He's been wearing those tights all year. :D

BillyMac Sun Jan 02, 2022 01:34pm

Kudos ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zoochy (Post 1046265)
He's been wearing those tights all year.

I'm one of the toughest "Fashion Police" officials that I know, yet I completely missed that violation as I was scrolling through the photos and looking for "fashion" issues.

Kudos to Mike Goodwin.

BillyMac Sun Jan 02, 2022 02:35pm

School Color ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1046259)
... there are no rule references to "school colors", but we still have some players, coaches, and, unfortunately, officials that believe that "school color" rules exist ...

Have there ever been "school color" rules in the rulebook, or is this just another myth passed down from generation to generation by players and coaches as they sit around campfires eating s'mores?

bob jenkins Sun Jan 02, 2022 02:43pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1046268)
Have there ever been "school color" rules in the rulebook, or is this just another myth passed down from generation to generation by players and coaches as they sit around campfires eating s'mores?

2013-14 interps

SITUATION 2: Prior to the start of the game, an official notices that several Team A members are wearing: (a) white wristbands and white headbands; or (b) black arm sleeves and white leg sleeves; or (c) black leg sleeves and white headbands.
RULING: Legal in (a) and (c); illegal in (b). In (a), wristbands and headbands shall be white, black, beige or a single solid school color and shall be the same for each item for all participants. In (b) illegal, the arm and leg sleeves shall be white, black, beige or a single solid school color and the same color for each team member. In (c), the rules do not require wristbands, headbands, arm and leg sleeves to all be the same color. (3-5-3, 3-5-4a)

SITUATION 3: The announcer announces (a) who scores (b) who fouls, (c) time left in the quarter.
RULING: Legal in (a) and (b); illegal in (c). In (a) and (b), the announcer is allowed to give basic information during the course of the game, such as who the foul is on, who is shooting free throws, which team is taking a time-out and the length of the time-out. In (c), announcing the amount of time left in the quarter is not information that should be given since there is a visible clock for all to see. There is no penalty. The announcer should be handled in the same manner as a scorekeeper or timer who are not in compliance with the spirit of the game. Appropriate training by school personnel and proper pregame instructions by the referee are necessary. (1-18)

SITUATION 4: Player A1 wears a red arm sleeve and his/her teammate, Player A2, wears a black leg sleeve.
RULING: Illegal. If worn, the leg and arm sleeves shall be white, black, beige or a single solid school color and the same for each team member. (3-5-3)

Mike Goodwin Sun Jan 02, 2022 03:01pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1046266)
I'm one of the toughest "Fashion Police" officials that I know, yet I completely missed that violation as I was scrolling through the photos.

I might have overlooked if I hadn't had to count photos while scrolling through. That's nearly a practical joke, Zooch!

BillyMac Sun Jan 02, 2022 03:09pm

Always Listen To bob ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 1046270)
2013-14 interps

SITUATION 2: Prior to the start of the game, an official notices that several Team A members are wearing: (a) white wristbands and white headbands; or (b) black arm sleeves and white leg sleeves; or (c) black leg sleeves and white headbands. RULING: Legal in (a) and (c); illegal in (b). In (a), wristbands and headbands shall be white, black, beige or a single solid school color and shall be the same for each item for all participants. In (b) illegal, the arm and leg sleeves shall be white, black, beige or a single solid school color and the same color for each team member. In (c), the rules do not require wristbands, headbands, arm and leg sleeves to all be the same color. (3-5-3, 3-5-4a)

SITUATION 4: Player A1 wears a red arm sleeve and his/her teammate, Player A2, wears a black leg sleeve.
RULING: Illegal. If worn, the leg and arm sleeves shall be white, black, beige or a single solid school color and the same for each team member. (3-5-3)

Thanks bob jenkins. 2013-14 was the last we heard about "school colors".

2013-14: 3-5-4-A: Wristbands and headwear must meet the following guidelines: Headbands and wristbands must be white, black, beige or a single solid school color and must be the same color for each item and all participants.

2014-15: 3-5-4-A: Wristbands and headwear must meet the following guidelines: Headbands and wristbands must be white, black, beige or the predominant color of the jersey and must be the same color for each item and all participants.

BillyMac Sun Jan 02, 2022 03:16pm

Same Color ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 1046270)
2013-14 interps: SITUATION 2: Prior to the start of the game, an official notices that several Team A members are wearing: (c) black leg sleeves and white headbands. RULING: Legal in (c); In (c), the rules do not require wristbands, headbands, arm and leg sleeves to all be the same color. (3-5-3, 3-5-4a)

I had forgotten that this (above) was legal only eight years ago.

Nice of the NFHS to simply the color restrictions. I wish that they would simply them a little bit more. I would not be adverse to ignoring all colors from the waist down.

Color restrictions above the waist? I can take them, or leave them, as long as the NFHS keeps the color restrictions for undershirts.

BillyMac Sun Jan 02, 2022 03:27pm

Undershirt Colors ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1046273)
I would not be adverse to ignoring all colors from the waist down. Color restrictions above the waist? I can take them, or leave them, as long as the NFHS keeps the color restrictions for undershirts.

This is my story and I'm sticking to it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1037388)
By custom, in my little corner of Connecticut, we allow illegal undershirts in scrimmages. I've worked preseason jamboree type scrimmages where players from several teams wear reversible practice jerseys (for some reason Connecticut frowns upon real jerseys being worn in scrimmages) and reverse their jerseys (but not their undershirts) depending on which teams are participating that period. Based on those scrimmage experiences over forty years, I can tell you with 100% certainty that undershirt colors not matching jerseys, different color undershirts on teammates, and different color undershirts on opponents, can turn easy calls into slightly more difficult calls, especially during rebounding action, both for out of bounds, and for fouls.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 994118)
I just got back from a girls scrimmage, three girls teams, all wearing reversible scrimmage vests, almost all wearing a T-shirt under their scrimmage vests, almost all white T-shirts, although there were several other colors thrown in. I'm the trail, ball goes out of bounds off the defense on my sideline. I sound my whistle, point in the correct direction, and state "White". But it wasn't white ball. It was blue ball. Why did I screw up? Because we had three teams, all with a choice of two color reversible scrimmage vests, playing alternating periods, all with mostly white T-shirts. The closest girl to me for the team that was supposed to get the ball was wearing a blue scrimmage vest, but there was a lot of white showing from underneath, two sleeves, and quite a bit of white showing from under the scoop top of the vest. I noticed that I really had to pay close attention to who was on offense, and who was on defense. Who was setting screens, and who was in the paint too long? Who was pushing who while battling for rebounds? This game is a little easier to officiate when the players are wearing the correct color undershirts.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1029675)
Green jerseys and white jerseys. Lots of different undershirt colors, some legal. Instructed coaches to get it fixed (allowed light gray for white). Both coaches complain ("only middle school, we never did this before", I actually believed them) and they go to instruct their players. I can see that a few players (remember it's girls) on both teams seem be very upset. So, I call both coaches back together and say that I would be willing to compromise and that if any players were very upset they could wear the illegal undershirts ... Fourth period, partner on endline after whistle. I'm closer to the table and beckon in substitutes, lots of them, two, or three from each team. I keep my hand up until I'm sure that we have five players from each team on the court. I then realize that players on the "White Jersey Team" have both green shorts and white shorts, and the players on the "Green Jersey Team" have on both green shorts and white shorts (it's now very obvious to me that both school have the same school colors, green and white), certainly all 100% perfectly legal. But players on the "White Jersey Team" have both green undershirts and white undershirts, and the players on the "Green Jersey Team" have on both green undershirts and white undershirts. I try to count twice, still not 100% sure, now totally exasperated, near the end of my rope, and close to the breaking point, I bring my hand down and yell to my partner, "Play".


BillyMac Sun Jan 02, 2022 03:52pm

Hard Work Or Hardly Working ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike Goodwin (Post 1046271)
I might have overlooked if I hadn't had to count photos while scrolling through. That's nearly a practical joke, Zooch!

Yeah. Why did Zoochy make us work so hard?

Not funny Zoochy!

Zoochy Mon Jan 03, 2022 11:38am

This post went out of control fast.
I still don't have a consensus on the ruling if a player is wearing different length leg tights.
Legal? or Illegal?

bob jenkins Mon Jan 03, 2022 11:55am

NCAAW:
A.R. 14. A1 is wearing tights that extend below the game shorts. The left leg is
longer than the right leg.
RULING: Illegal. Similar to an undershirt, both legs must be the
same length. A1 may not participate until they are properly attired.
(Rule 1-23.2)

BillyMac Mon Jan 03, 2022 12:10pm

Tights ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zoochy (Post 1046284)
I still don't have a consensus on the ruling if a player is wearing different length leg tights. Legal? or Illegal?

Asked and answered.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1046260)
Legal tights ... There are no "length restrictions" on any equipment (sans headbands and wristbands) except for undershirt sleeves.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 1046285)
NCAAW: A.R. 14. A1 is wearing tights that extend below the game shorts. The left leg is longer than the right leg. RULING: Illegal. Similar to an undershirt, both legs must be the same length. A1 may not participate until they are properly attired.(Rule 1-23.2)

As far as I know, the NFHS does not have the same length restrictions and limitations on tights as NCAA-W.

NFHS: 3-5-3: Arm sleeves, knee sleeves, lower leg sleeves, compression shorts and tights are permissible:
a. Anything worn on the arm and/or leg is a sleeve, except a knee brace, and must meet the color restrictions.
b. The sleeves/tights, compression shorts must be black, white, beige or the predominant color of the jersey and the same color sleeves/tights must be worn by teammates.
c. All sleeves/tights, compression shorts must be the same solid color and must be the same color as any headband or wristband worn.
d. Meet the logo requirements in 3-6.

Raymond Mon Jan 03, 2022 12:17pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 1046285)
NCAAW:
A.R. 14. A1 is wearing tights that extend below the game shorts. The left leg is
longer than the right leg.
RULING: Illegal. Similar to an undershirt, both legs must be the
same length. A1 may not participate until they are properly attired.
(Rule 1-23.2)

Same for Men.

BillyMac Mon Jan 03, 2022 12:24pm

Rule Language
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Raymond (Post 1046288)
Same for Men.

Makes we wonder if the NFHS has a similar purpose and intent, but has not published any corresponding rule language?

Sign of things to come?

BillyMac Mon Jan 03, 2022 12:36pm

Thigh Sleeve ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 1046285)
NCAAW ...

Makes me wonder.

How does a college official determine the difference between tights (with their specific restrictions) and thigh sleeves, as worn for hamstring injuries (with their specific restrictions)?

No way am I asking a young woman if "those" are tights or sleeves.

https://www.thatawesomeshirt.com/ima...t/223/430x550/

Raymond Mon Jan 03, 2022 01:04pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1046290)
Makes me wonder.

How does a college official determine the difference between tights (with their specific restrictions) and thigh sleeves (as worn for hamstring injuries)?

No way am I asking a young woman if those are tights or sleeves.

If I see a garment well below the shorts on one leg and something barely peeking out the on the other leg, I don't ask. I go to the player and tell them "Your tights have to be worn the same length on each leg." If they have only a single sleeve, they will tell us such. If the have a tight pulled up on one leg, they fix it. Don't think I've yet met a player clever enough to say one leg is a sleeve and the other is just showing the bottom of their compression shorts.

JRutledge Mon Jan 03, 2022 01:33pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raymond (Post 1046291)
If I see a garment well below the shorts on one leg and something barely peeking out the on the other leg, I don't ask. I go to the player and tell them "Your tights have to be worn the same length on each leg." If they have only a single sleeve, they will tell us such. If the have a tight pulled up on one leg, they fix it. Don't think I've yet met a player clever enough to say one leg is a sleeve and the other is just showing the bottom of their compression shorts.

I ask, "Do those tights have a waistband?" That usually starts the conversation and we get to the bottom of the situation. If they show me it is a tight, then they are allowed to wear them. If they show me it is an undergarment, then I tell them they cannot play with them. Then usually address it with the coach and let them deal with it.

Peace

BillyMac Mon Jan 03, 2022 01:34pm

Thinking Facetiously Out Loud ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Raymond (Post 1046291)
If I see a garment ...

Thanks Raymond. As someone will never officiate a college basketball game, I was actually thinking facetiously out loud. But I guess that it really does require some thought. I do appreciate your sincere reply. Maybe someday it will be a NFHS rule, and I'll be ready for such situations.

BillyMac Mon Jan 03, 2022 01:38pm

A Real Thing ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 1046292)
I ask, "Do those tights have a waistband?" That usually starts the conversation ...

Thanks JRutledge. Wow! Another college conversation I don't have to have in my high school game. I was only joking and it turned out to be a real "thing".

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1046293)
Maybe someday it will be a NFHS rule, and I'll be ready for such situations.


BillyMac Mon Jan 03, 2022 01:41pm

No Pun Intended, Or Pun Intended ..
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 1046292)
... we get to the bottom of the situation.

I'm not sure. Is this a pun?

JRutledge is usually so serious on the Forum. A pun like this would be so unlike his usual presence on the Forum.

Pun, or not, this is one of his funniest posts ever.

BillyMac Mon Jan 03, 2022 01:47pm

Me Too ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1046290)
No way am I asking a young woman if "those" are tights or sleeves.

Sixteen will get you twenty.

JRutledge Mon Jan 03, 2022 03:45pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1046295)
I'm not sure. Is this a pun?

JRutledge is usually so serious on the Forum. A pun like this would be so unlike his usual presence on the Forum.

Pun, or not, this is one of his funniest posts ever.

I am actually rather sarcastic a lot. Most of the time because that is what I do.

Peace

Nevadaref Mon Jan 03, 2022 10:54pm

There is also a photo of De Smet #1 (white uniform) in which he has his waistband rolled revealing multiple manufacturer’s logos (the Under Armour logo). The rolling of the waistband is permitted, but not the showing of multiple logos.

BillyMac Tue Jan 04, 2022 09:42am

Multiple Logos ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nevadaref (Post 1046298)
There is also a photo of De Smet #1 (white uniform) in which he has his waistband rolled revealing multiple manufacturer’s logos (the Under Armour logo). The rolling of the waistband is permitted, but not the showing of multiple logos.

3-4-5: Uniform pants/skirts must have only one visible manufacturer’s logo/trademark/reference. See 3-6-2 for size requirements. Showing multiple manufacturer’s logos on the waist band of the pants/skirts makes the item illegal.

3-5-5-Note: Equipment and apparel must not be modified from the original manufactured state and must be worn in the manner the manufacturer intended it to be worn. Provided the shorts are not in conflict with Rule 3-4-5, no drawstring or other part of the shorts intended to maintain them in a normal position causes potential harm to the player or others and wearing of the shorts is not objectionable in exposing the anatomy, there is not restriction on folding or rolling the shorts at the natural waistband seam.


https://bloximages.newyork1.vip.town...size=990%2C845

Zoochy Tue Jan 04, 2022 01:27pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1046299)
3-4-5: Uniform pants/skirts must have only one visible manufacturer’s logo/trademark/reference. See 3-6-2 for size requirements. Showing multiple manufacturer’s logos on the waist band of the pants/skirts makes the item illegal.

3-5-5-Note: Equipment and apparel must not be modified from the original manufactured state and must be worn in the manner the manufacturer intended it to be worn. Provided the shorts are not in conflict with Rule 3-4-5, no drawstring or other part of the shorts intended to maintain them in a normal position causes potential harm to the player or others and wearing of the shorts is not objectionable in exposing the anatomy, there is not restriction on folding or rolling the shorts at the natural waistband seam.


https://bloximages.newyork1.vip.town...size=990%2C845

BillyMac, you missed a second uniform violation. Not only are there multiple manufacture logo's on the waistband, there is also a manufacture logo on the shorts.

Raymond Tue Jan 04, 2022 01:37pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zoochy (Post 1046317)
BillyMac, you missed a second uniform violation. Not only are there multiple manufacture logo's on the waistband, there is also a manufacture logo on the shorts.

The waistband is part of the shorts, so that's still one uniform violation--multiple manufacturer's logos on the shorts. If he rolled the waistband one more time, then there would be one visible and he would be legal.

BillyMac Tue Jan 04, 2022 01:40pm

Show Me Zoochy ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zoochy (Post 1046317)
BillyMac, you missed a second uniform violation. Not only are there multiple manufacture logo's on the waistband, there is also a manufacture logo on the shorts.

Is Zoochy saying that there are three logos visible on the "pants" in this photo?

And that a single visible logo on the waistband of the pants and single visible logo on the leg of the pants would also be illegal?

3-4-5: Uniform pants/skirts must have only one visible manufacturer’s logo/trademark/reference. See 3-6-2 for size requirements. Showing multiple manufacturer’s logos on the waist band of the pants/skirts makes the item illegal.

https://tse3.mm.bing.net/th?id=OIP.m...=0&w=172&h=162


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:21am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1